What Happened to Us?
Things between us use to be great, we were perfect together until I wanted to give myself a bad reputation. In hind sight 'Run Joey Run' wasn't my best idea and now I'm without Jesse. I tried to get over him but it was harder than I ever imagined especially once his team crushed us at regionals. For a while I dated Finn but the spark was long gone.
One year on and after being left heartbroken yet again by Finn, you'd think I would have learnt by now, I was sitting in the auditorium preparing a song for prom when I finally saw him again.
Rachel: I feel you even though we're apart
And without you there's a hole in my heart
Oh, baby, baby, though I tried I just can't adjust
Oh boy, what happened to us, happened to us, happened to us? – I start off soft with my thoughts far away
We were in love, we both felt the same
The good thing that we had boy was insane
We had a bond that would never break
Why we let it go?
Oh, we used to stay all night long kissing to our favourite songs
Tell me where it all went wrong
That's what I got to know, oh, whoa, oh
'Cause I feel you even though we're apart
And without you there's a hole in my heart
Oh, baby, baby, though I tried I just can't adjust
Oh, boy, what happened to us, happened to us?
Rachel and Jesse: Thought that I could get over you- I was shocked when I heard Jesse's voice, I whipped around to see him standing in the doorway
Oh, but baby, that is so far from true
Oh baby, baby, got something I want to discuss
Oh boy, what happened to us, happened to us, happened to us?
Jesse: I think that we ought to gotta work it out
Like air your love, I can't live without – I had waited for these words and I felt the same
So have mercy, don't leave me in doubt
I love still hurts – I still feel slightly guilty when I think about it, I hurt him bad
(Still burns, still burns)
I try to go my separate way
At first I thought it was okay
I miss you more with each day so to you I turn- he had reached the stage now
Rachel: 'Cause I feel you even though we're apart
And without you there's a hole in my heart
Oh baby, baby, though I tried I just can't adjust
Oh boy, what happened to us, happened to us? – My eyes beg for answers
Both: Thought that I could get over you, oh
But baby, that is so far from true
Oh baby, baby got something I want to discuss
Oh boy, what happened to us, happened to us, happened to us?
Rachel: I know that you saw me with someone else – he must of seen Finn and I at regionals last year, just like I saw him with Giselle
Both: But believe me I'm all by myself
Oh, yeah, yeah
'Cause I feel you even though we're apart
And without you there's a hole in my heart
Oh baby, baby though I tried I just can't adjust
Oh boy, what happened to us, happened to us? – He offered me his hand which I gratefully took
Thought that I could get over you, oh- We began to dance together
But baby, that is so far from true
Oh baby, baby, got something I want to discuss
Oh boy, what happened to us, happened to us, happened to us? – he pulled away
(Tell me, yeah)
Rachel: 'Cause I feel you even though we're apart
And without you there's a hole in my heart – I held my hands to my chest and put my heart and soul into the rest of the song
Oh baby, baby though I tried I just can't adjust
Oh boy, what happened to us, happened to us?
(What happened to us?)
Oh boy, what happened to us, happened to us?
"Jesse, what are you doing here?" I ask breathlessly
"I came back for you Rach" he replied
"But why?" I move closer to where he was sitting
"Because I love you I never stopped" he replied
"I still love you too" I tell him. He held out his arms as an invitation which I gladly took. I always felt safe in his arms.
"We still need talk about everything that happened" he told me while tightening his grip
"I know" I sighed and snuggled closer into his firm chest.
"Why did you do it? Wasn't I enough for you?" he questioned after a short three minutes
"I have this psychopathic need to be popular. Even when things are good I yearn for more, nothing is ever good enough for me" I admit softly "But I know now that I will never be popular" I whisper sadly
"Rach you don't need to be popular to feel wanted or loved. I love you enough for the rest of them" Jesse's lips brushed against my forehead
"Jesse St. James will you do me the honour of being my boyfriend again?" I bravely ask looking down at my shoes
"Hey look at me" he gently grabs my chin and forces me to look at him "It would be my honour but no more getting musically promiscuous unless I'm the only guy in it"
"Deal" I was grinning like a Cheshire Cat. We sealed the deal with a kiss and knew from then on that we would be together.
AN: Thoughts? Praying for some St. Berry lovin' next season, fingers crossed. If you want follow me on twitter I follow back - Miss Natasha NatashaAnnxo /NatashaAnnxo