Meant To Be Chapter 1! By: Matt91 Rating: R
Summary: What if at the end of "The Fourth Sister", when Prue and Andy talked, Prue revealed her secret to him? How would things be different? Would they stay together? Would Andy die? Read on to find out.
Setting: This story is set at the very end of Season 1, Episode 7, "The Fourth Sister"
Disclaimer: Prue, Piper, and Phoebe Halliwell don't belong to me, as do Andy Trudeau, Leo Wyatt, Darryl Morris and any other characters that appear on the show. The idea for this story belongs to me. Please e-mail me with any comments you may have at
For Your Information: Words in single quotation marks (' ') are people's thoughts.
Andy's Building- Front
"Damn, it Prue, I still love you. I'm not saying you have to explain it all to me, Prue, that's your prerogative. All I'm saying is, it hurts that you don't trust me enough," says Andy, throwing his coat to the side.
"I do trust you, Andy. And it has nothing to do with you. It's just…it's just something that I don't know if I can ever share with anybody," says Prue, arms crossed.
"Well, I hope that's not true for your sake. All I know is there's nothing more I can say or do to reassure you that I'm there for you," says Andy.
He begins to walk up the steps.
(A/N: This part was taken from the Charmed episode, "The Fourth Sister". It doesn't belong to me!)
"Andy, wait," calls Prue.
"What?" asks Andy, annoyed.
"I love you, damn it. I don't want to lose you," says Prue, walking up next to him.
"Prue, I can't imagine my life without you but I can't keep doing this. I get ready to come see you and something always comes up. I wind up looking like the stupid one. It's ridiculous and it hurts me! I just wish you could tell me what this big secret, that keeps pulling me away from you, is," said Andy, dejectedly.
"Andy, I'll tell you. But not here, can we go inside?" asks Prue, ready to finally tell him.
"Yeah," says Andy, as they head into the building.
They enter his apartment and sit down on the couch.
"Ok, Andy, what I'm about to tell you is big, really big. You cannot tell this to anyone, not a soul. I am trusting you to keep my secret," says Prue, serious.
"You can trust me completely!" says Andy, finally ready to hear her secret.
"Andy, I'm a witch," says Prue, quickly.
"A witch? Are you being serious?" asks Andy, not believing her.
"Yes, watch," says Prue. She squints her eyes and a book on the table moves.
"How, how did you do that?" asks Andy, getting up, freaked.
"With my mind. It's my magical power, the power of telekinesis," explains Prue.
"What about Piper and Phoebe Are they witches too?" asks Andy, still freaked, yet curious at the same time.
"Yes, all three of us are witches. We inherited our powers from our mother and grandmother," explains Prue, hoping Andy won't freak out more than he is.
"What about children? Will they be witches, also?" asked Andy.
"If they are girls, then they will be witches," says Prue.
(A/N: At this point in the show, Piper and Leo aren't even dating. Therefore they're not married and have children. So, they have no idea that Wyatt and Chris will become the first male witches in the family. I'm just going along with what they knew in Season 1!)
"Oh My God! I can't believe this! My girlfriend is a witch, her sisters are witches and they have supernatural powers. I can't comprehend this it's too much! I can't take this! Why did you tell me this?" cries Andy, pacing, quickly, around the room.
"Hey, you're the one who wanted to know my secret so badly, not the other way around. I didn't want to tell you because I didn't think you would be able to handle it. If you didn't want to know, then you shouldn't have asked," screams Prue.
"I didn't think your secret was this big. I thought it something like you and your sisters were like social workers, who didn't have licenses to help people. I never expected to hear that my girlfriend is a freak of nature!" screams Andy.
"I'm a freak of nature? I would look in the mirror, if I were you. Uh, I'm so sorry I ever told you my secret. I'm leaving," cries Prue, heading towards the door.
"Prue," calls Andy.
"What?" asks Prue, upset.
"Give me some time," says Andy, softly.
"Whatever," says Prue, walking out of the apartment and slamming the door.
Andy sits on his couch, lost in thought.
'How could Prue be a witch? How could it happen? Penny and Patty always seemed normal, not at all like witches. I don't understand, how could I not have known? Weren't' there ever signs? I mean, whenever I was around strange things would happen. How could she keep this from me? We love each other and we have a relationship. A relationship is built on honesty and trust,' thinks Andy.
How could he be with her, if she wasn't honest with him?
Prue's Car
Prue is in her car, on her way home.
"I can't believe Andy freaked out like that. He was the one that kept pestering me about telling him my secret. So, I tell him and he can't handle it. I knew I never should've told him. He wasn't ready and more importantly, I wasn't ready! I should've waited. Things are just so screwed up. He had the nerve to call me a freak of nature, how rude! Uh, what am I going to tell my sisters?' thinks Prue, while driving.
What was she going to tell her sisters? She can't keep this from them because it involves their secret and that concerns all of them!
Author's Note: Ok, well, here's chapter 1. I hope it wasn't crappy! I tried hard but the first chapter of a story is always the hardest to write! Was it good? Did you like it? Is the plot good? I hope the answers to these questions are yes. What's going to happen next? What's Prue going to tell her sisters? Will Andy ever accept Prue's secret? Or will this cause them to break up? Chapter 2, coming soon! In the meantime, please REVIEW!
Author's Note #2: I have been noticing that this chapter, the first one of this story, has been getting the most hits. Every time I look at the hits for this story, the number of hits increases and all of the hits are always for this chapter. If you read this chapter, I would really appreciate it if you would leave me a REVIEW!