The song is by Eve6 and it's called Jesus Nitelight

The song is by Eve6 and it's called Jesus Nitelight.  I don't own it or the characters/show.

Your eyes shine bright like a Jesus nitelite
I'd like to touch your positive vibes
Indifferent eyes won't give me the time

He didn't love her.  Only as a friend, never to develop to anything more.  She is unable to accept that can't stop dreaming about him.  Thinking of ways to touch him accidentally while walking by.  He refuses to play her games while trying to keep respect for her.

 
May I help put aside your moral fiber
You're dressed in white my face is white
I'd like to be a colorful sight to see

She loved him deeply.  Since long as she could remember she'd scratch his name into her notebooks.  Her desk drawer was filled with images of his face.  Whenever she moved the first thing that was packed were them.  Now older and more mature she feels the time as come.  Having him so close all the time was a scene she once only imagined in her head.  Now instead of sleeping with his photo under the pillow they could now in time share a pillow.  Only if he was willing to give her a chance.

I'm only here in a background
Here on the ground lays my head
I sleep and then I wake make sounds and go to bed and wake again

He treats her kindly.  Helps her along in adjusting to his world, but still refuses to let her into his.  Over time her ever-pleasant attuide rawed his nerves out.  Soon he was no longer playing happy host.  And this hurt her deeply.  She couldn't understand where things went wrong.

The time is right but I feel all wrong
It wastes away until its gone
The time is right but I feel all wrong
It fades away and now you're gone

She ripped his photographs into pieces of confetti.  Destroying all evidence of him but unable to remove it from her heart.  All her life she knew she was going to be Mrs. Jack Phillips.  Since the time she saw him with his He-Man figures playing in the sand box all those years ago.  Listened intently to the letters from his family send to her family.  Now she's having doubts if these feelings were ever real or just fantasies of a lonely child.

You're walking by
I'm standing by
Behind the light
I'm standing by
By and by

He studies his books and practices the guitar.  Trying to ignore the guilt rising in his soul.  He knew of her love for him but did nothing.  Couldn't even be a friend.  Pushed into a situation against his will he's unwilling to change his life to make her smile.  Still the sounds of tears didn't help him.  No!  He tells himself while shutting the door and putting the radio on full volume.