So this story is completely different from the show; they're all humans except for Stefan and Damon, and Bonnie is still a witch. And before we get into the story, you should know a couple things so you'll get it. Katherine has bleach blonde hair and blue eyes. Basically Elena, but it would be weird to have them look exactly alike with them both being humans. So basically, Katherine looks like the Elena in the book, and Elena is the Elena on the show.
But this is still set in Mystic Falls with the same characters, just different story :)
And warning you now, Stefan will seem like a complete jerk and douche in the beginning. But it'll all work out :)
****This is also M for a reason. There will be a lot of sex and partying and everything. I'm warning you now!****
"New Year, new us." Katherine Pierce told Stefan Salvatore with a grin as they pulled into the school parking lot.
"Yep." Stefan said with a nod of his head. He knew it was a lie. For the past two years, ever since they were freshmen, they have been dating. Now, their junior year, and since then, their relationship has been filled with fights and unhappiness. Katherine only said that at the beginning of every school year to give them false hope.
Stefan parked his vintage red car in his assigned school parking spot, the two teens getting out of the car.
"There's Matt and Bonnie!" Katherine said enthusiastically, running towards her two friends. Stefan just sighed and followed.
"Hey, you two." Bonnie Bennett said with a light smile, hugging Katherine. She went to hug Stefan, but Katherine gave her a look that made Bonnie freeze. Stefan rolled his eyes and hugged Bonnie anyways.
"How's the golden couple?" Matt Donovan asked, and Stefan instantly felt annoyed.
Everyone at Mystic Falls High School called them the golden couple because on paper, they were. Katherine was the captain of the cheer and track team, while Stefan lead the school in football, basketball and soccer. Everyone girl wanted Stefan, and every guy wanted Katherine. Their relationship seemed perfect.
He liked Katherine, that was for sure. And he of course thought she was gorgeous. And he did love her, just not in the way she loved him. He only took interest in her once he would catch himself getting jealous freshman year when he saw upperclassmen hit on her. Shortly after, he asked her out.
Sure, he took satisfaction in the fact that literally every single male on campus was jealous of him being able to bang her every time he wanted to. But that was just what was basically there, emotion wise.
And even then, sex was just... sex. He felt absolutely nothing in his heart or in his head. He only felt with his lower half when it came to Katherine. Katherine having a perfectly sexy body just made it easier.
"We're doing okay." Stefan told him, forcing a smile.
"Better than okay!" Katherine added. "We went to a beach Italy during the summer, just the two of us! My parents finally let us do it!" Katherine beamed. Matt shot Stefan a knowing smile, making Stefan chuckle to himself.
"I have to tell you all about it." Katherine told Bonnie, pulling them away from Matt and Stefan.
"So who's the girl?" Matt asked knowingly, making Stefan laugh.
"I think her name was Isabelle. Or something. I can't remember. She was a native, though." Stefan told him.
On the second to last night of Stefan and Katherine in Italy, him and Katherine got in a fight, making Stefan storm out into the night, heading straight towards the nearest bar. Next thing he knew, he was fucking a leggy Italian Brunette in the bathroom. Just to let off steam.
Stefan didn't have to cheat. He didn't even feel like cheating. He doesn't like it, either. He only does it to get the anger out of his body.
"Man, come on. You can't keep doing this, it's like the second or third time. Katherine's a good girl... when she wants to be." Matt told him, slapping him on the back.
"I know. It's just... she makes me so mad. It's the only way I know of to let off steam. To get back at her." Stefan explained. He knew Matt didn't have much room to talk, he was the one who taught Stefan his ways of cheating without getting caught.
Matt just nodded. "Just don't get caught. She'll kill the girl. And then kill you."
Stefan understood. He once fucked one of the away team's cheerleaders after a football game last year under the bleachers. While Katherine didn't know about that certain detail, she only knew they had a conversation, Katherine single-handedly ended the girl's reputation. Stefan felt bad, but quickly got over it. He wasn't supposed to care about one night stands.
"Matt, Stefan! Hey!" Tyler Lockwood yelled, running to catch up with his friends. Stefan inwardly sighed a breath of relief. If anyone was truly in love with Katherine, it was Tyler. He would do anything for her. While they were almost like brothers, Tyler would run to Katherine the second he found out about anything that had to deal with Stefan and another girl.
"Hey! How was your summer?" Stefan asked him.
"Pretty chill. Nothing really went on, other than Caroline Forbes sneaking into my window some nights." Tyler said with a sly grin, earning pats on the back and claps from his two best friends.
"She's like the prudest one of all! How'd you do that?" Matt laughed, and Stefan scrunched his nose. He knew he wasn't one to talk, but one thing that did separate him from Matt and Tyler is that he respected girls. Which sounded weird, because he cheated on the girl he's supposed to respect the most as many times as he could.
"Magic." Tyler said with a snap of his fingers and a slight smile.
"Even though it's not real." Said Stefan, rolling his eyes.
"You're a wizard, Stefan!" Matt exclaimed in a funny accent, making the three boys laugh.
"Close," Stefan said before sitting down on a bench outside of the entrance to the school, his friends sitting next to him.
And in a way, Matt was close. But Stefan wasn't a wizard, he was a vampire. Him and his brother, Damon Salvatore. Ever since 1864. They were turned by a girl named Violet Shaw, who they were both in love with. She told them the only reason they would be with her is if they turned. So she made them into vampires. But the moment the two brothers woke up, Violet was gone.
So now, mostly the reason why he cheats on Katherine is so he can feed on a human before doing his dirty work with her. He cares about Katherine too much to feed on her. He came close, but he can't let Katherine know who he is. He wouldn't even be able to compel her to forget, because he's been slipping liquid vervain in all of her drinks since they started dating so Damon wouldn't pull one of his compulsion tricks to get her to do things Stefan won't approve of. Stefan just found it easier to cheat. But he wouldn't consider this reason cheating.
None of his friends knew his secret. And he didn't know of any other of his kind in Mystic Falls. But Stefan wasn't one to start trouble. He liked living the life as a human, even though he was stuck at 17 forever. He couldn't say the same for Damon, though.
"Who is that?" Tyler asked the two, and Stefan noticed he zoned out a whole conversation. He looked up in time to see a girl with a very thin, tall body, tan skin, long brown hair and deep brown eyes getting out of a car, along with some random kid who looked young enough to be the girl's brother.
"She looks way too much like Katherine. That's creepy." Matt said, even though he was still staring.
Stefan felt the area under his eyes start to swell with a mixture of blood and adrenaline. This happened to him every time he saw someone hot, or even if he was just hungry.
But something was different. Usually he'd pull this type of girl into a dark corner, feed, have sex and then compel her to forget what happened. But not this one. Stefan had to know her.
"Stefan, you alright?" Matt asked, and Stefan immediately rubbed his eyes to get rid of the veins. When he looked up, they were gone.
"I'm fine." Stefan said with a smile. "I'll be right back."
Stefan could hear Tyler and Matt's conversation as they walked into the school, but his mind was set on this one girl.
"Need any help?" Stefan asked as he approached the girl. She turned towards him and raised a perfect eyebrow.
"Getting a backpack out of a car?" She asked him, crossing her arms. It was insane how much she looked, and even acted, like Katherine. But Stefan knew she was different. She had to be.
"Yeah," Stefan said with a sigh and a slight chuckle, taking another step closer. "That's something called a pick-up line."
Stefan earned a laugh from the girl, and it was like music to his ears. Stop it, Stefan. He thought to himself. You have a girlfriend.
Yeah, one that doesn't mean shit to you.
"I'm Elena Gilbert." The girl said with a smile, stretching a hand out. Stefan took it and shook, holding her hand a second longer than he needed.
"I'm Stefan Salvatore." He told her as they started walking into the school, just in time for the bell to right.
"You're a junior too, right?" Elena asked him. Stefan nodded as he turned the corner into his calculus classroom. He noticed Elena followed him.
"You're in this class too?" He asked, and he couldn't help smiling.
"That's what the schedule says." Elena laughed. She took the seat next to Stefan, and Stefan cringed.
"What?" Elena asked. Stefan was about to answer, but then Katherine walked into the classroom, so he decided to just point at her instead.
"What are you doing in my seat?" Katherine asked Elena was false sweetness and a toxic smile. Stefan sunk low in his seat to avoid either of the girls' gazes.
"I didn't know we had assigned seats." Elena said calmly, even though she gathered her stuff and started to move to a spot diagonal from Stefan. Katherine just looked after her.
"Who is she to think she can sit next to you?" Katherine asked Stefan. Stefan just sighed.
Halfway through the lecture, Stefan started to get bored. He was looking around the classroom when he noticed Elena was looking back at him. She smiled slightly and gave a small wave of her fingers.
Instantly, thoughts of Elena flooded his head.
They were in his room on his bed, Stefan on top of Elena. Elena clawed at his back violently as she moaned loudly, Stefan pumping in and out of her hard and fast. Elena's fingernails started to draw blood from Stefan's back, but it healed quicker than she made the wounds.
"Oh GOD, Stefan!" Elena screamed as he easily and effortlessly tossed one of her long legs over his shoulder, going deeper. She reached up and traced his veins on his eyes making a loud moan rip through his chest. Her hands moved to his perfect biceps and even more perfect abdomen, making Stefan push into her harder.
"Fuck, STEFAN!"
Stefan shook his head quickly, getting rid of the thoughts in his head. Elena turned away from him now, paying attention to the lecture. He looked over to Katherine, who was too busy painting her nails to notice anything else.
Stefan raised his hand quickly, his teacher calling on him.
"May I use the restroom?" He asked. He was out the door before the teacher could even say the full word "yes".
He walked into the hallway straight for the water fountain, needing to cool down.
"Stefan?" He heard that voice ask. He could only hear what it would sound like screaming.
"Oh God." Stefan groaned quietly, taking deep breaths. He felt like he was a fourteen year old virgin by the way he was acting so nervous.
"Stefan?" Elena asked again, peeking her head into the men's restroom. "Are you okay?"
"Yeah, I'm fine." He said quickly, leaning over a sink, gripping it tightly with both hands.
"You don't look okay." She said calmly, walking closer.
"I am." He said even quicker.
"Are you sure?" She asked, resting a hand on his. Before she could even blink, Stefan had her pinned against the wall, holding her face in his hands. He gave in and kissed her, long and hard. Stefan picked her up and allowed her to wrap her legs around his strong waist as he pushed his body onto hers. One hand left her face to grab the hem of her shirt. When he pulled away, Elena was almost panting, her eyes still closed.
"We barely know each other. What was that for?" Elena breathed, even though her hands found their way to his hair, pulling his roots softly. Stefan just looked at her, somewhat shocked at what he did. He just kissed a girl he rarely knew not even twenty feet from his girlfriend. It was as if someone else was controlling him. And that someone else was obsessed with this girl in front of him.
"Well?" Elena asked, yanking Stefan's head closer to hers. One of her hands found the tops of his jeans while the other pulled at his hair, her back arched into his chest. "Are you going to kiss me again?"
And he did.
I hope you liked this first chapter! x
For all of you who want to know what Violet looks like, because I made her up, she looks like Cara Delevingne. For those who don't know who that is, here you go!: .
please read and review, it will mean a lot 3
