Authors Note: Set 3 years into the future, both Rachel and Finn live in New York (but not together) and have been dating the past 2 years, after Jesse left.

Rachel and Jesse are staring in Spring Awakening, but Finn doesn't know Jesse is in it.

Rachel and Quinn are best friends and Quinn, Puck, and Beth also live in New York.

Rachel POV

Quinn, Puck, Beth, Finn and I were walking through Central Park on a beautiful October evening. Puck took Beth to go swing and Quinn, Finn, and me were talking and drinking hot coffee.

"Rach I still can't believe you landed the lead in….what's that play again?" Finn said. "Winter Awakening?"

I rolled my eyes at him "Spring Awakening, Finn."

"Oh yeah, right." He said as Quinn laughed to herself.

"Uh Finn?" I said and he raised his eyebrows. "Can you go get me and Quinn some more coffee?"

"Uh yeah sure, I'll be right back." He turned around and started heading towards the coffee cart.

Quinn just started laughing. "I swear I think he doesn't ever pay attention to anything I say!" I said angrily.

Quinn rolled her eyes before she began to speak. "So when are you going to tell him Jesse's in the play too?"

I groaned. "I don't know. How am I even supposed to bring that up?" I said. "Oh hey Finn, you remember Jesse St James, right? That guy from high school who you totally hated? Yeah him, well he's playing my love interest in this play. Oh and by the way, there's this hot sex scene I'm going to have to do with him too. So what should we have for dinner?"

"Yeah, that might not be the best way to tell him." Quinn said smiling and Finn returned and Quinn motioned for me to tell him.

I decided it might be better to tell him with Quinn around.

"Hey, Finn?" I started.

"Yeah?" He answered.

"About this play….there's something you should know…."I began to say when the worst person possible walked over.

"Hey Rach, Quinn." Jesse St James said walking over to us in the middle of Central Park. Why now? This place was huge how did he happen to be in the same spot at the same time? "Hudson…"He finished.

"What the hell are you doing here St James?" Finn asked angrily, looking like he was going to punch Jesse.

"Uh oh babe, did you forget to tell the boyfriend something?" He said sneering on the word "boyfriend"

"Don't call her babe." Finn said heatedly. "What's going on Rachel?"

"Umm….well, Jesse is in Spring Awakening with me." I muttered quietly.

"Why didn't you tell me this before, Rachel?" Finn said, still glaring at Jesse. I was about to speak, but Jesse answered for me.

"Well, being the moron that you are you probably haven't seen or even know what Spring Awakening is about, do you?" Jesse said. Finn stayed glaring at Jesse but didn't say anything. "That's what I thought. Well, she was probably worried to tell you that I was in this musical, as the lead, of course, because we have a pretty graphic sex scene to do up on stage, every night, and most rehearsals too. The director wants it to be perfect." He finished smirking.

Finn was furious. "Why? Why, Rachel? You should've told me sooner, then letting me hear it from him."

"I-I-I didn't think it was that big of a deal." I said quietly.

"You are right Rachel; it isn't that big of a deal acting out a sex scene, when we have had sex before." Jesse said looking at Finn smugly.

"You had sex with him too!" Finn said, even angrier if it was possible. "You had sex with him, and you won't do anything with me?"

"It was a long time ago Finn." I said.

"Well, I've got to go now. It was a pleasure speaking with you." He said smirking towards Finn. He started walking away but abruptly turned around. "Oh, I'll see you tomorrow at rehearsals Rachel. Can't wait." He said with a smirk still plastered on his face.

He turned and walked away and I turned and looked at Finn who was still glaring at Jesse while he walked away.

"Finn-"I began to say but he stopped me.

"No Rachel, it's okay. I'm still upset you didn't tell me when you found out he'd be in this play, but I guess you were worried how I'd react." He said. "I'm going to go now. I'll call you tomorrow."

Finn turned around and walked away. I turned towards Quinn who was just standing there observing the whole time.

She started to speak. "I think the first thing you said would have gone better than that."

Review (: