A/N-I have rewritten the story because apparently people didn't like the fact that Spoby broke up and I want my readers to be happy. They are still together in this story, but are going to have to face a lot more challenges. I hope you enjoy and let me know what you think.

Chapter 1

You and Me...+1?

2 years later...

Toby pulled his truck in the driveway of his home. After a long days work at the construction site, he was ready to unwind with his fiancée. Before he got out of the truck, Toby took his time to admire the house in front of him. Just like he promised Spencer, he built their home with his own bare hands. With a little help from his friends at the construction company. The house was a 3 bedroom 2.5 bath Bungalow style home with extra amenities, like a large walk-through closet behind the double vanity in the master bath, an efficient mud room, a large multipurpose island in the kitchen, and generous adjacent pantry. The master suite occupies one corner of the ground floor. The rear porch off the great room brings entertaining outdoors. Two bedrooms flanking a shared bath are upstairs and there's a bonus room over the three car garage. The additional rooms are the Great Room, Living Room, Den/Study, and Main Floor Laundry Room.

Toby took it upon himself to make the house more into a home by putting colorful flowers at the front of the house and also in the backyard. A tire swing on the big oak tree on their front law. In the backyard was a pool, a shed for him and his tools, and a hammock where he and Spencer would leisurely spend their days. It took Toby a year in a half to build their home, but he was proud of it. There was only one thing he had left to do. He had to fill up those extra two rooms.

Toby shut off his truck and stepped out. He checked the mailbox on his way to the door to retrieve the mail. He walked on the front porch and before he could even open the door, Spencer came barreling into his arms.

"Whoa!" He said in surprised because he didn't see her sitting on the porch swing.

"I missed you." She said while she kissed every inch of his face.

"I was only gone for like eight hours." He said and chuckled as he walked them into the house, kicking the door shut behind him."What's that smell?"

"I cooked. Why are you looking like that?"

"Because it actually smells good." He teased and she smacked him on the chest and unwrapped herself from his body as a form of punishment.

"Are you trying to tell me something?"

"Yes, you only cook good when you have good news or bad news, so what is it?"

Spencer smirked and grabbed his hands to lace their fingers together."It's a surprise and I'll give it to you after dinner."

Toby followed Spencer int the dinning room. The lights were dim, there were candles lit, wine on the table, and soft music playing in the background.

"Did I miss our anniversary?" Toby joked half serious.

"No, Mr. Cavanaugh. Our anniversary isn't until next week, but tonight is something...special." Spencer said and Toby's heart skipped a beat. This could be the moment when she gives him the most wonderful news ever. This could be the day she tells him that he's going to be a father.

"Alright, then Miss Hasting, I don't to wait too long because I'll get anxious, so lets eat."

Spencer prepared her grandmothers lasagne and red velvet cake for desert. Toby knew that she was pulling out all the stops, so the news must have been big. About three times during dinner, Spencer had to tell him to slow down because he was eating too fast. He couldn't help it because he was excited. He couldn't wait to be a father.

"So, we've eaten dinner and we've had desert. Now, can you let me in on the big news?" Toby pleaded.

"Yes, just wait right here and I'll be back." Spencer said before standing up and leaving the dinning room. Toby drank himself a glass of water to calm his nerves before she got back. Soon, Spencer walked back into the dinning room with an envelope in hand. She sat down and slide the envelope across the table to Toby.

Toby was more than excited to see that envelope. He quickly grabbed the envelope and began ripping it open right away. Inside was a formal document, but when he read it his smile began to falter. It wasn't pregnancy test results. It wasn't a sonogram picture of their baby. There was no baby.

"Toby, aren't you excited for me?" Spencer asked bringing Toby out of his deep thoughts.

"What?"

She was a little taken aback by his unsupportive reaction. She had worked at hard on her exam for her toughest class and gotten an 'A'.

"I got a great grade on my exam. Aren't you happy for me?"

Toby thought about her words for a moment. Spencer always worked hard at anything that she ever did, but this class was tough and she was afraid that she might fail. He should be happy, but he was really hoping to see a beautiful thing they made together and not a letter.

"I'm very proud of you, Spence." He said in the most convincing voice he could, but that didn't work. Spencer stood up and ran to their bedroom and slammed the door.

Toby decided to give Spencer a few minutes before he walked down to their bedroom to beg for forgiveness. He lightly knocked on the door, but he got no answer. He knocked again and got the same result. He took a deep breath before he walked into the bedroom. Spencer was curled up on the bed with Snow and her eyes were red. Toby felt so bad that he made her cry. He walked over to her and tried to touch her, but Snow swatted at his hand. Snow was always there to protect Spencer.

"A little help." Toby said to Spencer and she just looked at him."Please, babe."

It took her a few seconds, but Spencer moved Snow to the floor and Toby replaced the spot she was in. He laid his head on top of hers and wrapped his arms around her waist. Spencer threw her leg over his hip, so that they were fully intertwined.

"I'm sorry, Spence. I am truly proud and happy for you. It just wasn't the news I was expecting."

"What kind of news were you expecting?" She tilted her head to look up at him and got goosebumps when she felt him press his palm over her shirt on her flat stomach.

"I was hoping that you were gonna tell me that we were gonna to be expecting a little Toby or Spencer."

"Toby, you know we've talked about this. I'm still in school and technically so are you. I just want to wait at least a year after I graduate college to have kids."

Toby sighed deeply and started stroking her stomach with his hand."I don't think I can wait that long."

"We technically have a child." Spencer leaned over Toby to point to Snow who crawled back up on the bed and was trying to lay in between them like she always picked her up and placed her back on the floor and she scurried out of the room."She's always been like our baby. So for now can we just have her?"

"Alright, if that's what you want." He said and started kissing along her neck."But we can still practice for making the baby."

Before she could respond, Toby's lips covered hers. Spencer knew she was in for a long night because she knew that he was going to try to get her pregnant even if it killed him.

A few days later, they were having a barbecue at their home. His parents and her parents came. Their siblings with their dates and their friends. Jason was dating CeCe and Melissa and Wren were moving to New York together. Aria and Ezra were married and were expecting their first child. Hanna and Caleb were living together and working on starting their own business. Emily and Paige eloped and were looking into adoption. And Holden was still living the life as a bachelor.

Toby and the boys were by the grills talking. While, Spencer and the girls were in the kitchen having a little chat. They were currently talking about Hanna's shopping spree she went on while her and Caleb were in Montecito.

"Really? Hanna you had to buy that many shoes?" Emily asked.

"You know what I say. If the shoe fits start looking for your sixth pair." Hanna winked at her friends.

"Well, I think she's lucky. I haven't worn heels in months because my feet are too swollen." Aria said and showed her slipper-like shoes she was wearing to her friends.

"Well, I think you look great, Aria." Spencer said and placed her hand on her friends baby bump."There's a certain glow about you and it's all thanks to this little princess."

"Thanks, Spence. I was meaning to ask for a favor. Do you think Toby could renovate the guest bedroom into a nursery?"

"Of course. I know he'd love to do that."

"When are you and Toby going to be having a blue-eyed baby-"

Spencer shot Emily a warning glance making her stop talking. She looked around to make sure Toby wasn't around."Shh. Don't say the word baby or else Toby will jump on top of me."

"And what's wrong with that?" Hanna said and raised her eyebrows at her friend questioningly."Have you not seen his body?"

"I think she means that Toby's hoping to get Spencer pregnant." Emily explained.

"I knew that, Em." Hanna said."I mean they're engaged. They have a home with more than enough space. They're financially stable. What's stopping them?"

"What's stopping us is that...I don't think I want to have kids."

"What!" Her friends yelled in unison and she had to shush them again, so Toby wouldn't hear.

"I do want to have kids...someday. Our lives are just getting started. My mom set me up with a job with her law firm after I graduate from UPenn and Toby's working towards starting his own business. We are only twenty-two and were are already living together and engaged." Spencer explained.

"Spence, are you having doubts abut you and Toby?" Emily asked.

"No! Absolutely not. Toby is the one and only one for me. But is it selfish to just want it to be us for a little while?"

"I don't think so. Just look at me and Ezra. We were married two years before we made the decision to have a kid and it made our relationship a lot stronger and know we know what our priorities are." Aria said.

"I agree with, Aria. You two should just take some time for yourself before having a baby. A baby changes a lot of things in a relationship and you guys need to be prepared." Hanna commented.

Spencer sighed deeply as she rubbed her hands over her face."Okay, since it's easy for you guys to tell me to wait, then tell me how am I supposed break the news to Toby."

Her friends all looked at her with blank expressions. There weren't too many ways you could just go up to your fiancé and tell him he has to wait to have kids for a couple more years. Spencer didn't know how to, but she knew she had to.