Based on a fan fic called Who Killed Kavanaugh? ByBiteMeTechie in the stargate Atlantis section
Who killed Chazz Princeton?
The following fan fic is based on a real story but the names have been changed to protect the guilty
'I think Jay did it in the duel arena with the duel disc' declares Syrus boldly
Jaden flinches "me? How can you suspect me?"
'sorry Jay man but all the clues point to you' replies Atticus
"yes and when you have eliminated everything else, whatever's left no matter how impossible must be the answer" declares Bastion in character as Sherlock Holmes
'how could I have killed Chazz with a duel disc – did I duel him to death?' asks Jaden
"Chazz was killed with a blunt instrument" replies Alexis
'we all hated Chazz – but would any of us resort to murder?' asks Syrus
"but why me?" argues Jaden "he's been stalking Alexis ever since first year that's a motive isn't it?"
'yes but I was in a pick up duel by the lake' replies Alexis
"yeah and I watched – it was a Rad duel" speaks up Atticus
'umm' Jaden thinks hard 'Hasselberry he's always been the most aggressive out of all of us'
"hold that thought Sarg I was in a fight with Private Trusdale at the red Barracks"
'yes he's been charged with attempted murder of Syrus and not the Murder of Mr Princeton' says Bastion
"yep" agrees Atticus "saw the whole thing minus 1000 stars for conflict"
'I still say I'm innocent and I'll prove it with this' Jaden picks up a card from the set on the board – a map of Academy island with pictures of various locations posted on it 'the false alibi card' exclaims Jaden 'hey wait a minute Atticus said he saw Alexis's duel and Sy and Hasselberrys fight'
"great Scott, Jaden your right there's not enough time for Atticus to witness both the fight at the Slifer dorms and the duel at the lake" Realises Bastion
'did anyone actually see Atticus' asks Jaden
"not really" Syrus thinks about it hard
'I was to busy trying to kill private Trusdale to notice'
"I'll remember you said that" replies bastion "Alexis?"
'well…I guess I didn't see him either' replies Alexis reluctantly
"ha! Your alibi is false – we know the crime was committed in the Duel arena and now we know what the murder weapon was" picks up another card "you did it with the banjo" declares Jaden
Atticus stands up 'okay I confess I killed him I was sick of him constantly stalking sissy'
"but Atticus" try's Syrus "last year you helped him to try and win Alexis's heart"
'I changed my mind' dismissively 'and I would have gotten away with it if it hadn't been for you meddling kids'
"seriously" says Jaden "I don't think anyone will miss him"
All reviews appreciated – for all Chazz fans let me state that I'm a fan of Chazz too but the idea kept irritating me and besides he's not actually dead – it was just a game the others were playing (like cluedo)