Hey guys! So I am aware that I have not completed "I Just Completely Blew It" but I just wanted to write this short story that will probably be like about 3 chapters because I have ALWAYS wanted to see this happen on the show! I think it would be HILARIOUS… So lemme know watcha think xD
"What? No! Nuh Uh… No mamn… Sorry but NO!" Finn exclaimed, shaking his head, Rachel was NOT spending the whole weekend at HIS house.
"Finn honey, she's not coming for you." Even though the words were supposed to put him at ease he still felt a twinge of hurt by his mother's exclamation. "It's Kurt's birthday and he wants Rachel to spend the weekend because she's his best 'girl' friend. Finn, you and Rachel can put aside your difficulties for ONE weekend."
"Mom, she CHEATED on me. I LOVED her and she ruined everything we could've had together! I can't stand looking at her let alone living in the same house for a weekend!" Why couldn't Kurt have this big sleepover soiree when "finchel" existed? Now THAT would've been interesting. He tuned back into what his mom was saying.
"I'm sorry you feel that way about her but honey, Rachel is coming for KURT, and you will barely see her. Please just do this for Kurt; he's so excited about this." He mom said giving him pleading eyes.
"Fine, but If I am forced in any situation to talk to her I promise that I might not be too friendly." Finn told his mother. Kurt and Rachel want to have their little sleepover, fine. It's not like he's going to be ANY part of it.
His mother gave him a small frown but sighed and said, "Ok Finn, but you were the one that broke up with her when she was trying to be honest with you. Maybe Rachel deserves a little more empathy from you."
He was flabbergasted at his mom's words. She's on Rachel's side? What kind of mom was she, taking his ex's side in the argument? "Whatever mom," he replied and stormed up the stairs. This was going to be SOME weekend.
Rachel arrived right when his family was sitting down for dinner Friday night. As soon as Kurt opened the door and Rachel stepped through the Hudson-Hummel door with exuberance, she squealed, "Let's get this Kurt Hummel/Rachel Berry Sleepover Weekend Extravaganza started!" She laughed, hugging Kurt.
Finn's mom came from the kitchen to greet Rachel, "Rachel!" she shouted grabbing her in a tight bear hug. "We're so glad to have you! We've missed you, you little ball of energy!" His mother continued.
With that, Burt came in from the living room, "Oh hey Rach, I've missed you, and especially you're baking. One of the favorite parts of my week is when you would bring over your baked treats; maybe while you're here you can grace us with some of those brownies you make." Burt said wagging his eyebrows toward her.
She laughed, "Sure thing Burt." With that Finn's stepfather showed off a HUGE smile obviously pleased. Finn stomach growled at the thought of Rachel's brownies. When they were together she was ALWAYS making him baked treats and he now yearned for another taste of one of her famous homemade brownies.
As Finn was unknowingly smiling towards her at the thought of her baking, Rachel finally noticed him sitting at the dining room table. Her face turned pink when she saw him smiling towards her. "Um hey Finn, It's nice to see you," Rachel stated awkwardly.
Her words broke him away from his creepy gaze and his face turned into a mask of nonchalance. "Oh Hi," he replied without an ounce of friendliness to his tone and he turned to the adults. "Mom, Burt, can we have dinner, I'm starved."
All 5 of them sat down at dinner whilst Finn's parent's asked how Rachel has been and Kurt and Rachel raved about their plans for the weekend. The whole dinner, Finn sat there silently eating his meal peeking secretly at Rachel when she wasn't looking. She seemed so… happy. She was giggling nonchalantly with friends while he sat in his room everyday just thinking about her. Finn was the one that broke up with her, so why was he the one left utterly alone, feeling like crap?
It was midnight and Finn was lying in bed, staring at the ceiling, not being able to fall asleep because the knowledge that the only girl he had ever loved was in the bedroom RIGHT next door and he could hear her mesmerizing laugh every two minutes.
An idea came to his head. Kurt still has his sunglasses from when Finn let him borrow them the other day. Maybe he could go in there and ask for them back because even with their break up, Finn was dying to see Rachel's smile and to hear her laugh, plus he would be able to see her in her PJ's, BONUS! It was decided. He swung up out of bed and made his way to Kurt's room. He was just about to open the door when e heard HIS name being whispered on the other side of the door.
"Rachel, Finn will come around eventually, you just have to be patient, he is really hurt by what you did." Kurt said. Finn wanted to punch his stepbrother for revealing so much to Rachel. Sure he cried himself to sleep for a week after their breakup and refused to come out of his room, but Rachel didn't need to know that.
"I know I was stupid Kurt, I just felt so hurt by Finn's lies and I saw him smiling at Santana in the hallway and I knew it was just a matter of time before he broke up with me and they got together." Crap, she saw that? Finn didn't even know why he did it; he was trying to be nice so she would back off. Rachel continued, "Puck was the one who consoled me, I just felt humiliated and unwanted and so I wanted Finn to feel the same way I felt. After I just felt so ashamed that I could do something like that to someone I loved." Love? Did she just say she loved him? "I needed to tell Finn the truth, so I did but I never thought that he would be as hurt as he was. Did you see him at dinner, Kurt? He hates me. I treated him like he was nothing to me when he is so much more. He was my everything and I blew it, Kurt. I ruined my one chance at true love." Finn could hear her start to cry and he wanted nothing but to run in there and hug her tight, but then she would know he was spying and what would she think of him then? He silently walked back to his room and thought about what Rachel had said.
She had no idea how much she truly hurt him. Whenever he imagined his future she would be in it. He planned to marry her and have a family. When he found out she cheated on him, he thought that maybe what he was feeling was all in his head and they were just meant to be high school sweethearts. Now Finn thought that maybe she did feel the same way he did and that she just made one stupid little mistake. He knew that she didn't care about Puck, that she just felt hurt. Finn forgave Rachel; he was going to tell her tomorrow. But he couldn't be in a relationship with her right now, not yet.