I want your honest opinion, people: Do I fail at poetry?

Standard disclaimer applies

Liar

Moonlight in your hair

You say you have to go

"Why?" I ask

You look towards the ground

"It's an order."

"But, why?"

You look towards the moon

"for us."

"Let me come. I can help."

You look towards the ground again.

"No one can help me."

You look at me and smile.

"but I'll be back"

You turn to leave

"Wait"

"Promise me"

That moment,

Looking back at me,

smiling in the moonlight,

You were truly beautiful.

"I promise."

You left and I waited

and waited

and waited

It could have been ten days, or it could have been ten thousand years

I'll never know

Time meant nothing

Nothing until I could feel it,

half of my heart,

dying.

I don't have to ask

Why Xigbar comes into my room

In the middle of the night

"I'm sorry," he says

"He didn't make it."

Anguish ripped at my soul

And the half of a heart you left me

I cry

And I cry

And the only thing that crosses my mind is:

You promised

You promised

How could you lie?