Hi all! I've decided to attempt my first Glee fic and yes it's a Shelby/Santana pairing, I love this pairing and there isn't many around so hopefully me writing this will get more writers to do the same. Hope I do it justice, enjoy. Rated M.

Love me right

Chapter 1 – Caught in the middle

It was Monday at William McKinley High school and Santana was walking to her locker with her best friend Brittany. She had really had enough today and was glad the school day was over and now it was choir practice and she was a little more excited than normal that she was going to choir practice The Troubletones with their coach Miss Shelby Corcoran. Santana was previously in Will Schuesters Glee club but since he had favoured the 'Model Pupil' Rachel and Blaine as the lead singers and it just wasn't something Santana was willing to let slip so herself, Brittany, Mercedes and Sugar. It was going well in the club Santana knew she had the best voice and she loved the limelight she got but there was something else which was exciting her and she couldn't put her finger on it.

Santana and Brittany made their way to the choir room and were greeted by Mercedes and Sugar; Santana just waved her hand in the air and went to sit down. They were all waiting for Shelby Corcoran to appear and just when Santana sighed she could hear the echo's of Shelby's heels telling her she was here. Something happened in Santana's body hearing the teacher coming, butterflies in her stomach and her heart beating faster. Santana hadn't felt this way before and she knew instantly with these feelings what was going on what she couldn't put her finger on was the very fact that she had a very big crush on her sub teacher Miss Corcoran. Of course that was it Santana chuckled to herself that it took her so long to figure it out, of course Shelby was an attractive woman, her long brown hair and hazel eyes that you could get lost in.

Santana started thinking to herself,

"I can hear her coming, oh god how does she even make me feel this way? Maybe it's the tight pencil skirts she wears which show every curve in detail or the fact that she's my sub teacher? Or just the fact that she is goddamn HOT!"

Santana let out a tiny moan and Brittany looked at her,

"Did you say something?" Brittany asked looking confused,

Santana could feel a slight blush coming did she really just moan out loud over thinking of Shelby? Just as Santana was about to reply Shelby walked in.

"Hey guys, glad to see you all here and I have an assignment for you all."

Santana had her eyes fixed on Shelby she couldn't seem to move her eyes it was like they were stuck, she took her eyes up Shelby's body taking in every detail on how beautiful she was she got to her chest and saw how perfect her breasts looked in her simple white blouse then she followed up to Shelby's face and she was caught. Shelby was looking straight at her with a slight smirk was that? Santana instantly blushed she had been caught admiring her teachers body and worst of all it was Rachel's biological Mother, not to mention being caught by Shelby personally it was just lucky no one else had noticed, Santana looked to the floor she didn't know where to look. Shelby continued,

"So I want you all to pick a personal favourite song of yours, perform it to the rest of the group and then write me up an essay on why you picked the song and why it is a personal favourite. "

There were a couple of groans from the group on having to do an essay but was later forgotten when the group were picking out their favourite songs to sing. Santana was sitting next the Brittany considering which song to sing, she had asked Brittany what she was singing and wasn't shocked when she said 'Hit me baby one more time' by Britney Spears. Brittany had stood up to speak to Mercedes and Sugar leaving Santana sitting on her own, Santana was still in two minds on what song to pick when she felt a presence behind her and then a hand on her back her heart started beating fast again he knew who's hand that was. To prove her assumption correct it was Shelby smiling down at Santana, Shelby went and sat down next to Santana she had a killer smile and was showing Santana it which wasn't doing any favours for Santana. Shelby smirked at the younger woman,

"So picked a song yet San?" Shelby asked,

There was that smile again Santana thought in her head and then her eyes were transfixed on Shelby's lips, she looked in detail at the lips wondering what it was like to kiss them when Shelby spoke again.

"San is everything okay?" Shelby asked,

Santana snapped out of it and looked at Shelby and replied,

"I'm sorry Miss C I was miles away then." Santana said as she managed to stop her blush from reappearing and Shelby just looked at her with a seductive smile. Santana watched Shelby lean over to her ear and what she heard made her heart stop,

"I bet you was I watched you earlier checking me out right?" Shelby breathed in Santana's ear and Santana just gulped did she just hear that? Coming from her teacher was this real? Santana looked at Shelby to see if she was dreaming but Shelby was waiting for an answer so Santana just nodded weakly. Normally Santana would be in control of everything but there was something about Shelby Corcoran which made her weaken her strength.

Shelby walked away from Santana and sat at her piano but continued to stare at the Latina, she had always thought Santana was a very attractive woman sure she had a temper and was a bit overly confident but Shelby had began noticing the effects she had on Santana's confidence and it fascinated her. Shelby was Santana's coach and sub teacher I mean why was Shelby even flirting with Santana, Shelby kicked herself mentally.

"What am I doing?" Shelby thought.

She couldn't flirt with Santana could she? It was so hard not too sure Shelby knew a while back that she had developed feelings for the girl but she was so much younger than herself and Shelby was old enough to be her Mother and a teacher-student relationship was so not cool. Shelby sighed to herself it was nearing the end of the singing session with her group.

"Right all your welcome to go now and I will see you on Thursday and we will go through your songs in more detail, see you all later."

There was a range of different byes coming Shelby's way and Mercedes left with Sugar first when Brittany walked over to Santana,

"Hey you ready San?" Brittany asked patiently for Santana who was giving her a lift home.

"Britt sorry but I forgot I need to stay and talk something over with Miss C." Santana said,

"Can you get a ride with Mercedes?" Santana added looking at her best friend, it wasn't something Santana felt proud off leaving her friend when she said she would give her a lift back home but ever since Shelby whispered in Santana's ear, the sexy side of Santana had come out and she wanted no needed Shelby right now and Santana was done with being weak around her. Brittany just smiled at Santana,

"That's cool I'll go catch up with her now and I'll see you tomorrow bye."

Santana waved her hand at Brittany then she slowly turned on her feet to look at Shelby. Shelby was facing the other way so her back was to Santana she was still going over why she flirted with Santana and all the reasons why it was bad. Santana sauntered over to Shelby and she put her hands on Shelby's shoulders then bent down to Shelby's ear, two can play at this game Santana thought,

"Yes I was checking you out, how could I not Miss C you're so sexy and I want my fingers inside of you right now; I want to hear you scream my name."

Shelby exhaled heavily and Santana smiled she could see the way Shelby had reacted but the next step upset Santana. Shelby stood up and looked at Santana before fleeing the room. Shelby ran to her car and practically jumped inside; her hands were shaking as she looked at herself in the mirror.

"What am I doing!?" Shelby shouted to herself as she drove off leaving Santana running out of the school to find her.

Santana stood watching Shelby drive away she cursed under her breath,

"Did she or did she not come on to me?" Santana muttered to herself, she groaned and went to her car it hurt Santana that Shelby had rejected her but that wasn't going to stop her and now she knew Shelby wanted the same Santana was going to get her woman.

Shelby had arrived outside of her apartment she felt like crying thinking about what had happened, how she had rejected Santana when she wanted her so badly but then she would be jeopardising her career at William Mckinley. What was she going to do? Shelby was caught in the middle and she didn't know what to do.

So there's chapter 1, I hope you all liked it it's pretty new to me Glee fics let me know what you think and whether I should carry on with it!