**A/N: Okay so this is y very first GLEE fanfiction! I'm excited!
There's no need for like a GIGANTIC author's note here, so i won't put one.
Just know that each chapter is a different song. I do suggest listening to it
so you can get a whole feel of the chapter and what is going on.
Each chapter has a FLASHBACK which will occur first
and then go into PRESENT day.
The song will work with the flashback and the present day.
ENJOY! OH! ALSO KNOW THAT REVIEWS=CHAPTERS!
Summary: In Lima there was the Fantastic Four: Puck, Finn, Kurt and his cousin Marilynn. Add two guys, vying for one girl. One wins, the other loses. He breaks her heart, she leaves but for reasons unknown. The world goes into rotation known now, Puck and Finn are the school jocks and Kurt? Well he's part of the Glee Club. Marilynn left two years ago and now, she's back. Will everything be the same? PuckxOCxFinn
Chapter One: Whatcha Say?
"Whatcha say?
Oh that you've only been where?
Oh well of course you did
Ooh whatcha say?
Ooh that's all for best
Because it is..."
-Jason Derulo "Whatcha Say"
June 14 2008
Tears flowed from her eyes as she threw her backpack onto the couch with anger. She had every right to be angry; she was angry at one person and of course that one person reminded her why you never think your in love at the stupid age of 13.
He was the reminder that you don't fall in love in a small cow town like Lima, Ohio. People who stay here didn't make it far in life. She heard stories of people who were destined for greatness, only to stay behind, like Brian Ryan.
Yeah sure he was supposed to be this huge star when he was in high school, but it failed and now here he is, back in this god forsaken cow town and living next door belting out showtunes when his wife isn't home.
Her shoulders began to shake from holding back the tears thay refused to shed; it was him that convinced her when they were younger that crying was for the weak and her wanting to be part of his lífe, didnt cry.
But he did this to her, and she had to let it out, like her own little way of letting him go. So once that single tear fell from her eye, the rest was history.
Suddenly, like true maternal instinct, the young girls mother knocked on the door. "Honey? Honey whats wrong? Why the tears? Did that Jacob Ben Israel harrass you again? I could hace sworn I told his mother about his antics.." the crying girl shakes her head no, only to further baffle her mom. "What is it then?"
The small girl with amazing brown eyes, just like her dad, looks into the hazel eyes of her mom. Finally she fines the courage to stop crying, if only for a moment to open her mouth and speak. "I want to move to New York with daddy. I miss him so much and I think I want to live with him for a while..." she lied. She couldnt tell her mother the truth, that the reason she wanted out of this cow town was because id her former favorite reason. There was no way she was telling her mother that tidbit of information, so she settled for the lie of missing her father, who her mom divorced two years back.
And with that lie, the young girls mom called her husband and arranged for their daughter to move to New York. That was the last summer Marilynn Evans was in Lima, Ohio.
September 5 2010
"Kurt, for the last time my face does not need to be...exfoiliated" Finn Hudson yelled, swatting his soon-to-be brother in law Kurt Hummel. The duo was such a hap-hazard mix, it was a mystery on how they agreed to share a room. "I don't know what 'exfoiliate' means anyway"
Kurt, the obvious diva of the two, rolled his eyes and huffed loudly. Folding his arms and pushing his hair from his face, he looked down at Finn. "You are such a neanderthal I hope you realize that Finn. No one in this house are going to have pores the size of Lindsay Lohan's legal problems, and that's pretty huge"
"What do my pores have to do with anything?" Finn asked with his head in his hands, groaning at Kurt and his antics. "I just asked a question-"
"Yeah you asked a pretty loaded question there Finny boy. You asked what was wrong with your face to make little miss Rachel 'Gold Star' Berry not like you like she likes Vocal Adrenaline lead Jesse St. James" Kurt answered as he sat on the drab cream couch him and Finn agreed on when they decided to decorate the room together. Leaning his left arm on the arm rest he exhaled "therefore I proceeded to tell you that you needed to exfoiliate your pores because they're the size of god forsaken hockey pucks"
"I doubt girls care about my pores Kurt...especially girls like Rachel" Finn mumbled before sitting on the other end of the couch and grabbing the remote. Kurt rolled his eyes as Finn smiled at the baseball game on television.
"Those baseball uniforms are hideous. I mean seriously, pinstripes? If numbers 2, 13 and 25 didn't fill it out so lovely, I'd not like the Yankees" Kurt chuckled as Finn groaned
"Normally I'd be weirded out by that remark, but I'm sick at the fact you just openly admitted that you like the Yankees when clearly the Indians are the better team" Finn corrected staring at Kurt.
Kurt looked at the screen and smiled "Oh yes, the team whose mascot are the people we enslaved and took land from. Hence why we are called...Yankees Finn" Kurt informed as Finn's face contorted into a scowl, and then into pure confusion. "Besides if the Indians were the better and more superior team, why is the score 5-0 in favor of the Yankees? I mean can't the Indians score a damn homerun?"
Finn began to open his mouth in a heated debate like he always had done with Hummel over sports that he just didn't understand, when the doorbell rang. Sighing he smiled "Thank you...the pizza is here. I'm starved"
"Greasy pizza is the reason why your T-Zone is so oily" Kurt mumbled as he started picking at his nails.
Finn grunted as he walked to the door. How he deals with this is beyond him, but now he's stuck. Thanks to Kurt for linking his dad and Finn's mom together, he's now into the shenanigans. Finn turned the knob and reached into his pocket, fishing out the twenty he stashed there to pay for the pizza. "So how much is the pizza...?" Finn asked as he looked up at the person at the door, losing all train of thought. Smiling, Finn inhaled and began to yell "Kurt! Kurt, get upstairs quick!"
Mere moments later, Kurt emerged with his Marc Jacobs wallet that he refused to believe was a knockoff and pulling out extra cash. "Did you not have enough to cover the pizza? Jesus Finn..." Kurt stopped to smile.
He took in the figure of the person in front of. Wearing black Ugg boots with white trimming, skinny black jeans that hugged her thin legs and decent thighs; the jeans complimented her gray tank that was under her white and gray polo shirt completely unbuttoned. Her smile was bright and she finally decided to listen after all those years and wore her hair short and wavy. Her brown eyes wide and cheeks pink.
"Jesus, a girl comes home and two men offer her money? I need to leave more often" she giggled as she watched the two guys smile "I missed you too, New York was great, yes I'm here to stay...and now here's the part where you just enjoy my presence"
Kurt was the first to move and hug the girl with a huge smile on his face. Letting go of his embrace, he took the sight of her in again and exhaled "Marilynn Evans. It's been entirely too long"
"Well it's nice to see some things haven't changed. Hummel and Hudson around me; it's like I never left" Marilynn giggled. The two chuckled nervously.
"Finn actually lives here. Our parents are..." Kurt started before Finn cleared his throat
"My mom and I moved in because Kurt hooked our parents up and now they're dating and whatever." Finn continued. "What brings you back to Lima? Was New York too much of a bore for you or something?"
Marilynn chuckled and leaned against the doorframe of the Hummel/Hudson home. "Actually my dad got a job in London. I didn't want to move and with the death of my mom, I had nowhere else to go. I called Uncle Burt at the shop, by the way he's totally not happy with long distance calls apparently"
"Yeah, you know my dad is frugal. I'm surprised that I still have my car and the fabulous things I own" Kurt smiled "But continue on darling"
"Well Uncle Burt decided to take in a certain niece of his so she can finish her schooling here in Lima" Marilynn continued, nodding over to her luggage and her black H2 truck. "So, are my darling cousin Kurt and childhood buddy Finn going to just stand there or help me move my crap inside?"
The two boys smiled and helped move Marilynn's stuff into the home. Once Marilynn was settled in she went down to Kurt and Finn's room, and sat between the two with her head in Kurt's lap and her legs across Finn's.
It was moments like these that made Marilynn not mind coming home, as long as they would always be like this. The one person she hadn't thought about in so long was distant from her mind as she laughed with her family and her friend she considered family.
"Welcome home Marilynn" Finn said as he stretched over her legs for another slice of pizza. "Nothing says the end of a great summer like pizza, a good baseball game and the return of an old face"
Marilynn smiled and giggled at Finn's response. "Thanks Finn" she replied sweetly "Now shush, Mark Teixiera is on"
Finn groaned "Not you too...!" through his hands and Kurt chuckled. Yep, Marilynn Evans is home.
REVIEW!