Last year when Quinn cheated on Sam he promised himself that he will never fall in love with Quinn EVER again. But you can't control your heart. And now Sam Evans is falling in love with Quinn Fabray once again.
When he came back to Ohio he likes Mercedes and when Quinn told him to try again he refused it. Because he know that Quinn just saying it to get Beth back. And he started to chase Mercedes. They kissed. She broke up with Shane. She felt bad and told him they can't date.
Then they won at Regionals. They went Finn and Rachel's wedding but it cancelled because of the accident. Now Quinn can't walk. And every day Sam wishes that he can help Quinn with everything she's been through. But now she and Joe are dating. Actually he is happy 'cause Joe is a good guy. But it's still hurting to see them holding hands.
He decided to show his feelings with a song. But he doesn't know what others will say 'cause Quinn have boyfriend. But he has to do this. If he don't tell his feelings he will explode.
Today is the day. He enter the choir room and see Quinn talking with girls. He sit and wait for . When he came in Sam stand up and said:
" I prepared something may I sing?"
"Of course Sam."
While these are happening Quinn was sitting wondering what Sam will sing. He got up and got his guitar, he pull a chair and sit down. When the song started Santana said:
"Really Trouthy, Bieber again?"
But he didn't care.
Everybody's laughing in my mind
Rumors spreadin' 'bout this other guy
Do you do what you did when you did with me,
Does he love you the way I can?
Did you forget all the plans that you made with me
Cause baby I didn't
(Chorus)
That should be me holding your hand
That should be me making you laugh
That should be me this is so sad
That should be me that should be me
That should be me feeling your kiss
That should be me buying you gifts
This is so wrong
I can't go on
'Til you believe that
That should be me
That should be me
You said you needed a little time for my mistakes
It's funny how you used that time to have me replaced
Did you think that I wouldn't see you out at the movies
What you doin' to me
You're taking him where we used to go
Now if you're tryin' to break my heart
It's working cause you know that
(Chorus)
That should be me holding your hand
That should be me making you laugh
That should be me this is so sad
That should be me that should be me
That should be me feeling your kiss
That should be me buying you gifts
This is so wrong
I can't go on
'Till you believe
That should be me
I need to know should I fight for love
Or disarm
It's getting harder to shield
It's breaking my heart
Ooooh, ohhh
That should be me holding your hand
That should be me making you laugh
That should be me this is so sad
That should be me that should be me
That should be me feeling your kiss
That should be me buying you gifts
This is so wrong
I can't go on
'Till you believe
That that should be me(Holding your hand)
That should be me
(The one making you laugh) (oh baby oh)
That should be me
That should be me
(Buying you flowers)
That should be me
(Talking for hours oh)
That should be me
That should be me
That should be me
Never should've let you go, I never should've let you go
That should be me, I never should've let you go
That should be me
Sam finished the song and sit. He now that girls are looking at him, boys don't understand what this song about so they don't really care. But Joe was looking at him.
Quinn thinked about the day he first sing Bieber. He said that he was singing Baby to her like all the other song he sings. But they were dating that day and now she have another boyfriend. But what if this song is about Sam and her?
When the bell ring Sam rushed out 'cause he don't want to talk with anyone. Quinn called his name but he didn't look back. She think about chasing him but she can't catch him with a wheelchair. When everyone is out she take Santana and Rachel to a corner, and asked:
"Who do you think Sam sang that song?"
They both said at the same time:
"To you."
"Are you sure?" Santana said that:
"Think about all the exes of Sam. You, me and Mercedes. It's not me, it's not Mercedes 'cause she don't have a boyfriend and this song is about a girl with a girlfriend and this gives us the answer YOU"
"But I cheated on him why would he will love me again?"
This time Rachel answered:
"Think about me and Finn. When I learned about he and Santana last year, I was so mad. But then I forgive him. But before that I made out with Puck and he forgived me too. This is how love works. You always forgive the one you love."
Then Santana asked the important question:
"But do you love him or are you in love with Joe?"
And that's the problem, she don' really get over Sam but she likes Joe and she don't want to make Joe sad. So she told them the truth:
"I still love Sam, I never stop."
They both stayed in silence. At last Rachel answered:
"Then you know what to do."
Yeah she know but it's not that easy.