A/N: In this story, Sam is Rachel's boyfriend that Quinn's crushing on and Finn is the boy Rachel cheated with.
Chapter 1
Mr. Shue passed out the sheet music to the Club. Rachel looked at the music.
"Excuse me, this isn't the right key," Rachel said, obviously Mr. Shue had given her Quinn's part or something.
"No. It's actually the right key," Mr. Shue said, a bit amused that Rachel was correcting him so early in the morning.
"No, no, this is the alto part," Rachel said.
" Yep. Quinn's doing the solo," he replied.
"I'm sorry, there must be some sort of mix up. I thought I made it very clear that anything from "West Side Story" goes to me. Maria is my part! Natalie Wood was a Jew, you know. I've had a very deep, personal connection to this role since the age of one," Rachel was getting ticked.
"Well, I'm trying to shake things up a bit. Get us out of our boxes," Mr. Shue said.
"You're being cruel!" Rachel snapped. Only she could get away with this behavior. She was the star!
"I think you're being irrational," Will said calmly.
"I think you're being unfair to me!" Rachel said.
"I think you're being unfair to Quinn, who might have been happy about getting her first solo," Mr. Shue said.
"Quinn knows that she's not ready for such an iconic role as Maria. She can't do it!" Rachel snapped.
Meanwhile, Mercedes has been looking over the sheet music.
"Wait… I'm a Jet?" she said.
Rachel turned on her heel and stormed out. The whole club looked after her, Tina and Mercedes looked like they might do a Rachel, and Sam was thinking about running after her.
"Congratulations, Quinn. This is going well," Will said to Quinn, who looked uncomfortable.
