Hey guys! So This is a sequel to "If I could Only Just Remember" soo enjoy:) Decided to make like a little series out of this and make this one funnier but with drama so enjoy;) thankss for my followers i really love u guys:) I do not own Glee, Heather, Naya, etc. Just the storyline.
"So here's what you missed in the If I Could Only Just Remember Series: Apparently Heather ended up in a hospital unconscious after some unknown accident occurred. All we know is that she had a bullet go through her body and that it all started with a suicide attempt. Crazy Heather. Naya is there, loving her and taking care of her and loving her and nourishing her and did I say loving her? Well she is. She is telling Heather their story as Heather is unconsciously listening to her tell her side of the story mixing the 2 stories together and making it all easier to understand. All we know from their story is that it all started 5 years ago the night they first had sex. Heather blamed Naya for the awesome lay, making Naya stop talking to her for a couple of weeks. Then they tried to work things out which just ended in make-up sex. Buut the next morning, Heather texted a "I love you" to Taylor (her boyfriend which Naya knew about), pissing off Naya. Heather tried to fix it, telling her the one she loves is really Naya which was actually worse cause Naya went all Lima Heights Adjacent on her ass. Naya then got drunk and told Lea and Dianna what was going on by mistake and then left Heather a voicemail that said she loved their sex and that she missed her and that she loved her back! What she didn't know is that she left the message on Taylor's voicemail, not Heather's. After a lot of arguing, Naya and Taylor agreed on fighting for Heather's heart without sleeping with her and without telling her! Yikes.. Let's see what happens. And that's what you missed on- FANFIC!"
(5 Years)
Outside of Heather's apartment, Naya and Taylor talked, agreeing on what they were going do about the woman they both loved.
"Ok, you said a few hours ago that if you were with her, you would treat her better. Was that a challenge?" Taylor asked.
Naya just raised her eyebrows in confusion. "What are you talking about?"
"You're right, I am being an asshole. I'm being an asshole because my heart and career depend on her. I don't want to lose her. I really do love her. Obviously, you love her too. And obviously she is confused. I did what I did out of desperation, so let's be fair here. Let's both fight for her heart. A fair fight. And let's let her chose. Deal?" He said calming down.
"What's the catch?" She said, puzzled.
"None."
"Rules?"
"We both play fairly and honestly. And we let HER chose. Winner keeps her, loser loses everything, even contact with her. Oh! And we can't sleep with her!"
"Deal..."
They both shook hands, making it official.
"May the best man win." He said with confidence written all over his face.
"Or woman." Naya corrected.
"Who are you talking to, Na-" Heather was saying as she walked to her building's hallway, but she cut herself off as soon as she saw her boyfriend's face. "Taylor! What are you doing here? I thought you were in Texas."
"I was." He said. "But I came to visit for the weekend! Hi baby!" He extended his arms and got closer to her to give her a huge bear hug. She nervously hugged him back and gave him a quick peck, trying to not let things get too awkward, even if they already were. She looked at Naya after she did, who just rolled her eyes.
"Aww, that's so sweet." She said as nicely as possible. "Bring your stuff in and come inside, if you want I can make some pasta I bet you're hungry." Taylor went in smiling, trying to hold his girlfriend closer to discourage Naya from the fight. Naya stood there, watching everything they did closely, so she can try it later on with her girl. That's right. HER girl. "You can come in too, you know?" Heather said motioning to Naya. Naya just nodded and joined them.
"That's ok honey, actually I brought some take-out. Is Chinese ok for you both?" Taylor asked, leaving his bags on the floor. Naya did not like the idea of Taylor feeding her girl. Or her for that matter. Uh-oh NO LE GUSTA!
"If she wants to cook for you, let her. She loves cooking, remember?" Naya said getting closer to the two of them.
"Well I'm just saying, why cook when there is some food already available?" Taylor challenged, leaning against the wall as his girlfriend pushed his stuff aside.
"All I'M saying is that if she wants to cook, you should LET HER and save the food you brought for LATER." Naya said raising her voice a little.
"All I'M saying is that it's a waste of time to make MORE food when we already have A TON of food RIGHT HERE." He also started to raise his voice, even when he was getting closer to the Latina.
"Maybe the food YOU brought is not what SHE wanted to eat."
"Umm guys..." Heather tried to ease the weird tension between the two.
"Are you saying that MY food is not GOOD enough for HER?!"
"I did NOT say that, YOU came up with that one yourself."
"Guys..." Heather tried again.
"Heather LOVES Chinese. You know what "LOVE" means? It means she could eat it every day without getting tired. And she LOVES her Chinese food." Taylor ignored Heather.
"She does LOVE chinese. But you wanna know what she LOVES more? Italian." Naya continued challenging him.
"Can I just-?" Heather started, being cut off by Taylor.
"Yeah she loves Italian, but you want to know what's her favorite Italian food? Pasta with MEATBALLS, which I BET she doesn't have here."
"Well then I hope she finds the two dumplings and the small egg roll you brought quite satisfying!"
"YOU GUYS!" Heather screamed out, breaking up the fight. As soon as they both quietly looked at her, she started speaking again. "Honestly I'm not really hungry I just ate. Taylor, if you want you can eat the food you brought and Naya if you want I can make you some Italian. Sounds good?" Heather knew they didn't really like each other, since every time he would come, they would compete for her attention. She also knew that after what happened between her and Naya, the Latina probably disliked him even more, so even if something seemed a bit off, she didn't want to address it.
"Nah, I ate before coming over." Naya answered. "But THANK YOU for offering to make me food, HEATHER. YOU are definitely the BEST." She looked at Taylor smiling sarcastically.
"But what if I wanted some Italian?" Taylor asked jealous.
"Are you seriously going to make her cook when YOU brought FOOD?!" Naya asked.
"Are you serious?! You just-" Taylor blurted out, but was cut short by Heather's louder voice.
"TAYLOR, do YOU want some Italian?"
"No, I'm good." Taylor hesitated as Naya glared at him without the blonde noticing.
"You guys are impossible..." Heather whispered to herself as she walked to the couch. "You guys wanna watch a movie?"
"Actually.." Taylor started off. "I kind of wanted to like... Be alone.. With you.."
"Taylor come on I can't kick Naya out. Besides we haven't talked in like forever I really miss her, just like I really missed you. So let's all try to get along, ok?" Heather tried to compromise.
"Yeah Taylor, she can't kick Naya out." Naya said mockingly as she sat down next to Heather on the couch.
"Ok, well, whatever that's ok. We'll catch up tonight." Taylor said as he sat on Heather's other side, leaving her on the middle.
"Yeah!" Heather said, trying to avoid Naya's disgusted face. She quickly picked up the remote and turned to her sides to look at her 2 love interests. "Well what do you guys want to watch?"
"I want to watch the Hunger Games!" Taylor screamed out looking straight into Heather's eyes . "I've been dying to see it! In what movie can you have games, death, and LOVE TRIANGLES all in ONE?" He glared at Naya quickly, and then looked at girlfriend's eyes again.
"Ok.." Heather said nervously. Oh shit does he know something? She asked herself, but quickly shook the idea out of her head and looked back at Naya. "Do you wanna watch it, too?"
"Whatever you want to watch, sweetie." Naya responded with the sweetest smile ever, which made Heather smile back.
"Okay, then The Hunger Games it is." Heather leaned towards the TV to look for the movie on her recordings. Taylor and Naya gave each other a death glare over her shoulders.
"Mr. Obvious" Naya mouthed to Taylor.
"Ms. Suck-up." Taylor mouthed back to Naya, neither one of them breaking the glare.
"Okay, all set." Heather said as she leaned back. Naya and Taylor quickly broke off from their glares and tried to look as relaxed as possible.
"Great!" Taylor said with a huge grin on his face. Heather could feel the tension, but she ignored it as she sat back down. The movie started and they were all quickly lost in the Hunger Games' world. But when the scene in which Katniss volunteered as tribute came on, Heather started to cry, not going unnoticed by Naya.
"Hey, what's wrong? Are you okay?" Naya asked, real concern evident on her voice, as she wiped out a tear off of Heather's cheek.
"It's just so beautiful. Katniss is practically giving the Capital her life so that her sister gets to live hers." Heather said, trying hard to not sob. "It's just so adorable."
"Aww babyy. Don't worry, Katniss is not going to die!" Taylor said as he took her hand and wiped out a tear from her other cheek."They are both going to be okay, you'll see."
"Yeah… Sorta…" Naya said nervously because TAYLOR OBVIOUSLY HADN"T READ THE BOOKS.
"Yeah, I know. But it's still cute." Heather said, calming down a bit.
As soon as Naya saw Taylor's hand touching Heather's, her blood started to boil. Oh no he didn't She thought to herself. She quickly snuggled against Heather's body, laying her head on her shoulder and putting her arm over her belly.
"You know.." Naya started off. "If I was Katniss and you were Prim, I would do the same." She looked back at Heather smiling, who gave her a smile back. Taylor quickly noticed and started talking too.
"Well, if I was Katniss and you were Prim, I would hide you in the forest so that nothing and no one could hurt you. I would bring food every day and I would play with you until you would get tired, no matter how weak I might be." Heather smiled back at Taylor and squeezed his hand. As soon as she was about to say something, Naya interrupted her.
"If I was Katniss and you were Prim, I wouldn't eat for a year to save up so we could move to China."
"What could possibly make you believe that China would be any better than America?" Taylor asked.
"What could possibly make me believe that it's not? They would probably have a shit load of money with all their amazing technology!" Naya said, leaving Heather's side and facing Taylor.
"First of all: isn't that like Japan or something?! And second of all, I know I said Heather loves Chinese food but I don't think-"
"GUYS! Can we JUST watch the MOVIE?! PLEASE?!" Heather asked, really irritated by their constant bickering. The other two just nodded and tried to cuddle with Heather as much as they could, squashing the girl in the middle.
After a lot of fighting and amazing effects, the movie ended.
"You know." Taylor started off, standing up looking for some water. "I think Katniss should end up with Peeta. I mean their relationship is what saved their lives."
"Well I disagree." Naya said. "I think she should stay with Gale. Gale IS her best friend and well your partner is supposed to be your best friend."
"I totally get that, but yet again love isn't suppose to grow from a brother-sister relationship. It's supposed to grow on its own, just like Peeta's and Katniss'." He said again. Heather just rolled her eyes and decided to just settle and listen to their opinions.
"Yeah, but they work together for their money and get each other perfectly. Why waste something like that?" The Latina answered.
"Because Peeta is something new for her. A challenge. Yes, their relationship shakes up the media, but in the end it's kind of an impossible love. They have everything against them, yet they chose to try. They act like if they are in love and in the process they fall in love. They complete each other, in a weird way." Taylor said, thinking he was proving his point but instead he was just encouraging Naya to fight for his girlfriend.
"Then never mind you are right, I'm Team Peeta." Naya said smiling.
Taylor noticed what he just did, slapping himself mentally. "Then whatever. I'm Team Gale. They have known each other for the longest time anyways and he always made her happy before Peeta came!"
"You're stupid." Naya said as she rolled her eyes.
"You're stupider!" Taylor blurted out. Naya just chuckled, mentally patting herself on the back for proving her point. She looked back at Heather who clearly felt frustrated.
"What do YOU think, Heather?" Naya asked.
"Yeah, what do you think baby?" Taylor added.
Heather stood up and looked at both of them. "I think she will pick whoever she thinks she can't survive without. It doesn't matter which one that is."
Taylor and Naya just nodded at her statement, wondering if she was talking about Katniss or herself.
The rest of the night was filled with a few arguments and awkward silences, which just made Heather wonder even more if something was up. But eventually, Naya had to go home, so she purposely let it go. After Naya said her painful goodbyes, she headed for the door, and Heather came after.
"Goodnight, Nay. Hope you sleep well." She said smiling as she gave the smaller girl a hug.
"You too, I missed you." The Latina said, returning the hug.
"Me, too but we still haven't finished our conversation..." The blonde said as she parted away from her best friend.
"We will. I promise. But not tonight."
"Ok..."
Naya then left the apartment, as Heather watched her. Taylor noticed the staring, so he ran to his girl and hugged her from behind.
"Alone at last..." He said huskily into her ear.
"Yep..." The blonde said rather weakly. "Alone." She didn't want to be alone with him. She wanted to be alone with Naya. His company felt like a burden and she knew she had to break it off before it was too late…
But then he twirled her around and kissed her passionately… and all she thought she knew went out of the window. She slowly opened her eyes once he leaned out, smiling at her as if she were important. And she didn't know what those few butterflies in the pit of her stomach were trying to tell her.
Before the man in front of her had mysteriously showed up, she was sure about who she wanted to be with. She wanted Naya, even if it meant hard. It was an easy decision. But now...
Her thoughts were interrupted by Taylor's beeping phone.
"Got a text.." He said as he read it.
(10:43 pm) From: The Girlfriend Stealer: NO SEX! Play fair
He just chuckled at the text, when he started to respond.
(10:43 pm) To: The Girlfriend Stealer: As long as this stays our little secret;)
(10:44 pm) From: The Girlfriend Stealer: What? Our competition? Even from Heather?
(10:44 pm) To: The Girlfriend Stealer: Yes, and ESPECIALLY from Heather
(10:44 pm) From: The Girlfriend Stealer: Deal... And Taylor?
(10:45 pm) To: The Girlfriend Stealer: What?
(10:45 pm) From: The Girlfriend Stealer: May the odds be EVER in your favor;)
And with that note, The Heather Games had OFFICIALLY begun.
Let's try to pretend the Hunger Games came out a year earlier… I wrote this a while ago, so I wasn't smart enough to notice this crucial mistake. Lol im sorry.