I saw this on Pinterest and I had to write it. This is an au sort of. I hoped you enjoy it.
Caitlin asked Barry if he thought she was pretty. "What's this about? he asked putting down his book. Instead of answering she asked him same question as before " Do you think I'm pretty?" "No," he replied a little exasperated. She asked him if he wanted to be with her forever, he said " No." Then she asked him if he would cry if she walked away, he said "No." Caitlin had heard enough and decided to leave. There were tears streaming down her face, at this point.
As she was walking away she felt a hand grab her arm. When she looked she saw Barry telling her to stay. He said, " You're not pretty, you're beautiful. I don't want to be with you forever, I need to be with you forever. And I wouldn't cry if you walked away, I'd die."