I didn't see the graduation episode but I know that Quinn and Puck end up together (which is stupid because was really into Joe for half the season... whatever) so I decided to write this. Thanks to ImaginetheWorldWicked (MEH not ALJ) for beta-ing this. I don't own Glee.
Sam POV
"Why did you take me back?" Quinn asked.
"Because I love you."
"But I'm so unlovable. I mean—" I cut her off with a kiss.
"Shut up. You're perfect."
"What about Puck?"
"He doesn't have to know."
"He's your best friend."
"He's using you."
"How so?"
"I heard him talking to Finn. He said he calls all girls whose boobs are still growing. He's using you for sex," I explained to her. She laughed.
"I'm not having sex with him," she paused for a second "Only you." She whispered into my ear.
"How many times have you had sex?"
"My first time with Puck and the other times with you during our relationship." She put quotes around the word relationship. "You seem too nice for a secret relationship."
"I was shocked when you tried to make a pass at me but I couldn't let an opportunity like this pass. I love you too much."
"You're so sweet," she said "And hot," she added as she ran her hands over my abs. Shit. She grabbed my hand and pulled me into her room. She pushed me onto her bed. She climbed on top of me.
"I have a confession," I blurted out.
"Really? Now?"
"I didn't have sex when I was a stripper." She smirked.
"I knew it."
"What do you mean?"
"You're too good of a Christian to have sex with someone you don't love. I knew I was your first. The fact that you gave it to me shows me you really love me."
"If I'm such a good Christian then why am I committing the sin of adultery?"
"Because you love me. I have a confession too. You're the only boy I ever loved."
"I'm offended," I joked. "I'm not a boy, I'm a man."
"No. You're my man."
"Your man still feels bad about going behind Puck's back to be with you."
"Puck doesn't love me, but you do."
Will update once I get 4 good reviews