The Seed that Shouldn't

"Tell Jill, I'm sorry."

"I mean, for f*ck's sake, my own mother had to die, no great loss there, so that I could stay true to the original."

"What's closer then family, the bond of blood?"

Did anyone ever wonder why these were said? I thought Kate was a good mother, so what was Kate sorry about? Why did Jill seem to hate Kate so much? And finally, why did Jill's hatred for Sidney seem more personal then she let on? Here's my theory.


What if Stu and Tatum had a baby before all of the murders? What if they didn't know what to do, if they were scared and left the baby on a doorstep? What if that doorstep turned out to be Kate Roberts and she took the baby in? And what if Tatum and Stu weren't really dead? Confused? I would be surprised if you weren't so let me explain.

A long time ago in a galaxy far, far away.

No, I'm just shiting with you but seriously…

About 15 years ago in a small town called Woodsboro…


(15 years ago)

Stu Macher was lying on the ground with a TV on his head when he suddenly moves and, after freaking out for a couple of seconds, lifted the TV off his head to show several bleeding cuts on his face before he got up and quickly stumbled to the garage to get out of the house but faltered when he saw Tatum's body hanging from the garage pet door.

"Shit, Tate." Stu cursed, it finally hitting him that Tatum really was dead- wait what was that? Did her feet just move?

"Tatum?" He called, hopeful and Tatum groaned, waking up and Stu quickly ran-stumbled- over to her and pulled her down and they disappeared and wouldn't be seen again for 15 years.


(12 years later)

A fourteen year old Jill 'Roberts' is having dinner with the woman she thought was her mother.

"Jill, I'm sorry. I have bad news, sweetie. I'm… I'm not your real mother. You got put on my doorstep as a baby." Kate told Jill who looked at Kate like she was Freddy Krueger

"Why didn't you tell before now!? Don't you think I deserved to know!? How could you not tell me!?" Jill all but screamed at her

"Jill, I am so sorry, I-" Kate started only to get cut off by Jill, who grabbed a knife and held it against Kate's throat

"No, I don't want to hear it! I don't want to hear your lame excuse or your lame apology about why you waited FOURTEEN YEARS to tell me the truth. All I want from you is to know if you know who they are and why they left me with you?" Jill told her

"I don't know who they are or why they left you but Jill-" Kate didn't get the chance to finish because Jill had already slammed the knife into the table and stormed out of the room, slamming her bedroom door so hard that a picture in the hall of Kate and Jill fell from its hook and cracked… right down the middle, separating them… forever.


(Present Time)

Charlie walked down the stairs to see all the lights off, the TV not working and the only thing to show that Robbie had in fact been there was the phone found on the floor

"Lights out, phone on the floor. You know you really could direct horror films!" Charlie called out, jumping when the house phone rang.

"Perfect timing but you don't have the app so you can't talk like Ghostface, can you?" He asked, answering the phone, tensing up when the Ghostface voice answered. He knew Robbie didn't have the app, he thought it was stupid. So if this wasn't Robbie… then who was it and the more important question… where was Robbie?

"Who is this?" He asked the person

"Not an app." Ghostface answered making Charlie falter. How did this person hear that? He had answered the phone after he said that. Charlie looked around the house but didn't see anything or anybody… not even Robbie.

"Who is this!?" Charlie asked again, slightly fearful

"Think of me as your director, you're in my movie, you've got a fun part so don't blow it." Ghostface told him

"Screw you, asshole! What did you do to Robbie?" Charlie exclaimed, slightly scared and, even though he knew he shouldn't be, excited. He was basically in Stab, it was so freaking cool.

"He's on the cutting room floor." Ghostface quipped

"That wasn't funny." Charlie said

"No shit, dumbass! This isn't a comedy, it's a horror film. People live, people die and you better start running." Ghostface informed him before Robbie's gutted body crashed through the glass doors. Well, it's safe to say, he found Robbie… and Ghostface. Charlie swore before running up the stairs with the killer chasing after him, he was running down the basement stairs when the knife lodged itself in his back making him tumble down the stairs. The killer stepped on the knife, digging it deeper into his back, making him scream out in pain before Ghostface slowly pulled it out, making him scream again before the killer turned Charlie over.

"Your… you're not r-real." Charlie said

"Are you sure about that?" The killer asked, amused and Charlie gasped as he recognized the voice before crying out as the knife came down and pierced his heart

"Why?" He croaked out, coughing out blood and the killer knelt down next to and tilted their head

"Practice." Ghostface said, simply, stabbing him in the throat, killing him instantly before standing up

"Nice work." Someone said and he turned around to face… a second Ghostface with the phone in his hand

"Thanks" He said before they grabbed Charlie and dragged him up the stairs where a third Ghostface was finishing setting up Robbie

"Got another one for you." He told the third killer who laughed before turning around, smiling at them

"You want to help me?" The third Ghostface asked him and he smiled gleefully, nodding excitedly

"Defiantly." He said before they began setting up Charlie's body


Sheriff Dewey Riley looked around the crime scene to see Robbie Mercer tied to a chair, his mouth gagged with his intestines at his feet, spelling out the words 'What's Your Favorite Scary Movie?' and Charlie Walker was hanging from the ceiling fan, a puddle of blood on the ground under him which the killer used to spell out 'How's it hanging?' There was just one question on everybody's mind…

Who could have done this?


Please review

Xxx Dark Goddess013 Xxx