The Covenant's Sin
Author's Note Okay, so I read this one Reid/Sarah/Tyler story and it made me realize that that would be really hot! And I went looking for others like it and couldn't find any, so I decided to write one myself! This is an M rated story, so consider yourself warned. Don't read if you don't like. If you're into threesomes, but not gayness, then this story is fine for you. If you know you won't like it and are only reading this for the sole reason of having someone to flame, then get the fuck out. If you flame, I'll question your intelligence and consider you one of the lower life forms on this planet.
Disclaimer I do not own the Covenant or any of its characters or settings. I'm sorry if this story resembles any others... I wrote it a long time ago in a notebook and only just found it now. So if it resembles someone else's story, I apologize to them, give them full credit, and will be more than willing to change it if they request. This disclaimer will count for the entire story.
Chapter 1
They stood outside looking anxiously around for any sign of Caleb. Their search was in vein, though, as they could see nothing of their friend; they could feel him though. Reid and Tyler felt him using – a lot. The two exchanged nervous glances over Sarah's head. Reid looked down at her as she shivered in the cool September breeze. Goosebumps exploded all over her bare shoulders and arms.
"You cold?" Reid inquired, even though he knew the answer. He just needed something to distract himself from the ongoing turmoil raging inside of him as his brother fought. The blond nodded numbly, rubbing her hands up and down her arms for warmth. Tyler made to take of his jacket for her when Reid held up a stopping hand. "Let's just go inside," he suggested, "It's bound to be warmer in there."
"Alright," Sarah agreed easily and led the way into the dance. Tyler and Reid followed a few paces behind.
"D'you think Caleb's alright?" Tyler asked quietly so Sarah wouldn't hear. She was, after all, Caleb's girlfriend and they didn't want to worry her any more than was necessary. She was already anxious.
Reid shrugged. "No doubt. It's Caleb, he's always alright. Until then we have to keep her distracted." Tyler nodded understandingly and they caught up with Sarah.
Inside, they stood to the side of the dance floor. Sarah was tense; Reid could see the muscles in her back knotted tightly. "C'mon," he said, lightly touching her lower back. "Let's dance, shall we?" Sarah smiled, looking relieved at a chance to forget about Caleb and the mortal peril she knew he was currently facing.
"Alright, let's go," she agreed, pulling him onto the dance floor as the last song ended and a new one immediately took its place. Sarah saw Tyler lean leisurely against the wall as she dragged Reid away. She stopped in the crowd and turned to face Reid, wrapping her arms around his neck. Reid's arms instinctively went around her waist and they swayed to the slow song, a respective distance between them.
He watched her when he knew she wasn't looking. She glanced around the room with those captivating blue eyes, a small smile gracing her perfectly shaped pink lips, and Reid, not for the first time, found himself hating Caleb for winning her. But he couldn't hate Caleb right now, or at least he shouldn't, because there was always that chance that he'd never see his covenant brother alive again. Tonight could be Caleb's death date.
As if reading his thoughts, the smile slowly slid from Sarah's face and she looked up at Reid, biting her lip nervously. That gesture was enough to drive Reid crazy and he wished she was his all the more. His thoughts, though, were interrupted by Sarah's soft voice.
"Caleb's going to be okay, right?"
Reid looked at her for a moment and then impulsively pulled her closer to him so their bodies were touching. What surprised him was the fact that she let him, and even hugged him closer.
"Of course he will. Don't worry about him; he can take care of himself. Just try thinking of something other than Caleb and try to have a good time tonight, alright?" He felt her nod against his chest and she pulled away from him as the song, regretfully, ended. Her face was stony. "C'mon, smile," he teased her gently. She gave him a small smile and Reid shoved his hands into his pockets, looking at her questioningly.
"You're being so weird tonight," she told him, her smile stretching wider to show her straight, white teeth. "The sensitive Reid; never thought I'd see the day..."
He laughed. "Well, I can go back to being an asshole if it makes you feel more comfortable."
It was Sarah's turn to laugh and the next song started up. It was a faster beat with a more hip hop rhythm to it.
Reid's mouth turned up into a mischievous smirk and he took his hands out of his pockets, holding them out to her. "Dance with me?"
Sarah's look was mischievous as well as she said, "I will in one second. Just wait right here, kay?" Reid looked at her quizzically, but agreed none the less. Who was he to say no to a beautiful girl? Sarah turned and blended into the crowd of dancers as she made her way back to the sidelines. She spotted Tyler in the same position they'd left him. He watched her as she approached him.
"Come dance with me," she proposed and grabbed his forearms, as his pocketed hands were unavailable.
"I can't dance," Tyler protested, though allowed her to continue towing him. They merged with the crowd and Sarah smiled almost seductively at him.
"I'll show you."
"But you've got Reid," Tyler pointed out.
Sarah smiled wickedly at him and, yes, that was definitely a seductive look on her face as they reached Reid and Tyler was released.
"Hey, baby boy," Reid greeted his friend as Sarah backed up into him and began grinding against him. Tyler stood alone, looking extremely uncomfortable.
"Why'd you drag me out here?" he asked, yelling above the music. "What am I supposed to do?"
Sarah reached forward and, without missing a beat, hooked her fingers in Tyler's belt loops and jerked him towards her. "You go in front," she said loudly in his ear, cheek pressed against his. Tyler gulped as she pulled his hips against hers and began moving him with him, her hands never leaving his hips. Reid smirked at the younger boy over the blonde's shoulder. Tyler looked like a lost puppy. Tyler glowered back.
Reid smiled. As much as he liked having Sarah pressed up against him like she was, Tyler needed the guidance, so he said to Sarah, mouth nearly touching her ear, "Turn around."
"What? Why?" Sarah asked, confused.
"Being in back's easier and take a look at Tyler." Reid replied. Sarah did so and laughed at the boy. He seemed to be concentrating, but he was still slightly off beat. She swung easily away from Reid and into Tyler. She looked over her shoulder at his surprised expression and smiled reassuringly, guiding his hands to her hips and then yanking Reid forward by his shirt. Reid laughed.
"That's how I like it," he said, "Good and rough." Sarah laughed, enjoying herself, all thoughts of Caleb gone from her mind. She was in the here and now and that was great. She looked around at the girls around her. She was the recipient of all their jealously because she was sandwiched between two of Spencer Academy's most eligible bachelors. Plus, Reid had probably slept with half of them, promised to call, and never followed through with it. She was the unanimously voted whore in the room at that moment and loved it.
"How's it going back there, Ty?" Sarah asked using Tyler's despised nick name and looking up and over her shoulder. Tyler's scowling face met her eyes and she grinned at him.
Reid recaptured her attention by asking seductively, "If I can guess what underwear you're wearing, will you show me?" Sarah grinned.
Her witty reply was, "If I can guess what underwear you're wearing, will you show me?"
Reid smirked. She was quick.
"Deal," he said. "White thong."
Sarah feigned hurt. "You really think I'm a thong kinda girl?"
Reid laughed.
"Nope," Tyler interrupted. "I'm gonna say... purple lace."
"Who said you were in on this?" Sarah playfully asked him.
"Well I'm in on it now," Tyler countered. "Your guess."
Sarah pondered for a moment. "Reid, I am going to say Christmas boxers." Reid laughed and Sarah continued. "And Tyler... blue boxers, probably with spaceships or something on them." She felt Tyler's chest rumble with laughter behind her and heard it in her right ear, felt his breath on her neck. "So am I right?" she asked curiously.
"I dunno, are we right?" Reid stalled eyes boring into her own.
"Let's go find out," she suggested devilishly, grabbing both boys hands in each of hers. She led them through the dancing students and into one of the alcoves harbouring an exit door. They were completely hidden from view in the dark cubby separated from the rest of the room. Tyler stood close to her, looking nervous, while Reid made his sneaky way toward the door.
"Here?" Tyler asked apprehensively.
Sarah glanced to the side, towards the rest of the room, before her hands reached out quickly and drew Tyler's face down to her own. She smashed her mouth against his lips, her hands entangling themselves in his hair. Tyler was stunned, but his first thought was She's Caleb's! and he pulled away. He looked bewilderedly down at her and she stared right back at him. Her tongue shot out to lick her wet, pouty lips and Tyler couldn't help himself. This time it was he who kissed her. He ran his tongue over her lips and they parted. He delved in, tasting her and revelling in it.
Next thing he knew he was being thrown backwards viciously, off of the seductive blond. His stomach dropped, thinking it was Caleb, but when he saw Reid's angry face his stomach only lifted a few inches. Sarah giggled, grabbed both their wrists and stealthy slipped out the door, the two boys in tow.
They scurried through Spencer's hallways, up a flight of stairs, and onto the floor of Reid and Tyler's dorm. Knowing now where they were going, Reid took the lead. When they reached their door, Tyler jammed his hand into his pocket in search of his key, but Reid was already Using to unlock the door. They piled in, short of breath. Tyler locked the door while Reid advanced on Sarah, who tried to look innocent as she was pinned to the wall by Reid.
"So was I right?" she asked coyly.
"Ladies first," Reid growled mockingly. Sarah pushed him away with her fingertips and backed him up until he stood beside Tyler.
She looked casually around the room, wasting time. She walked to the window and looked out at the dark campus. The reality finally hit her: her boyfriend was out there somewhere fighting for his life and she'd just dragged two of his best friends into their otherwise empty dorm room. She pushed the thought away. She needed the distraction and she'd already come this far... She wasn't the kind of girl to disappoint... She shut the blinds with a resounding snap. The street light was eliminated, the only source of illumination coming from one of the small lamps on the desk beside her.
Sarah turned and brandished at the zipper running up her spine, keeping her strapless gown wrapped tightly around her. "A little help boys?" She didn't hear either move to comply, but she felt the silky tendrils of their magic brush her back as her zipper seemingly undid itself. Back still turned, she slowly slid the dress down her torso, revealing her braless chest, over her hips, and down her legs, revealing her panties. She let the dress drop to the floor in a bundle around her ankles and stepped gracefully out of it, heels still on. She rotated to face the boys' still forms. She blushed slightly as their eyes roamed her body.
"Black silk," Reid finally said. He tore his eyes away from Sarah to observe Tyler's still motionless frame. "We were both wrong." Tyler reluctantly dragged his eyes away from Sarah to look at his friend as well.
"Uh huh," Sarah said, sauntering over to Reid. "Now it's your turn." Her hands found Reid's belt but he grabbed them tightly.
"If you're gonna start this, you'd better finish it, Sarah," he warned in a low growl, eyes brimming with barely contained lust.
"Reid, I wouldn't disappoint you," Sarah assured him huskily. The two boys looked at each other uncomfortably. Neither one wanted to see the other... 'in action', but it was obvious Sarah wanted both of them.
Tyler shook his head and held his hands up in surrender. "I won't look if you don't look," he bargained.
"Deal," Reid agreed and released Sarah's hands. She made quick work of his belt, fly, and button and his pants fell to the floor with a lot of jingling. He watched her as she lifted up the hem of his shirt and tens of Rudolf's faces peered up at her from a red background on his boxers.
"I was right," she gloated, playing with the waistband of his boxers and causing Reid's jaw to tighten and his eyes to narrow.
"I'm not complaining," he ground out between clenched teeth. Sarah smirked and moved on to Tyler, the baby of the Sons of Ipswich. He looked considerably more nervous than Reid.
Sarah captured his eyes with hers as she began undoing his belt.
"You aren't a virgin, are you, Tyler?" she inquired curiously. Reid she was sure was experienced, but Tyler was a mystery to her in pretty much every way. Reid laughed and Tyler shook his head no, apparently focusing on breathing in and out rather than wasting his precious air speaking. "That's good, or else this would be a very awkward first time, wouldn't it?" Sarah continued as she unclasped the button on his pants and thrust them to the floor. She proceeded to lift up the hem of his dress shirt and look down at his blue boxers patterned with little red cars and yellow trucks. She chuckled.
"Right again, Reid," she taunted, "This must be my lucky night."
"No," Tyler said, speaking for the first time since she'd unbuttoned Reid's pants. He stepped out of his pants and forced her back, Reid close behind him. "It's our lucky night." And with that she was picked up by Reid and thrown onto the nearest bed.
Author's Note Like it? Let me know in a review! I've already got the next chapter written up, all I'm asking for is 3 reviews!