Verse 1: Sam
*Sam walks onto the stage slowly, looking sad and full of regret*
Why couldn't I just agree?
To stay away from that Ruby?
Demon blood turned me bad
And even though poor Dean had
Told me to leave all of it be
I went ahead, now Satan's free
Chorus: Sam
Right now I must admit
Now that I have the chance to say
Dean told me not to do it
But I did it anyway
Oh I wish I had just listened
To his apparent dissatisfaction
And now we're being stricken
By the consequences of my action
Verse 2: Castiel
*the stage darkens, and a spotlight appears on Castiel, who is gracefully descending onto the stage*
My brothers and my sisters
Turned out to be truth-twisters
He had told me all along
And as it turned out, I was wrong
By the time I did rebel
Lucifer was freed from hell
Chorus: Sam and Castiel
*Sam and Cas are back-to-back with separate spotlights, both looking into the distance with their eyes shining with the regret of their stupid decisions*
Right now I must admit
Now that I have the chance to say
Dean told me not to do it
But I did it anyway
Oh I wish I had just listened
To his apparent dissatisfaction
And now we're being stricken
By the consequences of my action
Bridge:
*Castiel's spotlight turns off, leaving Sam's*
[SAM]You would think we'd have learned by now
*spotlight switches to Cas*
[CAS]To not ignore ol' squirrel's scowl
*both spotlights are on, and another turns on, highlighting Dean*
[DEAN]If they had just listened to me
I wouldn't have to tidy their debris
But they didn't seem to see
The simple philosophy
I know we all make some mistakes
But how much does it really take?
So stop it for God's sake
And let's all hope it's not too late
Verse 3: Sam
*spotlight focuses on Sam*
I was determined to make
Up for all of my mistakes
My only goal at this stage
Was to get Satan in his cage
I jumped with him into the hole
But was brought back without a soul
Verse 4: Castiel
*spotlight switches to Cas*
Now with Satan in The Pit
Heaven had turned to shit
I made a deal with Crowley
To eat the souls in Purgatory
But it wasn't a good plan
And I let out the Leviathans
Chorus: Sam and Castiel
*both Sam and Castiel's spotlights are on as they sing together*
Right now we must admit
Now that we have the chance to say
Dean told us not to do it
But we did it anyway
Oh we wish we had just listened
To his apparent dissatisfaction
And now we're being stricken
By the consequences of our actions
Verse 5: Sam
*Sam starts singing, but all the spotlights stay on*
Well one thing led to another
The Mark of Cain got on my brother
I teamed up with Charlie and Castiel
And Crowley's mom, the witch, as well
Poor Charlie's life was ceased
And The Darkness was unleashed
Chorus: Everyone
*every spotlight stays on, Sam and Cas starts singing*
Right now we must admit
Now that we have the chance to say
Dean told us not to do it
But we did it anyway
*Dean finishes the song*
Oh I wish you had just listened
To my apparent dissatisfaction
And now we're being stricken
By the consequences of your actions
THE END