Zoe Dawn is the best friend of the new doppelganger, Katelyn Flemming. When two mysterious new guys, brothers to be exact, come to town and enroll in Zoe's high school, Zoe falls hard for the older brother, Damon Salvatore. But Damon seems to have eyes for only Kate, like every other guy in their lives. It's always Kate.

After Elena's death, Damon and Stefan have grown closer. They are both devastated by the loss of the girl they both loved, Elena Gilbert, but they plan to forget about her together, as brothers. What happens when a new doppelganger is discovered, and both brothers fall for her? Will their new brotherhood be destroyed, or will Damon realize that he loves Zoe?