What if Woody didn't leave Sunnyside? What if he met Bonnie later in the movie?
Woody sighed as he left his friends in the butterfly room. He didn't want to leave them, but he also didn't want to not be there for Andy. Hanging onto the janitor's cart, he was taken into the bathroom where he crept out a window onto the roof. He ran to the edge and looked out at the playground. The daycare was surrounded by a long brick wall. As he pondered how he was going to get over it, the wind blew his hat off his head, resting against a lone kite. The cowboy smiled; that was his ticket over the wall! Holding onto the bar, he ran across the roof and jumped, letting the wind take him over the playground. He touched the ground on the other side and chuckled to himself. However, his victory was short-lived when two pairs of hands grabbed him, pulling him into the bushes. He tried to fight them off, but something hit the side of his head and he fell to the ground, blacking out.
He woke up hours later, lying in the middle of the butterfly room. Around him was a circle of toys: An insect toy, a purple octopus, a robot, a big baby doll, and a rock-face doll.
"Hey, the ragdoll's awake." The insect said. Woody gasped and backed up against the wall.
"Back off, Twitch. All of you, back up." Into the light came Lotso, who Woody had met earlier. The bear smiled wickedly at him. "Hello sheriff. Were you going somewhere?"
"I, I was going home. My boy Andy needs me." Woody said.
"Aw, you hear that fellas? The sheriff wants to go home to his kid." The group of toys laughed. "Well there is just one problem, sheriff. This is your home now. No one ever leaves Sunnyside."
"You can't keep me here!"
"Oh I can't? Sheriff let me show you what happens to those who try to escape." Lotso took out a knife and nodded at the octopus, who grabbed Woody's arms. The bear stuck the knife in at the top of his left shoulder and dragged it down along his arm. Woody screamed and dropped to his knees.
"You're a psychopath! I am not staying here so that you can torture me! I'm going home." The bear grabbed him by the neck.
"Let me bestow a piece of advice on you, cowboy. This Andy that you care for is not a child anymore. He is a grown man about to leave for college. You go with him; you will do nothing except sit on a shelf watching him forget you. You will never be played with again."
"No, you're wrong, you're…" Lotso gripped his throat tighter.
"Loyalty will get you nowhere in life, sheriff. Get that through your head now. So as I said before, you belong to me now and if you step out of line again, I will kill you." He released him and Woody gasped and coughed. "Now let's go tell your family that you'll be joining them!"
*So that's chapter one! I've been wanting to write this version for a while, but didn't want to ruin it. Hopefully it's good!