Disclaimer- I don't own any rights to the Vampire Diaries (Books or Show)
A/N-So this is like a part two of Fells Church Meets Mystic Falls. I hope you love it as much as me! Happy Reading!
Chapter One
It had been almost a week since Fell's Elena was gone. Things were finally starting to get back to normal in Mystic Falls. The Fells gang was still there, but this had become the normal for them now.
"I think we should go to the carnival" Caroline smiled.
"That's an awesome idea" Elena smiled. They looked around for re-assurance from the rest of the group.
Both Damons, Stefans, Matts, and Bonnies were smiling in agreement with Jeremy and Meredith smiling as well.
"Hate to be a downer, but has anyone seen Tyler?" Mystic's Matt asked, Tyler was his childhood friend and he knew Tyler had gone home, but no one had seen him and he wasn't answering his phone.
"No" Everyone replied, but no one seemed as worried as Matt was.
"Alright... so carnival" Mystic's Matt smiled, changing the subject.
XXX
Later that day the large group gathered into several cars and drove to the carnival. They walked around riding different things, laughing, and of course eating. They were sitting around eating lunch when they saw Tyler sitting behind the Information booth. His mother was working the booth and obviously didn't notice the flask her son was drinking from.
"Hey Tyler" Mystic's Matt called waving. Tyler looked at him, but other than that Matt received no other acknowledgement.
"He's drinking again" Matt cast a glare in his direction.
"What did you expect?" Mystic's Damon snapped, not wanting the joyful mood of the group ruined.
"Just an observation" Matt whispered.
"Whatever... we're here to have fun... and his mom is right there. No worries" Mystic's Stefan tried to cheer him up.
"Right... let's go to the tunnel of love" Mystic's Matt was, again, the one bringing up the doom and gloom and washing it away.
"Yeah!" Everyone agreed excitedly. They hurried to the line, which was surprisingly long considering how early it was.
"So I know we've been doing everything together." Damon started off lazily, "But this ride is for two people only. So we got to split up."
Jeremy almost jumped with joy at his opportunity, "I'll go with Meredith." He blurted out and when everyone turned to look at him he managed to stammer, "I mean...if she...if she wants to."
Meredith only laughed and linked her arm with his as they pushed past the gangs and disappeared into the darkness where they supposed you got on the boat for the ride.
"I'll go with my dear Elena..." Damon smirked, his eye twitching in that way of his as he grabbed Elena by the waist and claimed her as his.
"Wait, Damon." Stefan managed to call after him before they were also gone.
"I just don't want him to mess with her if she doesn't want the attention." He explained quickly when everyone shot him confused looks. They shrugged and brushed it off, only Bonnie seemed bothered the whole situation. She was frowning as she stared off into space.
He made his way toward her, "I'm over her." He assured her although he wasn't exactly sure why he was telling her that.
She smiled up at him with her dark green eyes dancing with joy, "Do you want to go together?" She asked, nudging him and pointing to the entrance, where Matt and Caroline were already stepping inside.
"Sure." They followed them, leaving behind most of the Fells Church gang. Stefan, Damon, Matt, and Bonnie stood there awkwardly for a few seconds
"I, uh, I think I'll pass this one." Stefan offered, breaking the silence. He waved at them and crossed to the other side by ducking under the velvet tape that held the line in place.
"Wait for me, man." Matt said loudly, racing after him.
"Should we go together?" Bonnie inquired, glancing up at Damon with huge brown eyes.
He nodded and shrugged, "I don't see why not." She smiled at him tightly before she stepped through the entrance, Damon right behind her.
XXX
Stefan and Matt sat down at a table after getting a soda for both of them.
"This sucks. We seriously don't have dates for the tunnel of love so now we're stuck alone out here" Matt sighed.
"Yeah... I know... I kinda wish Elena was here" Stefan mumbled.
"Me too... but she'd probably be with Tyler... so here we are again" Matt sat back in the chair and took a long swig from his drink.
"Um... hey... sorry to interrupt... I'm Lexi... and this is Anna... can we um join you guys?" A tall blonde girl asked her bright green eyes friendly.
"Sure" Stefan smiled gesturing to the other two chairs at the table.
"So what brings you two cute guys to sit here alone?" The dark haired one, Anna, asked.
"We didn't have a date for the tunnel of love with our other friends so... we just kinda sat here"
"That's funny... the same thing happened to us" Lexi laughed.
Stefan laughed, "Oh... I'm Stefan by the way... and this is my best friend Matt." Stefan patted the blonde boy on the back and Anna laughed.
"Where did you guys meet?" Anna asked.
"School" They replied, "What about you... you kind of seem like the least likely of friends" Stefan added.
"Well... we were helping one another with some of our other friends and just became close over that... it was weird... I'm surprised we have so much in common" Lexi laughed again.
"Me too" Anna giggled.
"Do you girls want to play a game or something? You don't have to if you don't want to but it could keep us busy while our friends are in the tunnel of love" Matt smiled at Anna shyly.
"That would be awesome!" Lexi beamed, she was bold and Stefan liked that.
They chatted on the way over to the game with the milk bottles where you have to knock them all down to win a prize. Stefan put the money up for him and Lexi. Lexi threw and missed, leaving one standing. Stefan hit them all and won a teddy bear.
"Here you are miss" Stefan bowed handing her the teddy bear.
Lexi took it laughing, "Why thank you kind sir".
Matt put up the money for Anna and himself. Anna did the same thing as Lexi and Matt hit all of them.
"Thank God for football and baseball" He smiled giving Anna the stuffed shark he let her pick out.
"That was fun" Lexi smiled and Anna agreed, "but you know we could have hit those if we really wanted to" Anna teased.
"Of course" Stefan and Matt laughed rolling their eyes.
XXX
A few minutes later, when the four of them were seated around a table, Caroline and Matt came up to them. They were slurping from a smoothie, sharing one straw and they were so engrossed with each other it was ridiculous. They hardly glanced up at Stefan and Matt before they sat down and began making out like there was no tomorrow.
Stefan cleared his throat and Matt reddened, mumbling a "Come on, guys, there's two really pretty girls here, they don't want to see that..."
Mystic Fells' Matt caught on and he pulled away from Caroline, still keeping an arm around her shoulder as he turned to look at the 'two really pretty girls'.
Caroline giggled slightly and did the same. When they both saw Anna and Lexi, the smiles froze on their lips.
"Hey I know you two..." Matt murmured, running a hand through his hair as he tried to remember where he'd seen them before.
"I'm-"
"Lexi," Caroline interrupted. She smiled warmly and reached out to touch Lexi's hand, "How nice to see you again." But when her eyes reached Anna she narrowed them suspiciously, "What are you doing here, Anna?"
Neither got to say anything because at that moment, someone tapped her on the shoulder and she turned around to see Meredith and Jeremy, with Damon and Elena a few feet behind them.
She saw the look of alarm Jeremy and Elena shared and she couldn't blame them, because last time they'd seen Anna, she'd fed Elena's blood to her starving mother.
"What is this?" Elena asked once she'd reached them. She glared at Anna and Damon stood a few inches in front of her, as if to protect her.
"What are you doing here, Anna?" Damon snapped in an annoyed voice.
"Hey don't talk to her like that." Fells' Matt complained, "She's a really nice girl."
Damon rolled his blue eyes at him and said, "She tried to kill Elena."
"I did not." Anna protested, crossing her arms, "I just needed to save my mom. A little blood wasn't going to kill her."
"Right." Damon snorted, "That's what I always say before I feed, when I feel that little bit of sympathy and compassion for the girl I'm about to kill."
He shook his head, "What is the real reason you're here?"
Just then, a familiar voice rang out from behind him, "What's going on?" His brother pushed past the crowd of people, pulling Bonnie along with him, and when they saw Anna and Lexi they stiffened.
"I see." Stefan muttered.
"What is she doing here?!" Bonnie snapped angrily, pointing a finger at Anna, "She's nothing but trouble."
"We know that, Bonnie, calm down." Stefan said, softly squeezing her hand before he let it go and stepped forward to interrogate them.
XXX
Meredith wasn't really listening. Her attention was fixed elsewhere, on two people beside a cotton candy machine about a yard away. She could swear that it was Bonnie-she was really recognizable because of her bright hair-and Damon.
She almost gasped when Bonnie reached up and kissed him, and even more surprised when Damon paid the man behind the machine and handed her a cotton candy. He wrapped an arm around her waist and they slowly made their way toward them.
"What's wrong?" Jeremy asked, noticing her behavior. She shook her head but he still turned around to look. He raised an eyebrow, "Looks like they made up, huh?"
A few seconds later, Damon and Bonnie reached them and when they noticed the wary expression on everyone's faces, they made their way toward Fells' Stefan and Matt.
"What happened?" Fells' Damon asked with a raised eyebrow.
"Well... we met Anna and Lexi... apparently... no one here likes Anna" Matt frowned.
"To be honest," Lexi spoke up, "we were kind of worried about you two when you said what your names were... actually we were here to see Damon and Stefan... just for a friendly visit" Lexi finished with a smile.
"Right... so um... this is awkward" Anna mumbled as all eyes seemed to be glaring at her, "Lexi... maybe we should go?" Anna begged Lexi silently.
"Yes... well... call us" Lexi smiled at Mystic's Matt and Stefan as they hurried away from the group.
"Why did you do that!?" Matt shouted annoyed, he thought he really liked Anna and their friends had scared her away.
"She's dangerous, Anna is" Mystic's Damon warned. "No she isn't alright" Jeremy whispered.
"You're only saying that because you dated her!" Mystic's Stefan argued. "What?" Meredith whispered, but no one noticed.
"Let's just go home" Elena suggested calmly.
"Good idea" Mystic's Damon agreed.
XXX
Later at home everyone else had fallen asleep. Fells' Bonnie sat reading a magic book using a small flash light so that she could see. She had been trying to work up enough magic to bring Elena back and tonight was the night.
When she was sure everyone in the house was sleeping she snuck out of the house and tromped through the woods to find the spot where they'd buried her Elena. She froze when she heard someone already there. It sounded like digging. Bonnie moved behind a huge tree and looked around it. She was shocked to find Bonnie Bennett digging up Elena's coffin.
"What are you doing?" Fell's Bonnie asked. Mystic's Bonnie jumped at the sound of Bonnie's voice.
"Bon... I was... I was going to try to bring her back... I think I can... with enough magic"
"Then let me help... two witches are always better than one" Fells' Bonnie gave a half smile and helped Bonnie lift the coffin out of the hole.
They opened it and Elena looked the same way she had the day of the funeral in a clean white dress, her hair still perfect.
"She looks so peaceful" Fells' Bonnie whispered.
"I know... but she would want to be here if she could right? Tyler needs her too... he's depressed... he loved her" Mystic's Bonnie sighed and grasped the other Bonnie's hands.
They slowly began chanting and the candles around them burst into flames as their chant continued. When they finished both fell over panting and the candles died out
"Did it work?" Fells' Bonnie gasped looking over for signs of breathing. There were none.