Hey all! This is a sequel to Inconceivable and it shouldn't be hard to follow if you didn't read it, but you probably should incase I'm wrong. Anyway, thanks for reading!

Chapter 1

Serena POV

I grin as I shoot another goal past Hugo. I pump my fist as I zoom back across the pitch. Louis high fives me on my way by, I give James a big smile as he pouts on the opposite side of the pitch. Louis, Lily, Fred and I are playing against James, Hugo, Albus and Rose and my team is definitely winning.

I turn around to head off Rose from scoring when I noticed James' Mom walking quickly towards us. When she reaches us she starts waving her arms and Albus calls a break and we all fly down towards her. She stops at the edge of the field and waits for us to meet us. "Your letters came!" She calls with a grin.

"We should go home! C'mon Hugo!" calls Rose, as she sprints towards the Potter's house.

Hugo groans. "She's way too excited." He walks after, but starts running when she shouts at him again.

"So where are they?" asks Lily.

"I left them inside. I also got some ice cream for you, if you're interested," replies Ginny.

"I know I'm interested!" says Fred, starting towards the house.

"Don't you want to go get your letter?" asks Louis, following behind him.

"Well, it's not like I'm going to get prefect or quidditch captain so why do I need to open it right away?" He calls back over his shoulder.

"He's got a point," I say, as we follow after him.

Louis hums in agreement as we head into the house.

As everyone heads to the ice cream I set my broom against the table and grab my letter. "Do you think I made prefect again?" I ask with a giggle.

"Can they really change it after they make you prefect your fifth year?" asks Lily.

"I'm not sure," I reply as I rip my letter open, immediately a badge falls out and into my hand, but it's not what I was expecting. I stare at it for a moment while everyone starts in on their ice cream.

James walks over to me with an ice cream cone for me. "Hey is something wrong?" He asks, holding out my ice cream cone.

I quickly skim through the letter. "I'm not a prefect this year."

"Really?" asks Harry, as he walks into the room. "I didn't think they could do that."

"Then what are you holding?" asks Louis.

I chuckle to myself before looking up at him. "My new badge."

"Well how can you have a badge if you aren't a prefect?" asks Fred confused.

"Because they were stupid enough to make me head girl," I answer, holding up the badge for them to see.

I laugh as Lily squeals. "Rose is gunna lose it!"

"Why? She's only a sixth year," says Al.

"Because she doesn't think that Rena is fit to be a prefect," giggles Lily.

"She's kind of right," I chuckle.

"Well, I'm really proud of you," James throws his arms around me, careful not to get ice cream in my hair. He kisses me sloppily on the cheek before handing me my ice cream.

"Thanks James," I blush. I set down my letter and grab my ice cream from him.

"Oh kids open your letters!" pleads Ginny. "James maybe you'll make prefect."

"How would I be prefect, Louis is the prefect?" asks James confused.

"Well James, we all know Louis probably got head boy. But maybe they made Fred the prefect," says Harry, trying to keep a straight face.

James glares at him. "I'll open my letter later thank you." He shoves it into his back pocket.

Ginny rolls her eyes, as her other two children open their letters.

"Well Mum one of us got prefect," says Lily, waving her badge in the air.

"Oh Lily!" Ginny yanks Lily into a hug. "That's two!"

"Hey! I got quidditch captain that's a big deal!" James yells.

Ginny gives him a look over Lily's shoulder. "Yes, yes we know."

James pouts as Albus pulls out his prefect badge. "Poor James," says Al.

Shortly after the Potter Prefect debate Louis and Fred floo home to check their letters. A while after dinner Rose, Hugo, Ron and Hermione come over and Louis and Fred come back.

"Well, I got prefect again, so I guess we won't find out who head boy is until school starts," says Louis, plopping down on the couch next to James and I.

"I wonder who it is?" says Fred, sitting on the armchair next to us.

"I'm still surprised Serena got head girl," says Ron, who's playing chess with Harry in the corner near the fire.

"Ron," scolds Hermione. "Serena is a very good student! She deserves to be head girl."

I chuckle. "Thanks Hermione, but Ron does have a point."

She shakes her head. "Either way I think you deserved it."

"We all do," says Harry, winking at me.

"Well, I know who head boy is," says James, munching on a chocolate frog.

"How could you possibly know?" I ask him confused. "You haven't owled anyone today and Louis and Fred aren't head boy…."

He wiggles his eyebrows at me as it slowly dawns on me. "Oh my Merlin, they didn't."

He shrugs.

"James!"

"What's going on?" asks Lily confused, as everyone stares at us.

"I think James has something to tell you," I say not knowing whether to laugh or not.

James stands up dramatically and holds out his hand. "I have been made head boy."

Fred snorts. "No way!" He snatches the badge out of James' hand.

Ginny jumps up and pulls James into a hug. "Quidditch captain and Head Boy? I'm so proud of you James."

"Oh how the tables have turned!" He says, acting hurt.

She shakes her head, before going back to her seat on the floor next to Harry.

James sits back down and I wrap my arms around his neck. "I'm proud of you, ya know," I whisper.

"I know."