I do not own Pretty Little Liars

See You Tonight

Spencer (POV) Cafeteria

"Hey guys!" Emily says sitting down at the table.

"Hey Em! Whats up?" I ask taking a bite out of my salad.

"I just met the new movers today."

"Whats their names?" Aria asks.

"They have a son and a daughter. Toby and Jenna Cavanaugh."

"Cavanaugh?" Alison asks suddenly interested in what Emily has to say.

"Yeah Cavanaugh, Why?"

"Nothing, I think I know Toby from somewhere."

"Well there he is." Emily says pointing at Toby laughing with Noel Kahn, Caleb Rivers, Ezra Fitz, and Jason Hastings.

"Well Toby is already friends with our boyfriends. Check that out Aria." Hanna says amazed.

"Yeah and Spencer's brother." Aria adds.

"Im guessing Toby plays football." Spencer says unamused.

"You know Emily, if you and Noel got together, you would probably make a cute couple."

"Seriously Ar? Me and Noel Kahn?"

"What? Spencer and Toby would also make a cute couple. We hang out all the time anyways with the guys."

"Toby is kind of cute." Spencer says in a daze and the girls snicker as she stares at Toby.

Alison's eyes widened in surprise. "Ali, whats wrong?" Hanna asked noticing her discomfort.

"Its Toby Cavanaugh." Alison said stating the obvious.

"I know, Em just said its Toby Cavanaugh. Whats wrong?"

"He was the school player back in my old town. He always tried to get into a girls pants including mine just not very successfully."

"Im intrigued. Tell us more." Hanna said. She's changed this past summer. She turned skinny and more gossipy if thats even a word.

"He always just hits on pretty girls and never actually cared for them. He only used them to get into their pants. When he's got what he wanted the girl gets no calls, no texts, no nothing and it just gets awkward when she sees him at school with another girl." Alison says looking like she's in a trance.

"He sounds like an asshole." I say pulling her out of her trance.

"He is an asshole. He even tried to hit on me, I was just lucky enough to have a friend tell me about his plans."

Cafeteria : Toby (POV)

"So this is the cafeteria. You have the nerds sit over there." He says pointing at their table. I should have guessed. I don't think normal people bring science textbooks to lunch. "You have the popular girls over there." He says pointing at a table with Alison DiLaurentis. Surprise, surprise. "Everyone else and then we sit here." He says pointing at everyone else's table before sitting at his own.

"Do you think its too late to try out for football?" I ask out of the blue.

"No I don't think so. I'll ask coach if you can try out if you want to try out." Noel says before a couple of guys sat down at the table.

"Whose this?" A guy with dirty blonde hair asks holding his hand out to me.

"Toby Cavanaugh." I say as nicely as possible. I didn't want to be rude.

"Jason Hastings."

"Caleb Rivers." I shake his hand as well as the next guy.

"Ezra Fitz."

"You guys all play football?" I ask out of curiosity.

"Pretty much." Jason says taking a bite out of his lunch.

"Should I know anything about this school? Possibly like girls I shouldn't go near or any teachers I shouldn't cross?"

"Just stay away from my girlfriend Aria. She's the cute short girl over there at the popular table. Did I mention she's cute and pretty and beautiful?" I laugh as he stares at her.

"Stay away from the hot blonde at the popular table." Caleb says pointing at the "Hot Blonde" at the popular table.

"As for me just paws off of Emily Fields, okay?" Noel says looking at me.

"Okay. She's actually my neighbor. You like have a crush on her or something?"

"He loves her." Jason says putting emphasize when he said the word love.

"No I don't. I just care, okay." We all laugh at him.

"Got it." I say and continue to eat my lunch.

French Class : Toby (POV)

I have always wanted to take french class. I got in early because I'm the new kid and the classroom wasn't as far from my locker. While I was sitting in class a very beautiful girl walks in. I think I just saw the most hottest girl I have ever seen in my life. I couldn't find the right words to describe her. Her curly brown hair flowed down her shoulders and every step she took towards me made me drool just by looking at her long stunning legs. Wait, she's coming towards me.

I gave her my sexy, flirtatious, charming smile welcoming her as she sits down in the seat right next to me. Class was about to start and the french teacher started talking. I was in the second row of seats so I couldn't talk to the beauty sitting down next to me. All I knew was she was going to have to be mine.

We had an extra ten minutes before we have to get to our next class and Mr. Leroy let us talk amongst ourselves. This is my chance to make a good first impression. Don't ruin this. You just have to show her your irresistible charms. I mean I have a face most girls just can't resist, Right? I just hope she's not friends with Alison DiLaurentis. I saw her today in school and she was not happy.

*FlashBack*

"What are you doing here?" Alison asks me angry.

"My dad decided to move here." I say looking down at her.

"You know you have some nerve to actually stay here. I can ruin you just like I did before."

"They're all just lies, Alison. Its your fault everyone at school thinks I'm some player."

"Toby you are just some player. First your with me and then your apparently falling in love with some other girl." She says disgusted.

"I never wanted to be with you. And that other girl told me she wanted a guy who can stay committed but she doesn't believe me and its all your fault. You even made everyone believe I broke your heart!"

"I just told her what needed to be said." And with that said she stormed away angry and she seemed to be hurt.

*End Of FlashBack*

"Hey, Your Spencer right?" I ask tapping her shoulder to get her attention and I get a nod back in return.

I put my arm around her shoulder pulling her in. "Did you know you're so beautiful that you made me forget my pick up line? And did you also know that if being sexy was a crime, you'd be guilty as charged?" I flirt with her not really caring if people are staring which I hope they aren't.

"Hmm. I wonder how many times you've used that one." She says but failing in trying to take my arm off her shoulder.

"I only used it once and it was on you, babe." I smile at her and she smiles back about to lean in for what seems like a kiss. I so nailed it when it came to flirting with her. And before I knew it she elbowed me in the ribs, hard. I take my arm off of her rubbing my ribs and she smiles down at me after standing up about to leave the classroom.

"Did you know that I'm not that easy to get, Cavanaugh?" She walks away in victory. Im about to leave when somebody walks up to me. I recognize him as one of Noels best friends.

"Hey dude! Spencer Hastings, Really?" Caleb Rivers asked amused.

"She's hot." I say getting my things and walking out of the classroom with him.

"She's cute but, Im going out with her best friend Hanna Marin."

"She just elbowed my ribs. That surprisingly turns me on." He snickers.

"Well Me, Noel, and Ezra are all meeting at Jason's tonight after school to play some video games and practice if you wanna come."

"I don't know where Jason lives."

"Did you know Jason is Spencer's older brother?"

"Your joking right?"

"Nope."

"I think I would love to come over. Whats the address?" Caleb smiles handing over the address and heading off to his next class. I do the same heading off to Chemistry. I walk in and smirk. Ms Hastings, my french partner and chemistry partner. Great. She turns me on but hits like a fighter. I rub my ribs before sitting down next to her. After that I know Im going to have to make her mine when she rolls her eyes at me.

Class went by really slow and I can never seem to pay attention. My eyes glued to the brunette sitting next to me. Toby, your supposed to be mad at her for the rest of the day. Im going to have to make her mine someday. Wow. Alison was right. I have the mind of a player but not all the time. I'm a guy. Its not like I do one night stands.

Spencer is just different. A good different. She's the first person I met who was able to resist my undeniable good looks and charms. Okay, so Im cocky too. The bell rings signaling that the day is over and we can finally go home or in my case her house to play video games and practice some football.

I walk out of the classroom and go to Spencer's locker just to bother her so I run up to her and block her from going to her locker.

"Get off my locker!"

"Not until you ask nicely."

"Im sorry. Can you please move your annoying self off my locker?" I get off her locker but don't go just yet.

"I seem to have lost my number. Can I have yours?"

"Do you want to get elbowed again?" I roll my eyes and walk away. I walk up to my buddy Noel who happens to be my locker buddy as well as Caleb, Ezra, and Jason. I didn't even know their lockers were that close to mine.

"What were you doing with my sister?" Jason asked.

"He was trying to flirt with her in french class and failed miserably. She elbowed him right in the ribs." Caleb laughs and Noel, Ezra and Jason does too. I slam my head inside my locker embarrassed about that.

Jason snickers. "That sounds like my sister. For the record if you hurt her your a dead man, Toby." I gulp as he smiles. "You coming over to play video games right?"

"Yeah sure. Caleb gave me the address."

"Awe, Does wittle Toby have a wittle crush on Spencer?" Noel asks mocking me and I groan annoyed.

"If you want you could ask Spencer if you can take her home. I wouldn't mind." Jason smiles and I look at him questioningly.

"Come on dude. Ask her she might say yes." Ezra encourages me hiding or trying to control his laughter.

"She's going to elbow me again." I groan and Noel just pushes me to her making me slam my body to the locker next to hers. I glare at them but ask anyways. I can see them all laughing.

"Do you always get caught on lockers?"

"Yeah, Im like a magnet. I attract lockers and beautiful girls." I smile.

"What do you want?" She spat at me.

"I was wondering if you wanted a ride home?" I ask nervously sending glares at the guys every chance I get.

"I elbowed you in the ribs and you still can't get the message?" She rolls her eyes but none the less elbows me anyways causing me to shriek in pain. That was harder than last time. I heard the guys burst out laughing.

"What? I can't take a pretty girl like you home?" I sigh face palming. "That sounded a whole lot better in my head." She rolls her eyes and closes her locker while she passes me I make a comment. "See you tonight!"

"Tonight? Where? In you dreams?"

"No actually in my bedroom." I slap her butt walking pass her in victory and I could feel her glaring at me from behind. I walk up to the guys and they laugh at me.

"Nice one dude! But Spencer is going to murder you." Jason says laughing.

"Your not mad?"

"Oh Im mad but that was funny as hell."

"She still elbowed me though." They burst out laughing and I roll my eyes rubbing my ribs.

"Bye Tobes! See you at Jason's tonight!" Noel patted my back and we all parted ways. I was walking to my car when I bumped into Aria. She was Ezra's girlfriend. She really was short. Or as I learned in french today "Petite."

"Hi! Your Toby, Right?"

"Yeah and you must be Aria." She looks at me questioningly. "Ezra."

"What are you doing to Spencer?" She asks while walking with me to my car.

"Nothing."

"I saw you smack her butt and besides she's my best friend. She told me you tried flirting with her and failed miserably. Ezra said the same." She laughs and I groan. That happened barely five minutes ago. How did she find out so quickly?

"Is that all?"

"Alison also told us what you do to girls."

"What she tell you?" I sigh.

"The fact that you used girls for your own sick little game. Oh and that your a player."

"I don't use girls and I'm not a player like she says I am."

"How do I know your not just lying?"

"How do you know Alison is not lying? I never used girls. Alison had a way of making people think that because I broke up with her only because I didn't want to be more than friends." I shrug.

"Wait, Alison liked you as more than a friend?" I nod. "She said you tried hitting on her and tried getting into her pants."

"Thats funny because I think it was her trying to force me into wanting me to get into her pants. That didn't make sense, did it?"

"Nope, but why would Alison lie about this?"

"She probably didn't want anybody making fun of her for getting friend zoned." I smirk and get in my car. "It was nice talking to you Aria. I'll see you tomorrow!" I say and drive off. I find the adress Caleb gave me to Jason's house and set it on my GPS device before telling my dad that I'm going over a friends house. This is going to be a fun night.

So how was that? Did it suck? I was trying to make a sequel for "Will You Be My Valentine?" and this story idea came to mind. This is AU obviously if Jason is apparently a Hastings… Check out my other story 17 Years Later if you want. No? Don't want to? Okay… Ezra Fitz is in fact in high school and so is Jason and they are all the same age well except Jason hes like a year older. Anyways I'll probably post the next chapter Monday or Tuesday? Im not sure. Review maybe? Hope you enjoyed this! -ThatKidFromSchool :)