A/N: Extremely AU! Fabray Twins! Who doesn't love fafaberry? No Beth, it's junior year, and Russel and Judy are still together. Also I can't decide which title to go with so I think you guys should decide. {: Oh! And thanks to KW05 she helped me figure out a few things ;) Four for you Glen Coco! You go Glen Coco!
"One Love/Another Heart Calls" Chapter One "Explosions In The Sky"
Quinn Fabray is a twin the older twin of precisely two minutes and thirty two seconds, her twin Charlotte 'Charlie' Fabray was the younger more happier sister who didn't care for popularity or boys. But as Quinn's job of being the first born (Well out of her and Charlotte, but her other sister Frannie is the eldest and extremely perfect sister that set the bar majorly high.) Quinn had to do everything Frannie did because it was expected of her. She was always a daddy's girl and a daddy's girl was suppose to make her daddy proud and honored to have a daughter like her. So Quinn joined the cheerios, the celibacy club, and glee something she actually liked. She was even dating Finn Hudson the most popular guy in school and the quarterback.
Quinn pretty much hates her life she hates always being compared to Frannie and Charlotte. Stupid Frannie and her stupid husband, and Charlotte and her stupid kind heart. Quinn always thought to herself when her father and mother never thought anything was good enough because Frannie had either done it better, or Charlotte took a new picture.
Now to Quinn, Charlotte had everything she wanted. Blue eyes, real friends, wore regular clothes, and never had to try and live up to Frannie but the one thing Quinn wanted most was love, but not just any love she wanted Rachel Berry's love, the girl she had been in love with since they were kids. She wanted to have cute conversations, sweet kisses, the smile that never left, the flutter in her heart, to have songs sung to her in front of everyone. She wanted Rachel Berry for everything the brunette had to offer; romance, sweet words, hugs, kisses, and sex.
She constantly has dreams of Rachel being her first, of Rachel making love to her, of Rachel holding her tight till they both came undone. Quinn remembered feeling sick to her stomach when she came home extra early from Cheerios practice because coach Sylvester had a mental breakdown only to hear the moans, hisses, and groans coming from her sister's room.
Flashback
Quinn slowly walked up seeing the door open and peeked seeing Charlotte on top of Rachel who was sitting up as well, both riding each other to ecstasy. Quinn thought maybe it was one of those sex toys and tried to make her self turn away and leave the house but when Charlotte orgasmed along with Rachel she watched as they both hit the bed worn out and panting. Quinn widened her eyes watching closely to Rachel taking off a condom, wrapping it up, and throwing it in the garbage can. Quinn gasped at the sight of Rachel with penis she couldn't believe her eyes.
Rachel jolted up. "What was that? Did you hear that?"
Charlotte giggled bringing Rachel back down kissing her neck to her jawline. "Relax baby, Quinn has Cheerios practice and my parents went on a short vacation. Quinn won't be back for like three hours." Charlotte smiled against Rachel's neck.
"Oh, well, I guess we better make the most of this then huh?" Rachel grinned flipping her girlfriend over making her squeal.
End of Flashback
Quinn shook her head at the memory hearing Santana call everyone around to play truth or dare. She watched as Charlie kissed Rachel's cheek and walked out of the room.
"Okay Berry, truth or dare?" Santana smirked.
"Dare!" Rachel grinned.
"I dare you to kiss Quinn." Santana smirked she knew Quinn was totally into Rachel she may be sexy as hell and the biggest bitch in Lima but she wasn't dumb. Both Quinn and Rachel paled. "And if you don't then you have to tongue a random stranger of my choosing."
Rachel had looked towards Charlotte for help but she had forgot that Charlotte had went to the bathroom, so Rachel in her obvious drunken state shook it off and drank a little more and laughed slurring. "Quinn Fabray, I'm about to rock your world." Quinn gulped feeling her heart pound against her chest. She licked her lips watching Rachel lean in closer and closer smirking and slowly brought her lips onto Quinn's gently. When they both pulled apart they both felt a rush of heat wash over them. Both seeing fireworks and gold stars shooting everywhere.
"Not uh! You have to have tongue!" Santana remarked.
Rachel's eyes went in a daze looking into nothing but dilated Hazel eyes. Rachel caressed Quinn's cheek then threaded her fingers in her hair; and softly brought their lips together this time both girls slipped in a little tongue earning a moan from Quinn.
Everyone around them went silent seeing the two get into it especially when Charlotte came back and saw them making out. "Rachel!" Puck whispered. Santana smirked evilly seeing Charlotte's smile vanish. Kurt cleared his throat loudly.
Both girls broke apart slowly; staring into each others eyes both knowing what the other felt. A sniffle brought Rachel out of her daze seeing a hurt Charlotte.
"Charlotte, this isn't what you think it is." Rachel said calmly. Charlie let out a sob and ran away. Rachel jumped away from Quinn and sprinted to Charlotte.
Quinn looked down trying to settle her nerves and looked back up to see half of New Direction's jaws dropped. She looked towards a smirking Santana and grumbled out of breath. "Your such a bitch." to Santana who just shrugged.
"Charlotte! Charlotte wait! Wait!" Rachel shouted running after the blonde taking her hand.
"That was not what you think it was." The brunette shook her head.
"Then what was it? Did you think I was her?" Charlie sniffled.
"No, no of course not. It was a dare from Santana." Charlotte huffed 'Of course it was' she thought to herself. "She said if I didn't kiss her then I would have to kiss some stranger with tongue that she got to pick."
Charlotte nodded her head crossing her arms and looked up at her brown eyed girlfriend. "Did-" Charlotte winced. "Did you french kiss my sister?"
"...Well not at first, but Santana made us." Rachel said hoping it would help.
Charlotte sighed closing her eyes; she loved Rachel very much and any other girl it would have been fine but the fact that it was her sister, her very popular hazel eyed sister, made her churn with jealousy. "Did you...like it? Cause the way you both were looking at each other it was like-"
Rachel plastered on a smile. "Of course not Char, I love you." she replied cupping Charlotte's face. "Now, are you ready to go back inside?" Charlotte smiled with tears in her eyes and nodded taking Rachel's hand. Rachel smiled back kissing Charlotte's temple as she wiped her eyes.
Quinn watched as Rachel and her team played flip cup and won.
"Woo!" Rachel cheered along with everyone else and walked up to Charlotte.
"Rach, your drunk." Charlotte said nudging her girlfriend away.
"Oh come on baby, let's go somewhere just you and me huh?" Rachel asked slipping her arms around Charlotte's waist kissing her cheek while still holding on to her cup.
"No, I wanna go home."
"Babe come on live a little."
"So your definition of living is drinking to a pulp?" Charlotte raised her eyebrow.
Rachel scoffed. "I've only had like two, three beers."
"No, you've had four beers not including the one in your hand, and three shots."
"God, what is with you today! Why can't you just get off my back!" Rachel slurred.
"Is that how you really feel? That I'm annoying you?" Charlotte asked feeling hurt.
Quinn rolled her eyes at her sister she really didn't need to be such a prude to Rachel the girl was having fun and just wanted to be happy with Charlotte. They did just win Regionals.
"Yeah, yeah it is. Look around you! Everyone is having fun but you. I love you Char but it's just us Glee kids, what's the worst that could happen?"
"I don't need to have fun by drinking! Look at yourself Rachel you can't even speak without slurring!"
"We just won Regionals! Fuck! Loosen up a little will ya!" Rachel yelled back.
Charlotte's expression went from hurt in bitch mode something Charlotte hardly ever went into but when she was lied to, yelled at, or hurt she pulled it out. "Okay I'm going to ignore everything you just told me and take you home because obviously your too drunk to function." Charlotte said taking Rachel's wrist.
"No, I'm not going." Rachel replied snatching her wrist back.
"Rachel-"
"If you want to go then go. I'm staying."
"Fine!" Charlotte scoffed and stormed out.
Puck laughed throwing his arm around Rachel's shoulder. "Don't worry just blame it on the alcohol in the morning, now come on Ray let's party!"
An hour later everyone was starting to fall asleep. Especially when Hold Me Now came on. Rachel chuckled at Puck who snuggled up to Lauren. She slowly started to feel lonely with out Charlotte till she looked around at everyone seeing that everyone asleep except one Quinn Fabray.
Right when they locked eyes 'Time of the Season by The Zombies popped on. They both stared at one another with pure lust and hunger. Quinn turned walking towards the staircase and went up; slowly looking back at Rachel. A sign for the brunette to follow her.
Rachel breathed out and began to follow Quinn, opening Puck's door to feel Quinn push her down on the edge of the bed straddling her.
Quinn looked down at Rachel both feeling their hearts flutter at the sensation. Quinn bent down kissing Rachel like she had before. Full of want and need.
Rachel began to trail her fingers up Quinn's thighs then let her palms grip them and lift the blonde up and gently laid her down against the bed.
Quinn threaded her fingers through Rachel's hair bringing her closer but Rachel pushed away. "Wait we-we can't." Rachel said trying to get out of Quinn's grasp but the blonde held her close knowing the real reason didn't want to do it.
"I know Rachel." Quinn said softly.
"Then why won't you let me go?" Rachel whispered her eyes glazed and her pupils dilated.
"No...I know." Quinn repeated dragging her hand down to Rachel's groin area.
Rachel sucked in air at the placement of her hand "How?"
Quinn blushed deeply looking away. "I may have saw it once." Rachel gulped turning bright red.
"But...what about Charlotte?...She's your sister."
"She's your girlfriend." Quinn began to sigh and said "I want you Rachel. I've wanted you longer than her. You were my first kiss, my first love, and now I want you to be my first."
Rachel's eyes widened a little as she gulped looking into Quinn's hazel eyes. Rachel and Quinn both heard the small voice in the back of their heads shouting 'no'. But the moment they really looked into one another's eyes all their worries went away. Rachel bent down taking her lips with hers; starting their dance.
When both girls finally shredded their clothes, Rachel kissed Quinn one last time before throwing the covers off and pulling the blonde's legs on top of her tanned shoulders. Rachel kissed around Quinn's flaps till she reached around running a finger up and down and gently entered Quinn making her gasp softly gripping the pillow. Rachel smirked bringing her finger out and let her tongue run over her clit a few times watching as Quinn moaned bucking her hips for more. The brunette stopped for a second letting her lips cover it sucking on it.
"God, you taste so good Quinn." Rachel groaned letting her hands travel up the blonde's body then re-tracked then taking her previous stance between Quinn's legs with one arm underneath her pale neck kissing it softly.
Rachel laid with her forearm against the bed holding her up as she kissed down Quinn's jawline; letting her hand graze the blonde cheerleader's soft thigh.
Quinn gasped feeling herself drip with want. "Wait." she rasped. Rachel lifted her head looking into Quinn's hazel eyes."Do you...have protection?" she panted.
Rachel pushed Quinn's hair back caressing her cheek. "Of course I do Q...it's me." Quinn blushed as Rachel bent down grabbing her pants and taking out a condom, and put it on.
Rachel got on top of Quinn laying her arm underneath the blonde's neck holding her shoulder.
Quinn gasped feeling Rachel's hard on against her. "Go-Go slow...please." Quinn rasped. Rachel looked into Quinn's eyes and nodded, she moved her hips letting her hard cock run through Quinn's wetness, and slowly met Quinn's entrance. Quinn winced as she felt Rachel slowly push herself inside of her. Rachel groaned softly letting her head fall by the blonde's head, letting herself feel how tight Quinn was; her walls clenching her.
The brunette heard a sniffle from Quinn and kissed away her tears. "Do you want me to stop?" Quinn shook her head biting her lips from the pain. "Ke-Keep going just make the pain go away." Rachel began to kiss Quinn making the blonde focus on her lips rather than the pain, and slowly began thrusting in. The blonde gasped gripping Rachel's back tightly with her nails, pulling her closer.
Rachel began kissing right at the end of her jawline to the tip of Quinn's ear finding the blonde's weak spot that drives her crazy. Quinn moaned breathing heavily into Rachel's ear making her speed up the pace a little. "God, Quinn, your so tight." Rachel groaned; clutching onto Quinn with one arm beneath her neck, and one hand holding her thigh.
"Rachel..." Quinn husked throwing her head back. "Ohhhhh, Rachel...Baby, your so...amazing." Quinn gasped. Rachel bent down taking in Quinn's lips; pulling apart only to let her forehead rest against hers. Both Breathing in what the other breathed out. Rachel lifted up with her palms watching as Quinn moaned louder and louder as she went faster and deeper.
"Oh God, Rachel, you fill me up so good...it's soo...Ohhhh!" Quinn moaned.
"Quinn, your so beautiful...fuck." Rachel groaned.
"Rachel! Ahhhhhhhhhh!" Quinn squealed as Rachel started thrusting in and out as fast as she could, even Quinn started bucking along till they both exploded. Rachel rotated her hips slowly pressing down on Quinn's clit letting the blonde ride it out along with her.
Quinn kissed Rachel holding her in place; too afraid to let go just yet. Quinn pulled back and whispered. "I love you."
Rachel went back down kissing Quinn softly and sighed against the blonde's forehead. "I love you too."