A/N: Okay, so like it says in the summary, this is the sequel to 'Not Your Average Horror Story'. If you haven't read it, then you might want to go read it first, otherwise you may not understand what's going on in this story! Anyways, here you go!

Pairings: Quinn/Logan, Zoey/Chase, Lola/Vince, Michael/Lisa

Disclaimer: We all know I don't own Zoey 101.

It was 7:45 on a Friday morning as Logan Reese lay awake in his bed, mentally reliving the past few days of his life. He could not believe he, the Logan Reese, had been Punk'd. Sure, it was awesome that he was going to be on TV for it, but he still couldn't stand the fact that he had once again been duped. He rolled over in his bed, facing his full-length mirror that was hanging on the wall, and thought about all the things they had done to him in the past:

(A/N: Everything in the list below is stuff that they really did in the show, I wrote the episode when it happened after each one in case you couldn't remember!)

Tricking him into admitting he had put the webcam in the girls' lounge and making him lose his job at Sushi Rox (Webcam), Chase and Zoey scaring him half to death by making him think there was a monster after him (Haunted House), Zoey, Lola, and Nicole publicizing the fact that he got rejected by a girl (People Auction), Lola trying to trick him into losing the "S" bet (although he didn't fall for that one) (Quinn's Alpaca), Quinn tricking him into wearing a dress and heels across campus (he forgave her though obviously) (Chase's Girlfriend), putting that rat down his pants (Zoey's Tutor), Chase and Michael making him think he drank toilet water (Dance Contest), Zoey tricking him into losing the Hands on a Blix Van contest (Hands on a Blix Van), Chase, Zoey, and Lola fooling him into getting his money taken away again after his father had finally given it back (Logan Gets Cut Off), Zoey making his art project fly away (Anger Management), Zoey and Dustin putting honey on his Jet-X (Anger Management), Zoey, James, and Dustin shooting him with a paint grenade (Anger Management), everyone making fun of him endlessly for mispronouncing 'flabbergasted' ONE time (Coffee Cart Ban), Lola chomping on his ear (Roller Coaster), Lola throwing his hamburger into the fountain (Roller Coaster), Michael torturing him because he told a couple people (okay, maybe more than a couple) his secret (Roller Coaster), and many other things.

Yes, payback for all of the bad deeds done against him was definitely necessary. In order to get proper revenge, he would need someone's help: someone he could trust, someone who could keep secrets, someone smart. He smirked as he thought of the perfect person for the job.

He jumped out of bed and headed to Quinn's room. Logan walked in to find that she was still asleep, which wasn't surprising seeing as how it wasn't even 8 a.m. yet. He grinned, then ran and jumped next to her on the bed, sending her flying slightly into the air as she was jolted awake.

"GOOOOD MORNING QUINN!" he screeched, "How's my gorgeous girlfriend today?"

"Well, I was sound asleep until you shot me up in the air," Quinn replied groggily, "what do you want?"

"I want you to come eat breakfast with me,"

"Fine," she yawned, "I'll come eat breakfast with you in an hour when I wake up."

"No, I think you will right now!" he teased as he pushed her off the bed onto the floor. "OOOPS! Well, now that you're up, come have breakfast with me!" She rolled her eyes as he helped her up and dragged her to the kitchen.

"You know, I have to admit," Quinn said in-between bites of her cereal, "you took that whole 'Punk'd' thing a lot better than I expected. We all thought you were gonna explode when you found out. I was amazed you didn't scream at anyone."

"That's because I'm going to get all of you back for what you did to me," he smirked.

Quinn frowned, "Even me, baby? I told you, they made me go along with it."

"I might spare you if you prove yourself worthy," he said with an evil grin.

"What, make out with you? Fine!"

"No…well, yes…but I want you to be my partner in crime," he told her, frowning when she fell into a fit of giggles.

"Partner in crime?" she mocked, "What in the world?"

"I want you to help me get back at everyone else, and if you do a good job, then I will spare you from my wrath. Deal?" he asked, extending his hand.

"Deal," she responded, shaking his hand, "So, what do I have to do?"

"Oh, you'll see," he said as Chase walked in.

"She'll see what?" Chase asked with a suspicious look.

"She'll see…what the big surprise is! You know, once everyone wakes up, then I'll tell you what it is," Logan replied with almost no hesitation.

"We're not going to be on another one of your dad's reality shows, are we?"

"Um, no," Logan smirked, "You'll find out soon enough."

The three continued eating their breakfast and making small talk until Lola, Zoey, and Michael all eventually arrived in the kitchen.

"Hey Logan, everyone's here now," Chase pointed out, "will you tell us what the surprise is?"

"What surprise?" Michael asked, "Wait, are we gonna be on one of your dad's re…?"

"No! If you be quiet and listen, then I will tell you what the surprise is," Logan snapped. All eyes were on Logan, eagerly awaiting the unveiling of the surprise. "Although, after what all of you did to me, I don't think I should tell you!"

After much pleading and begging from everyone, he finally gave in and told them. "Okay, so my dad owns this private island about 60 miles from here, and this weekend we are all going to stay there!"

"THAT'S the surprise?" Lola asked, not seeming very psyched.

"Uh, yeah," Logan replied, rolling his eyes at her lack of appreciation.

"I think it sounds really cool!" Quinn chimed in, not sure of the plan, but positive that she needed to help get everyone more pumped about this place.

"It sounds stupid," said Lola. She was constantly trying to rain on Logan's parade (not literally, of course!).

"There's more to the surprise for you and Michael," Logan retaliated, "I was gonna wait until we got there to tell you, but I guess I will just tell you now."

"Oooh, there's more for us?" Michael piped up, "What? What? What? What is it?"

"Well, you know how Vince couldn't stay here all summer because he's helping at that football camp thing, and Lisa was at dance camp?"

"Yeah…oh my gosh, are they…?" Lola was so ecstatic now she couldn't even finish her question.

"They are meeting us there, and they're gonna hang out with us the entire weekend!" Logan told them. While Michael squealed in excitement, Lola just flat out jumped on Logan to hug him, thanking him for bringing her man to this island.

"Hey now, watch whose boyfriend you're hugging, woman!" Quinn joked.

"What?" Lola asked, then looked and realized who she was embracing and quickly moved away. "Oh, sorry Quinn, I'm just so excited Vince is coming with us! I haven't gotten to talk to him in days!" She started jumping up and down again. "What am I gonna wear? I gotta go pack…" she kept talking to herself as she left the room, the other girls following her out the door to help her pick out the best outfits.

The boys remained in the kitchen, enthralled in one of those random conversations they always seemed to have. Chase had started it when he said, "So, if you could only bring one thing to the private island that your father owns, what would it be?" Logan rolled his eyes at the weirdness of his friend.

"Chase, Michael and I have already discussed this, remember? I thought a knife would clearly be the best thing you could bring, which it still is by the way, and Michael said a sock, so you could do a puppet show or put a rock in it and use it as a weapon."

"Oh yeah, I remember that conversation," Michael said, "but I wanna change my answer. I know something that would be better to have than a knife or a sock."

"What's that?" Logan asked.

"Clackers!" Michael smiled.

"UUUUGGGGH!"

A/N: Okay, so it's kind of a slow beginning, but stick with me please, it's gonna get better, I promise! This story will probably take longer for me to update since I don't already have the whole thing written like I did with the other one, but that's good because you can give me some input on what you want to happen! The only way to do that is to review, so please review and tell me what you thought, what you want to happen, or whatever else you want to tell me! :)