Summary: AU. Dean finally gets the chance to talk to Castiel and they end up in a great relationship…until those three words are spoken that mean all too much for Dean. Please Review!
Disclaimer: I don't own Supernatural or its characters.
Pairings: Dean/Castiel, Sam/Lucifer.
A/N: Okay, not much detail here, but Lucifer's a nice guy in this so that's okay. I know this chapter only really focusses on Sam and Lucifer but Dean and Castiel will be the main focus for this story. Please give this a chance and let me know what you think! ENJOY!
So Afraid to Love You
Chapter One
Dean had seen him here before, sparkling eyes lit up by the club's lights, dark hair dishevelled and so amazing Dean just wanted to mess it up even more. He sat in dark red and black tonight…God it was a hot sight. He was with another guy, but they didn't appear to be in a relationship kinda thing…they were sat checking other guys out for a start.
"Hey, Sam…" Dean hissed, grabbing his whiskey and swigging it as he looked at his brother, "Check out dark hair-blue eyes over there…"
"Him again? I wish I knew who he's with" Sam breathed, checking out the blonde who sat with the dark haired man, as he had been all night.
"I don't know, but I don't wanna make the first move, either." Dean replied, "Oh, act natural, Blondie's coming over."
Sam giggled and Dean raised an eyebrow, turning and starting half a conversation with his other.
"You are totally wrong, dude." Dean laughed, Sam turning as the blonde guy sat beside him, leaning over and whispering in his ear.
"You looking for a good time?"
Sam blushed a little and bit his lip, Dean not watching as his brother was getting an offer.
"Depends what you wanna do." Sam replied, the blonde chuckling and leaning closer.
"My name's Lucifer." The blonde whispered, Sam trying not to swoon at the strong name.
"Sam."
"Well, Sam…I got an apartment not far from here if you wanna take off…" Lucifer breathed, sliding a hand up Sam's thigh, "Only…I've seen you looking at me all night…and I've been looking at you too…"
Sam turned and smiled, Lucifer winking and taking his hand. Dean laughed as his brother was led out by Lucifer, hearing a soft noise as none other than the guy with the dark, amazing sex-hair and bright blue eyes was standing right with him.
"Hi…" The man said shyly, Dean putting on his best charming smile and nodding.
"Hi." He replied, "You want a drink?"
The dark-haired man blushed and smiled, nodding and biting his lip as he climbed on the barstool beside Dean.
"My name's Dean." Dean said softly, watching the unbelievable sparkle as it danced in this…this angel's eyes…
Angel? Ugh…big girl.
"Castiel."
"Castiel?" Dean asked, "Nice name."
"Thanks." Castiel replied, blushing again.
Damn, that was cute.
As Dean ordered their drinks, Castiel watched his green eyes as they shone in the bright lights, hardly able to contain his excitement that he'd finally talked to this beautiful man before him.
A deep kiss was shared as Lucifer thrust into Sam, the younger man twisting his fingers in the sheets as he felt on fire within, felt alive, and felt so close he wanted to just die.
"Yes! Yes! PLEASE!" Sam cried, "Oh God…LUCIFER!"
Lucifer smirked against Sam's neck and began to pound into him, earning more cries and please in response to the movements.
"Sam…you're fucking beautiful!" Lucifer breathed, "Oh my fucking God…"
With that he came hard, Sam following and shooting streams all over their abdomens, shivering and crying out as he did. They slowed to a stop and Lucifer rested on top of Sam, looking down at his hot one night stand and kissing his lips.
"Man, you're fucking hot…" Lucifer laughed, the comment hurting Sam a little.
Oh no…the tears…he was going to cry, he could feel it. Oh, man…he couldn't cry…not now.
The sniffle sounded and Sam closed his eyes, Lucifer rolling over and looking at the young man by his side.
"Sam? What's wrong?"
-TBC-