I'm starting a new series of one-shots. I love that couple and they deserved a proper ending in the show. I'll still carry on with my other stories. I hope you enjoy these stories. I have quite a few planned out but if any of you want to send me prompts, I will gladly write something for you. They'll be of varying length and rating.
This one-shot is set at the end of Season 2 and it's what happens after Jesse is kicked out of the prom. Rachel didn't sing "Jar of Hearts" at the prom since she is NOT hung up on Finn.
It's Always Been You
Jesse and Finn have been kicked out of the prom and now Quinn is glaring at me like it was personally my fault. It's not my fault that Finn decided he couldn't handle seeing me with my prom date. He already has the prom date and now he wants the glee loser? I don't think so.
Quinn comes storming towards me with a glare on her face. I kind of wanted the ground to swallow me up.
"You couldn't handle the fact that Finn is happy could you?" Quinn fumed.
"As if. I invited Jesse to come with me remember? Why would I do that if I was still hung up on Finn?"
"You can see that he's happy again and you can't handle it." she insisted.
"I'm not having this conversation with you Quinn, I'm going to go and find my prom date. If you have a problem with what happened, go and talk to your date, princess." I said harshly and walked away before she had a chance to say anything else.
I found him in the parking lot, leaning against his car. When he saw me, he smiled brightly. "Ahh, there you are. I was waiting for you."
I stood in front of him and put my hands around his waist. "I'm sorry for what happened in there." I said.
He shook his head. "No, I'm sorry. I should never have retaliated in the way I did." He then ran a hand down my face. "I'm sorry you have to carry on with your prom without a date."
I looked up into his eyes. "You think I'm going back in there without you?" I asked. I chuckled. "I'm not." I told him.
He smiled. "What does this mean?" he asked, gesturing to the both of us.
"What do you want it to mean?" I asked. I shrugged, even if I knew what I wanted it to mean. He smiled good-naturedly. "Ok, I'll tell you what I want it to mean. You, Rachel Berry, are one of a kind. You and I are the same and not in a bad way. You're everything I want Rachel Berry and not just because you are determined and head-strong, bossy and stubborn." I'm confused, I thought he was trying to tell me how much he wanted us to be together. "On the other hand, you're beautiful, kind, caring and loving." He told me. I beamed. "You're everything I want." He repeated.
I smiled happily. Even if it is what I wanted to hear, it was nice to actually hear. I crashed into his chest and hugged him tightly. I heard him chuckle and then hug me back.
"That ok with you?" he asked before kissing the top of my head. I simply nodded. I then heard him chuckle again.
We stayed this for a couple of moments before I looked up at him. I took a deep breath and chose my words very carefully. "It's always been you." I told him. The next thing I felt was his lips on mine. It was a passionate kiss, yet it was also soft and sweet.
"It's you and me now." He told me. "I'm sorry for everything that happened in the past." He told me. I shook my head.
"We're not apologizing for that anymore." I told him urgently. "Just don't egg me again and we'll be fine." I said angrily.
He chuckled again. "Scouts honour." He told me. He then looked down at me. "Shall we go and find somewhere where you can put that beautiful dress to good use?"
I nodded wordlessly at him. He kissed me on my forehead and took my hand. "Get in the car then." He ordered.
I walked round to the passenger side of the car. Just as I was about to get in, I saw Finn staring at me and I knew he'd seen everything between me and Jesse. What did I do? I got in the car with my new boyfriend and went in search of somewhere where we could dance. Finn and I are over.