Dear Riley,
I am writing to you to tell you of the dilemma that I find myself in. My heart is split in two, held captive by your bright blue eyes and her sweet smile. For both of you, I feel love, but in different sorts of ways. With you, I always feel happy. I love to see your smile, and listen to your eyes light up and your mouth open wide when I say something that isn't even funny. But with Haruhi, I feel like a father, protective of my child. She is adorable, and I love her. But whenever I am enjoying my time with her, my mind always drifts to you. Even as I write this letter, I am realizing more and more that I want to be with you. Together, we are perfect. Silent moments are never awkward between us, as we can always tell what the other person is thinking. I love you. Please say that you love me in return. You will forever be my only guest at the Host Club. Please be mine.
With all my love,
Tamaki