A/N: Welcome to my new story. I know that I probably shouldn't be making a new one with A Night to Remember not being finished but I couldn't get this idea out of my head so here it is. This is set during season three. I plan on making it a multi chapter story but that is if enough people want it to be. Please read and review and let me know what you think of this first chapter!
Disclaimer: I do not own Glee that belongs to Ryan Murphy and Fox.
It was an ordinary morning for Will Schuester as he got up and got ready for school. He took a hot shower, made some breakfast, collected his glee music and Spanish papers, kissed his girlfriend Emma and headed out the door.
Will had been dating Emma for almost five months, ever since he had gotten back from New York this past summer, and ever since then they almost always had driven to school together because of now living together. However, Emma had started to notice a change in Will. He was leaving earlier and leaving without her.
It wasn't that Will didn't enjoy Emma's company it was just that he sometimes couldn't handle her. The hardest part about being in a relationship with Emma was that she liked to wait when it came to being intimate with each other. He understood that she was a virgin and wanted to take things slow but it frustrated him, he was a man after all. As Will was driving to school, he thinks that this is the problem that caused him to fall for one Rachel Berry.
He knew it was wrong to be romantically involved with Rachel seeing as she was underage and his student but he couldn't help himself when he was around her. He didn't even know how it had happened between them; he just knew that going to New York with her was probably not the smartest idea.
The memory of that weekend had been replaying in Will's head over and over again ever since they had gotten back. It was all he could think about on his way to school this morning and he replayed that night in his head.
It had all started five months ago when New Directions were on their way to the National show choir competition in New York. Emma had offered to come along to be another chaperone but he politely declined her help.
Everyone was excited to be there but were soon devastated with the realization that they had received twelfth place in the competition. They were all heart broken and vulnerable that their hard work was for nothing. After a long tiring day of losing, everyone decided to go to bed early except for him because he couldn't sleep and apparently neither could Rachel.
Rachel poked her head in looking tired and worn out. He offered for her to come in and she accepted. From that point on everything had happened so fast. They talked about everything even about Emma and Finn for Rachel was confused about her feelings for him. The talking had died down and he remembers mentioning something about it getting late and curses at himself for bringing it up. He didn't want Rachel to leave because he enjoyed talking to her but he knew that she had to. Rachel hesitated before moving slowly off of the bed that they were sitting on but was stopped by the gentle touch of his hand on hers. She looked into his eyes and it made him feel like his heart was going to explode out of his chest.
"Rachel," he softly muttered out.
"Yes?" she replied with slight hesitation in her voice.
"Please, don't go?" he asked more as a statement rather than a question. Rachel just stared at him with her big brown eyes not breaking her concentration on him.
Before he knew it, his lips were on hers and they were kissing passionately. Their hands were roaming everywhere and soon clothes were being taken off.
"Are you sure, Rachel?" he asked making sure this was what she wanted.
"Yes, Will. I want you," she replied not even hesitating to use his real name.
That was enough to push him over the edge. When they woke up the next morning though, he felt terrible and incredibly guilty, like he had just committed the crime of the century. He not only had adult interaction with Rachel, he had cheated on Emma even if they weren't technically together yet. It was then that they decided that whatever they had between them would not be able to work out when they got home and they put an end to it.
So that is how Will fell for Rachel but ended up with Emma instead five months ago. When they got back from New York, Will had asked Emma to move in with him over the summer and to make it official to be his girlfriend while Rachel went on to date Finn.
Now, as Will was driving to school he thought of how his first interaction with Rachel went when they had gotten back. He replayed the memory in his head again since this was the second most important memory to him.
When they had gotten back home, he just didn't feel the same when it came to Emma anymore. His heart longed for Rachel and he was pretty sure that Rachel wanted him too seeing as she wasn't herself around Finn. He couldn't get her out of his mind though so he met with her a few times over the summer telling Emma that he was going out for a long run. The meetings were nothing special, usually meeting only once or twice a month, but they soon became more insistent and more frequently.
Everything had once again changed when it was just two weeks before the new school year started in late August. He snuck out of the apartment when Emma was out grocery shopping and met Rachel at the park like they normally did when they met.
"Hey Rach, got your text. What's wrong?" he asked.
"Will, we can't keep meeting like this if nothing is going to come out of it," she said almost on the verge of tears. He looked at her stunned.
"What do you mean?" he asked.
"I just don't know how much longer I can keep lying to Finn. If we are just meeting for nothing then I can't do that anymore to him," she stated. "It is tearing him apart."
"Don't you feel bad for Emma?" she asked. He did but that didn't stop him from not caring about her.
"Rachel, you know that I care about you," he started to say but was cut off.
"I know but you are with Emma," she finished for him.
"Yes, but actually I was going to say," he started to say but took a pause.
"That I still have feelings for you," he said rather quietly.
"You do?" she asked not sure if she believed him or not.
"I do and I hope you feel the same way about me," he said now looking into her eyes. "I couldn't stop thinking about you ever since we had gotten back from New York."
"I do, Will. I care about you more than you know," she said moving closer to him and wrapping him in a hug.
"But we can't be together," he said bringing in the reality of their situation.
"What if we could though?" she asked hopefully.
"How?" he asked confused.
"Well we still date who we are with we just use them as cover ups and see each other on the side," she said.
"That would be great, Rachel but I don't want you to have to sneak around for us," he said. He also didn't like the idea of cheating but he wanted to be with Rachel and get to know her more so maybe just this once he would make an exception.
"That's sweet of you but the thought of sneaking around kind of turns me on," she whispered in his ear. He could feel his heart beat speed up.
"It does, does it?" he asked seductively.
"Of course," she purred in his ear while she gently bit it. He let out a low gasp and moved her so that she was in front of him. He lent down and kissed her finally giving into what his lips wanted ever since they had left New York.
From that meeting on Will had found himself around Rachel more and more and Emma less and less. Sure he felt terrible for cheating on Emma. She didn't deserve it but that was the only way that people wouldn't get suspicious of him and Rachel.
It was now two months into the new school year as Will was driving to school that morning rethinking of how he and Rachel came to be. He was planning on meeting Rachel in the choir room for some alone time. Everything was going perfectly between them in these past five months and nobody suspected a thing between them. Well that is what he hoped anyways.
He pulled into the school parking lot and put his car in park. He reached over and grabbed his bag out of the back seat and headed into the school and to the choir room. He smiled when he walked in as Rachel was already there waiting for him at the piano.
"Hi," Will said as he walked over to her.
"Hi," Rachel answered back. "What did you tell Emma this time?" she asked curiously.
"I told her that I had to fill out some paperwork for the glee club in order to compete for sectionals," he said.
"That's a new one," Rachel smirked.
"It is. I was running out of excuses to tell her," Will said.
"What did you say to Finn?" he asked her.
"That I was coming in early to work on a new song for West Side Story. It's a lame excuse but I know that it will always work," Rachel said. Will nodded at her.
"I can't believe we have been dating for almost five months," Rachel said. "It still seems unreal," she added.
"It does and I have enjoyed every second of it," Will said. "Aside from hurting Emma though," he added. Rachel nodded back because she felt the same way about Finn. Will moved around the piano and took a seat next to her on the bench. He grabbed her hand and they looked deep into each other's eyes.
Rachel leaned into kiss him, tangling her hands in his hair and pulling him closer. She moved her tongue into his mouth and soon they were both fighting for dominance. They finally broke apart both breathing heavily.
It was starting to get more crowded in the hallway. Not too much to where they could get caught but enough to know when to stop. The bell would be ringing soon anyways. Rachel stood up and grabbed her bag off of the floor.
"So I'll see you later?" she asked.
"Of course," Will said with a smile.
Rachel smiled back at him and headed towards the door. Yes, these past five months have been perfect Will thought to himself but little did both of them know that everything was about to change.