We Can't Both Have Her
A while back, MythScavenger, who usually writes PeterxJane, wrote a PeterxWendy fanfic. In order to balance out the universe, I, who usually write PeterxWendy, have written a PeterxJane fanfic. If you don't like it, I apologize. Please let me know your opinion on this story. Anonymous reviews are accepted as well as signed reviews.
As a Gentleman Thief, I swear to you I don't own any characters named herein.
o|-|o
He knew he would lose this struggle, but he continued, despite his lack of hope that she would choose him. She would want a normal life, like Wendy, Molly, Alice, and Cindy before her. With all of them, he'd given up quickly, and without a fight, but with Jane, it was different. She belonged in Neverland, he was sure of it. She was too perfect to grow up.
A mysterious feeling rose in his chest at the thought of her. Was this… love? At any rate, he constantly checked on her, but she was always asleep, so he'd just give her a small kiss on the cheek and fly off, not noticing her bedroom door was always opened a crack.
One night, as he continued the routine that he had become accustomed to, the door opened the rest of the way. Wendy called him silently to walk with her.
"Peter," she whispered gently to her old friend, "You know we can't both have her."
"I know," he replied, sadly, expecting her to tell him to leave.
"If it's her choice," Wendy said, "please watch over her for me."
"What?" he asked, believing that he had misheard her.
"I'm giving Jane the choice I had all those years ago," she said, tears welling up in her eyes, "If she chooses you, please protect her."
"I will, Wendy," he replied solemnly.
"Come back tomorrow," Wendy said as calmly as she could.
o|-|o
As per Wendy's instructions, Peter did return. He flew into Jane's window and sat in the empty room. He knew she wouldn't choose him, so he closed his eyes to prevent any tears from escaping. Suddenly, he felt a gentle hand in his. He looked up to see loving blue eyes looking at him. Unable to resist her, Peter kissed Jane softly on the lips.
"I chose you," she said lovingly.
o|-|o
The pair flew off to Neverland, forever together, and forever in love.