OKAY GUYS! Here, I tried something completely different. I took a poem but twisted it so that it's like Sam and Andy are talking, or reading each other's mind, per se. I'd love to hear your guys' feedback!
Please read and comment! :)

ROOKIE BLUE
Inside Each Other's Head...

...

Sam: bold
Andy: italicized

...

What is it, exactly, that you want me to say?
My eyes have always been a dead give-away.

Your endearing charm drew me in.
Your sense of humor sealed the win.

You have this effect on me of an unknown sort.
Any kind of explanation will fall short;

But I'll try to describe it anyway for you,
'Cause I don't really know what else to do.
I can't get enough of having you around,
And when you are – my hands shake, my heart pounds.

I laugh like an idiot, and smile too long.
And it feels like there's nowhere else I truly belong.
It's the little things that drive me up the wall.
A funny text, an extended call…

A sweet smile at that just-perfect time,
Or the eye contact you engage – an unwritten crime.

I see something in you, too.
There's a little change, it's true.

If only you would say just a little more,
Could you imagine all else we could explore?

...

Maybe, someday… we'll actually admit.
That in between us, something clicks.
Undefined, is fine with me.
So long as you and I together, can finally be.