I do not own Glee or any of the characters.
Finn was coming over any minute. Everything had to be perfect.
Rachel Barry rushed to do some last minute organizing before she was interrupted by a knock on her door. She tossed her hair and patted the wrinkles out of her clothes, before she opened the door.
"Finn! Come in!" she said happily as she closed the door behind him
Finn stepped through the door, an apologetic smile on his face.
"Sorry I'm late, I just needed to help Quinn-"
The smile dropped off her face. "Quinn." She said quietly. "Quinn." She walked over and sat on the couch.
"I thought that you and Quinn weren't…friends anymore", said Rachel with anger and annoyance seeping through her cheerful façade.
"We aren't! We aren't!" said Finn quickly "She uh- she needed some help with her- um Spanish homework."
"Why would she go to you? You're failing Spanish. I'm sure Mr. Schuster would have been happy to help her. "
"She- she needed some notes, and I was there…. So…" Finn said softly. "I swear, there is nothing going on between Quinn and me."
Rachel stood up and charged towards Finn until they were face to face.
"Finn, I swear to god, if you're cheating on me with that-"
"Rachel!" he said pulling her into his chest, "there's nothing going on."
"Fine then." She said as she wrestled herself out of his embrace. "Give me your phone."
"What? No!" Finn said as he stepped back. "Don't you trust me?
"Give me the phone." Rachel said through bared teeth.
"No!" Finn shouted, "I'm sick of you being so freaking overprotective and jealous all the time! You're seriously starting to piss me off!"
She slapped him across the face
He held his face in his hands, "You crazy bi-"he began before she pushed him into the door.
"What the hell Rachel! Why are you acting like this?" he said
"SHUT UP!" She screamed
Finn glared at her and then touched his head, which was bleeding.
"Now look what you've done! God!" he said as he went to the kitchen to get a paper towel.
"Come back here!" she screeched as she followed him.
"You know what?" Finn said once they were in the kitchen. "You're insane Rachel. You seriously need some help!"
"I don't care I don't care I don't care!" she screamed "Just tell me." She looked at him with crazed eyes. "Are you cheating on me with Quinn?"
Finn laughed sarcastically. "What's there to lose?" he said as he through his arms up in the air. "I have been cheating on you with Quinn, and you know what? I love it! To be honest, I don't even know why I'm still with you Rachel! I should have dumped your crazy ass a long time ago to be with her!"
"Take it back." Rachel said in a low voice. Finn just laughed. "Take it back you bastard!" she screamed as she took a knife out of the drawer.
Finn widened his eyes and took a couple steps back. "Whoa! Rachel calm down!"
"No! I won't calm down until you take back what you said about being with that whore!" she said shaking her head furiously.
"Rachel, you're not thinking straight, just but the knife down." Finn said cautiously as he took a few steps forward, and then tried to grab the knife from her hand.
"Say it's not true." She said as tears began to form in her eyes as Finn looked away. "Say it's not true!" she bawled.
"I'm sorry Rachel." Finn said. "It wasn't supposed to end this way." He said as he turned around and headed for the front door.
Rachel screamed, and lunged forward, stabbing him in the neck.
"It's not true! It's not true! It's not true!" she said as punctuated every word with a stab. His body dropped to the ground, and she stepped back.
"Finn?" she said softly. She bent over and rolled him on his back. He's eyes were open as if he were frozen. She gasped loudly and quickly crawled away from the body.
"Oh god." She said quietly before she burst into tears. What had she done?
Thanks for reading! I'm thinking of turning this into a little murder mystery story, but I'm not sure…. I didn't really think this out… oops:) Leave a comment telling me what you think! Hoped you liked it!