Chapter 1 – In Godric's Hollow
Lily felt uneasy. Even though they had rattled out Peter as the rat, she was worried. The prophecy was still intact. She was worried about Alice, Frank and Augusta. She was worried about all the deaths, and how Severus knew of Remus' furry little problem. But in a sense, she was glad. Glad that Sirius, James' best friend, offered to be their secret keeper even though when he knew of the risk. Glad that Petunia would take good care of Harry if anything happened to James and her. Glad that Severus would look over Harry.
But in all her thinking, there was a problem. Sirius had flooed in and told James how Voldermort was coming for them. Prongs had a plan though.
3 months later
Lily couldn't believe it. Even though it happened 3 months ago, Voldermort had survived the Killing Curse.
The day after, she rushed to Dumbledore's office in order to find out why Voldermort hadn't died. " Ah, my dear Lily. You see, there once was a young wizard here by the name of Tom Marvolo Riddle. Otherwise known as Voldermort. I tried to get a memory out of Horace Slughorn, but he had tampered with it. This was why I needed you back. Lily, Horace likes collecting rare things, or people. You are one of his most prized collections. I need you to get the real memory back. To find out what happened that night when Tom changed from smart to cunning."
Lily had tea with Horace. She went on his walks with him. She even started taking Liquid Luck before she realised what was wrong. Horace! He never drank pumpkin juice! Yet, the other night, as she was walking down to Hagrid's hut with him, he said he was drinking pumpkin juice out of a little bottle. She told James immediately. James knew what was going on. A Death Eater had disguised as Horace to get her secret keeper's name so Voldermort could torture them.
Lily had contacted Dumbledore immediately. She told Dumbledore of her suspicions and James'.
A week later in the prophet, it said that there was no more killings, and all of the death eaters had been removed. Lily though this was a tad bit suspicious. But no one else did. No one but Augusta.