Mouth starred into the sky and thought about his last for years in high school, he smiled to himself. Though he trusted Brooke with his life, he couldn't help but wonder why she had called him to the river court at such a late hour. He found himself thinking that maybe she would declare her love for him, but then sighed, knowing he wasn't good enough.
He then heard some footsteps , the smell of Brooke's perfume hit his nostrils and he breathed in and out.
"Hi Mouth" said Brooke, in a friendly tone.
Mouth's heart was beating as fast it had ever done before, he quickly turned around. His face dropped as he starred Brooke in the face, she had a gun in her hand.
"Brooke, what is that?" Mouth said, trying hard not to burst into tears.
Brooke rolled her eyes and then raised the gun up to mouths head.
"Mouth, you were a great friend, I can't lose you … not to" Brooke screamed but didn't do a thing to stop it. Mouth had fallen to the floor, blood was oozing out of his head.
Brooke looked on in horror and then went on to say "Luke, what have you done?"
Lucas glanced at Mouths motionless body and grinned evilly.
"I did what we planned, pretty girl" Luke said without remorse. Brooke looked stunned at this statement.
"When did we agree this? Mouth is my friend, he was all …." Brooke's speech came to a halt when she noticed Lucas staring at something behind her, she slowly turned around and her jaw dropped. Stood there with a confused yet horrified look on his face was, Chase, Brooke's ex-boyfriend. But it wasn't Mouth that had horrified him, it was something else.
"What are you doing with Lucas?" he said, with a puzzled tone in his voice. A smug smile appeared on Lucas's face. Brooke walked up to Chase and went to kiss him, he pushed her away
"No, you're a two timer" he said, resigning to the fact that he had lost Brooke forever.
This statement angered Lucas, he pointed at Chase and yelped, a fight was about to break out. All the while, Mouth lay unconscious on the ground, perhaps dead, perhaps not. Lucas shoved a startled Chase, he glared at Luke and suddenly a nerve was hit. Chase screamed at the top of his voice and charged, Lucas went flying backwards, landing directly on Mouth. Chase didn't stop then, he ran up to Brooke and grabbed the unused gun.
It was now pointed at Lucas, who was still groggy from his fall.
"Luke, watch out!" Brooke said, this angered Chase and in a moment of madness, the guns target was changed and seconds later Brooke had fallen to the ground below, killed instantly by the blast.
Lucas, in a fit of rage, grabbed the distracted Chase and pushed him to the river. But Lucas forgot to release his grip and they both ended up plunging into the deep dark water. Minutes passed and nothing, there was no doubt that they had both drowned. A dazed Mouth suddenly got up, he looked around in confusion, in front of him now stood Haley, Nathan, Peyton and Rachel. They all looked as shocked as each other
"You murderer, of all the people, how could you mouth?" said Rachel in horror. Mouth looked down to see a motionless Brooke, with a gun shot wound in the stomach.
"You'll do life for this, Marvin!"
And to this day Marvin "Mouth" McFadden sits in a prison cell and constantly repeats the line "You broke heart". Lucas was never seen again, but Peyton had moved in with Jake, and assumed he had gone on to pursue his career in writing. Chase was never thought of again, except when Rachel once mentioned the fact that she had in fact slept with him, therefore meaning, he wasn't the innocent man he claimed to be. Instead of her name "Brooke Davis" on her grave, they requested that the words "Pretty Girl" would be engraved on it, no one ever thought to mention the fact that neither Chase or Lucas, came to the funereal. It weans presumed that they had other people to pour there heart out to.