Disclaimer: I own nothing.
A/N: I'm a huge Puckleberry fan so I have no idea where this came from! Forgive me!
He sang Sweet Caroline for her.
She said she was proud to have him on her arm.
Their make out sessions were hot.
He thought 'this is a girl I could fall in love with'.
Then she left him for Finn Hudson.
She was hurt and wanted revenge.
Them making out was as hot as ever.
But he knew she'd hate herself if they went any further.
So he stopped it.
She went back to Finn Hudson again.
Finn fucking Hudson.
He realized she may be the girl he'd fallen in love with,
But she'd never fall back.