Who's That Girl?

A/N: Hey Guys! My second One Tree Hill Story! I'm so glad its back on-air! Well i got this idea from a song. i hope you guys like it. Its about Peyton being the 'new' girl there. Brooke gets a little jealous that she has a crush on her boyfriend, Lucas. So Brooke decides that Lucas can chose who he wants. Who does he pick? Find out when you read my second story!


B: Lucas!

L: Hey Brooke whoa man damn you got that ass! Lucas put his hand on her butt.

B: Lucas!!! She slapped him on the arm.

L:Its not my fault you have a great ass.

B: Just be sure to stay hott and sexy for me k babe

L: Hey anything for my girl

B:Oh damn it theres the bell. Lucas I got to go

L:Or do you. Lucas grabbed her arm and took her to the janitor's closest.

B: Lucas what are we doing here?!

L: I just adore being in here don't you?

B: Lucas stop joking around! I'm going to be late!

L:Or you could just skip it

B: Lucas you know I only do that for Algerbra!

L:Oh alright go run off to your stupid class

Then Peyton was walking in the hall looking for her class as Brooke and Lucas walked out.

P: Hey umm do you guys know where Mrs. Alfred's class is at?

B: Yea I'm taking it right now but its not this closest.

L: Yea I'm taking it too.

P: Ok... can you guys take me there?

BL:Yea sure

L:'Damn she got an ass'

B:Ok here we are oh and can you cover for us?

P:Sure no problem

MA: Ahh Brooke, Lucas I see you have decided to finally join us.

B: Yea well we saw that she was a new student and we asked her.. what she was taking next... and uhh.... guess what Mrs. Alfred she takes it with us

MA: Sit your butts down. Hi I'm Mrs.Alfred. You must be Peyton. Its very nice to meet you. go ahead pick a seat.

P:Ok

Peyton went to sit down. Brooke was writing a note to Lucas.

B: Pissssssssssssssssss. pass this to Lucas.

Some girl handed it to Lucas. He opened it and read 'I know what you were thinking when you saw Peyton's ass. i know that face expression.'

L:'Aww man'

L: Mrs. Alfred.

MA:Yes Lucas

L:Can I go to the bathroom

MA:No Mr.Scott I'm afraid not. The bell will be ringing soon so wait till then.

L:But its an emergency

MA:Fine Mr.Scott you may go

L:'YES'

Then the bell rang. Everybody got up, and left to go to there lockers. Brooke walked to her locker. Haley came walking towards her.

H: So you saw a new girl?

B: Yea. You won't beleive who likes her ass.

H: Oh my god. Lucas?!

B: Yea!!!! I can't believe him! Ahhhh!!!!!! After our 3 year commitmot.

H: Hey Nathan and I have only been dating for like 3 months. He still looks at my hott body.

N: Hey Hales!

H: Hey Nate!

Nathan came and put his arm around Haley's waist.

N: So Brooke a new girl is it?

B: Damn it how do you know!

N: Its so fucking obvious!

B: Ok yea its the new chick you happy now!

N: Not until Haley fucks me

H: Nathen!

Haley slapped him on his arm.

N: What Hales is it my fault you so fine?

H: No its actually my parents fault. So Brooke I'll see you at lunch?

B: Yea

L: Brooke whats wrong?

B: You looking- no checking some girl out

L: Look she's not as fine as you ok. So don't be mad.

Lucas started to kiss Brooke on the lips. Brooke joined in.

B: Ok fine you got out of this one.

L: Don't I always. Come on lets go to lunch.

Brooke and Lucas walked off to the cafeteria. Peyton enterupted.

P: Hey umm where's the cafeteria?

L: Look why don't you just go ask them? We are also new.

P: Ok..... I'll go

B: Don't you think you were being a little harsh?

L: That's what you wanted? Didn't you?

B: Yea.... but not like that.

L: Whatever...... lets go eat.

So they headed off and went to sit next to Haley and Nathan.

N: So I see it worked out

B: Yea

H: Ha you owe me $20.00 bucks Nathan

N: Damn it

B: Wait you guys bet over this

H: Yea I won now we can go to the mall today!

B: Don;t get your hopes up I have to go rehearse my song at the bar.

H: Ok we can go after that.

B: Haley by then I'll be all worked out. So maybe you can come watch me.

H: Yea......... sure

So they day was about to end real fast. After school Brooke and Haley drove off to the bar. They got out of the car and went inside. it was so dark.

M: Ahh Brooke Davis. Come get on stage and what was the song?

B: Umm Ashlee Simpson. Lala. By the way who are you?

M: I'm the manajor. That's what you call me ok Manajor. Can you say it?

B: Manajor.

M: Ahh yes there we go.

H:Ok lets get to rehearsal!

The band started to play.

B: You can dress me up in diamonds

You can dress me up in dirt

You can throw me like a line-man

I like it better when it hurts

Oh, I have waited here for you

I have waited

You make me wanna la la

in the kitchen on the floor

I'll be a french maid

Where I'll meet you at the door

I'm like an alley cat

Drink the milk up, I want more

You make me wanna

You make me wanna scream

You can meet me on an aero-plane

Or in the back of the bus

You can throw me like a boomerang

I'll come back and beat you up

Oh, I have waited here for you

Dont, keep me waiting

You make me wanna la la

in the kitchen on the floor

I'll be a french maid

Where I'll meet you at the door

I'm like an alley cat

Drink the milk up, I want more

You make me wanna

You make me wanna la la

in the kitchen on the floor

I'll be a french maid

Where I'll meet you at the door

I'm like an alley cat

Drink the milk up, I want more

You make me wanna

You make me wanna scream

I feel safe with you

I can be myself tonight

It's alright, with you

Cuz you hold, my secrets tight

You do, You do

You make me wanna la la, la la la, la la, la la la la la la la la la

You make me wanna la la, la la la la

You make me wanna la la

in the kitchen on the floor

I'll be a french maid

When I'll meet you at the door

I'm like an alley cat

Drink the milk up, I want more

You make me wanna

You make me wanna la la

in the kitchen on the floor

I'll be a french maid

Where I'll meet you at the door

I'm like an alley cat

Drink the milk up, I want more

You make me wanna

You make me wanna scream

You make me wanna la la, la la la, la la, la la la la la la la la la

You make me wanna la la, la la la la

You make me wanna la la, la la la, la la, la la la la la la la la la

You make me wanna la la, la la la la

You make me wanna la la, la la la, la la, la la la la la la la la la

You make me wanna la la, la la la la

Brooke sounded just like Ashlee. She was great!

H: Wow! Brooke I never knew you could sing like that.

B: Well you should see me when I do my vocals.

H: You so good. Do it again!!

B: Don't you want to go to the mall?

H: Yes

B: Ok so lets go

H: OK

So they left the bar. The night she was going to do it was Friday. They got to the mall. Lucas was there. He was hanging out with Peyton. Then they started to kiss.

H: Umm Brooke I think there's something you should see. You know why he's not picking up well he's here.

B: What? He said he would be home.

Then Brooke turned her head and saw what she could never think of. Peyton and Lucas making out. It was so horrible. Brooke ran out of the mall. Tears falling from her eyes. Haley ran after her. They drove to Brooke's house. Brooke never stopped crying.

H: Brooke.... please stop crying. A boy is not worth it.

B: Haley! He's not a boy he's a man. He was my man. Uhhh

Brooke was mad and sad at the same time. She didn't know who to blame but herself. She cried all night long so Haley drove over to her house and grabbed her clothes. Went back over to Brooke's.

H: Sorry I took so long.

B: He called.

Brooke said in a whipering voice.

H: What did you say?

B: I said I have a surprise for him. I told him to come over. He's on his way. He should be here right about now.

Brooke was still whipering asking herself 'do I want to break up with him'. She was so confused. Then Lucas came knocking on the door. Brooke went to answer.

L: Hey Brooke! So where's my surprise.

Lucas said looking around not paying attention that she was crying.

L: Brooke what's wrong. Why are you crying?

B: I know

Brooke said in a crying voice.

L: Brooke can we talk about this. It wasn't supposed to happen.

B: You lied to me Lucas! You lip locked with another girl!!!!!!!!! How can I not be mad at you!

L: Brooke just let me explain-

B: What?! Lucas explain what?! That you kissed Peyton! How can you?

L: Look-

B: I don't know what to say but.... Its-.......... its........ its......... over

Brooke's voice got softer and softer as she said that.

L: Brooke please... give me another chance. Please... I'm so sorry. Brooke!

Brooke shut her door and started crying. Lucas was still out on her porch. He slept there for the night.

H: Brooke I'm so sorry.

B: Haley its not your fault. It's mine. Ok so now can we just get ready to go to bed.

H: Ok.

B: and Haley.

H:Yea

B: Don't wake me up for school. I'm not going. Your not going either.

H: Ok.

They slept. Lucas over did it. He didn't go either.

To be continued...............


A/N: Hey guys I hope you like it so far! I'll do the next chapter soon. Please R&R!!!!!!!!

Music: Ashlee Simpson-Lala

One Tree Hill Theme Song.