Disclaimer: I do not own Pretty Little Liars.

What you need to know about this story

Jason, Spencer, and Noel are full siblings (I just thought that would be interesting)

Jason just graduated school but wants to wait a year before going to college

Jason is not related to Alison

There is no A

Alison is alive (if I include her in the story)

The couple will be Aria/ Ezra/ Jason triangle (tell me which one you want to end up together in the end), Hanna/Caleb, and obviously, Spencer/Toby.

Jenna and Toby are full siblings (Jenna is his older sister)

This story is AU

A/N: I wanted to start this story after I finished "I Trusted You" but this wouldn't get out of my mind so I am going to at least start this story and if you like it, I'll continue.

Spencer (P.O.V)

I get up to get ready for school. I just put on a simple t-shirt and dark skinny jeans with black feminine combat boots.

I try to be quick because Toby, my best friend, is picking me up.

We have been best friends since eighth grade when I started tutoring him in French. Now we are in our junior year of high school and practically inseparable. People often mistake us for a couple except for the rest of our group, Hanna, Caleb, Aria, Jason, Emily, Paige, and Noel. We understand though, we do often act like a couple. Sometimes we hold hands, and one time he lost a bet and had to give me a piggy back ride to each class.

The truth is, I do want to be with him. But there is one problem.

I hear him beep his horn so I run outside and hop into the passenger of his truck.

"Hey, Spence." He says with a smile. "Hi Toby!"

"I have news." He says.

"What is it?" I ask.

"I have a date tonight." Surprise, surprise.

"Who is it this time?"

That is the problem he is going out with a new girl every other day. He never sleeps with them or anything, but he still flirts with them, say something about liking them for a really long time (which is a lie) and then dumps them a couple days later. He never did that to me though. I am sort of the limit. He respects me too much to try something like that on me. The girls he usually ask out are slutty.

He wasn't always like this. It was after I had my first boyfriend, Wren Kingston last year. We broke up, and Toby started going out with every girl in school. Unfortunately, as his best friend, I have to hear about his latest conquest.

"Spencer?" He asks.

"What?"

"You zoned out. What's on your mind?"

"Nothing, it's just that I have a math test today."

"I know when you're lying Spencer, you can tell me. We tell each other everything." I hear the concern in his voice. He is an amazing friend to me and the others. He really is a good person, so I don't know why he does what he does.

"I'm really tired." I know he doesn't believe me but he doesn't ask any further questions.

Toby (P.O.V)

Spencer seems to have something on her mind, but she wouldn't tell me. She is my best friend and I wouldn't want her to be upset.

In an attempt to cheer her up if she is upset, I pull over and ask her to get something from the store. She looks at me weirdly but does it.

When she walks away, I can't help but check her out. I have never told anyone this, but I really like her. I have ever since she tutored me in French. I don't think she feels the same way, though.

When she comes back with a bottle of water she goes to reach for the door handle but I keep making the truck move so she can't get in.

"Toby let me in!" She yells while laughing.

"Sorry what was that?" I ask. She keeps laughing, knowing that I'm joking. I have done this to her plenty of times before. I'm surprised that she still falls for it!

All of a sudden she stops laughing and has a scared expression on her face. She points to my left, so I look in that direction to see what's scaring her and then I hear a thud. Spencer got in through the window.

"Why didn't you get in through the door?!" I question.

"You would have enough time to keep moving the car!" She replies.

We get to school and walk in together. At Spencer's locker, awaits our other friends, Aria, Hanna, and Emily.

"Hey Tobes." Hanna says. The other girls smile and wave. I wave back and turn to Spencer. "Well, bye Spencer." I gave her a quick hug and left. I walk over to Caleb and Noel, and when they notice me, Caleb asks, where have you been? You got here after me, and you know how late I usually am."

"I was giving Spencer a ride." I answer.

"You do that everyday. Did something happen?" Noel asks suggestively. I punch him semi-hard in the shoulder.

"No I wouldn't let her get in the car. Whenever she tried I would start driving."

"When will you guys be a couple already?" Caleb asks. I mentally face palm.

Spencer (P.O.V)

The girls are looking at me with weird looks on their faces. They are smiling too much.

"What is with you?" I ask them as I get my books out of my locker.

"Someone likes Toby!" Oh yeah. I told them last night about my feelings for him.

*Flash back*

I am hanging out with the girls in my room, and we are all talking about relationships. First, it was "Haleb" , how Caleb asked Hanna out last week and how amazing their first date was. Then, it was "Jaria" where we comforted her about how my brother, Jason is constantly acting like an idiot. Finally, we talked about "Paily" and how sweet Paige is. Emily is very much in love with her.

I thought we were done when of course, I was forced to talk about Toby.

"So, how is our beloved Spoby?" Hanna asks. Yes, she is the one to come up with the couple names for all of our relationships.

"Hanna, there is no such thing and probably never will be, no matter how much I want to be with him." Oops.

Aria gasps, but smiles. Hanna playfully starts hitting me in the arm, screaming, "I knewwwww itttttttt!" I bury my face in a pillow, embarassed. I didn't mean to tell them, I wasn't thinking.

"Please don't tell him that I said that!" Emily pats my back and says, "It's okay Spence, we won't!" while laughing.

"For what it's worth, I think he likes you too. Maybe he'll ask you out." I take my face out of my pillow.

"No, he can't." I say.

"Why not?" Hanna asks, sounding a little sad.

"He asks out every girl in school! I don't want to be like any of those other girls."

*End of flashback*

"Guys, be cool, please?" I plead.

"Okay, but you should really tell him. Tonight." Emily suggests.

"I can't. He has a date tonight."

"Again? What happened to Courtney?" Hanna asks.

"He dumped her, remember?" the girls roll their eyes, unamused.

Noel (P.O.V)

Caleb and I know that Toby likes Spencer, but we can't say anything to the girls.

"Just ask her out and go on more than one date with her! We know you like her."

"I said that when I was drunk, guys! We are just friends!"

Yeah, sure.

A/N: I hope you like this story so far. This idea has always been in my mind and now I am actually writing it. Tell me if you would like me to continue it. If you do, also tell me if you want a one shot that has to do with this story about how their friendship was or a chapter about it.

Please review!