Unforgettable Love
by CollegeStar21
Summary
Brittany Pierce and Santana Lopez were finally a couple and not to be open at McKinley High. Everybody knew they had something going with them and didn't care because they knew that Santana would kick their asses for messing with her girlfriend.
But what happens when Brittany's old childhood best friend/first ever girlfriend, Rachel Berry moves back to Lima after being in California for so long, shows up Brittany's Jher Senior year all grown up and not the same girl she was when she was younger,sparking up feelings that Brittany struggled to long forget while also putting a strain on her relationship with Santana Lopez?
Will Brittany and Rachel start their friendship over as just best friends or will they finally admit that they still want each other? Find out what happens.
Season 4 Rachel Berry clothes and hair style in this story. Minor Brittana relationship but Brittberry romance hopefully in the end.
Enjoy.
In Brittany's POV.
Today was going to be a magical day for me and my favorite unicorn. I'm inviting her over to go swimming in my pool. That right I said unicorn because she is one like myself and I love her with all my heart and I know she loves me too. It was the summer before our first year of high school and so far we've spent everyday together.
Oh you have no clue who I am right or who I'm talking about when I say unicorn? I'm Brittany Susan Pierce. It's Brittany bitch. I'm 14 years old and live in lima Ohio. Some say I'm stupid because I think differently. I'm smart in different ways like with people.
Like did you know that dolphins are just gay sharks? It's a true fact but people don't seem to get it but my girlfriend's parents are dolphins and I totally respect them because they support me and their daughter together. My parents get me and so does my best friend. She's like the only person that understands me.
Her name is Rachel Barbra Berry, she has gay dads as her parents. We've been best friends since we were 3 years old and now were both 14 and she's been my girlfriend not just best friend since we were 11 and were happy together. I can see myself with her forever.
"Brittany can you feed Lord Tubbington now?" My mom said from the living room and I rush downstairs to feed my really fat cat Lord Tubbington, he keeps reading my notebook that I now have to hide. He smokes too and Rachie is working with me to get him stop.
"Lord Tubbington it's time for food then Rachie is going to be here soon." He listens to me and I feed him then I wait by the door for my super cute and tiny girlfriend. Rachel's so tiny she can fit in my pocket. She hates to be smaller then me but that just makes me love her even more.
We were each other's first kiss and that's how we started dating each other. I wait for a few minutes then the door bell rings. I opened the door knowing it's my bestie/girlfriend and saw her standing there looking upset.
"Rachie why are you upset? who hurt you?" I asked her letting her in but she just stood there.
"Brittany we need to talk." I looked at my mom and she gave me a sympathetic smile. I know what we need to talk means. She was going to break up with me and I don't know if I want to hear it.
"Why are you breaking up with me?" She frowns looking down.
"I'm moving to California as soon as were done talking." Why was she doing this to me? were supposed to be starting our first year of high school together here in Lima.
"No your not moving to California. You can't move away that far? we have school in a month." She sighs walking in and grabs my hand but I pull it away.
"Britt don't pull away from me. I don't want to move but I don't have a choice." I know she doesn't but it still hurts.
"Rachie, please don't leave me?" I tell her in tears.
"Trust me Britt, I want to be here with you as we start our first year of high school but my dads got a job in California and we have to move in our new house soon and they already signed me up for school there." I start crying.
"Why are your dads trying to break us up?" I said through my tears.
"I don't know Britt but I promise that i'll be back and if you haven't met somebody who is perfect as me? then we can pick up were we left off but if your seeing somebody then I'll be there supporting your relationship. your my bestie for life and I love you baby remember that." I just nod crying and she walks over to me with tears in her own eyes.
"I love you Bunny." She can't say that to me because it hurts too much to hear.
"I love you too Fluffy." Rachel leans in and pecks my lips and I kiss her back then I heard hunking and I knew it was time for her to leave.
"I'll never get you Rae." I just hug her with tears falling down my face then we let go.
"I'll never forget you Britt. It's not a goodbye, it's a I'll see you soon and I promise we will keep in touch with each other." She tells me before hugging my parents then kissing me again and leaves.
"Good bye Rachel." I said sadly before running upstairs to my room and cried for days.
Senior Year.
It was the second day of Senior Year for 17 year old Brittany S. Pierce. She was on the McKinley High cheerios, she was in New Directions which was a Glee club. She was super poplular and she was dating her best friend Santana Lopez. They were out as a couple since Junior year and they are happy but Brittany found herself thinking about Rachel Berry wishing she could see her.
"Britt? are you even listening to me?" Brittany snapped out of her thoughts and saw her girlfriend Santana staring at her confused.
"Why are you staring at me like that?" Santana raised an eyebrow at her girlfriend wonder what was up with her.
"I asked you if your ready to walk into the school since you've been standing out her for the past 20 minutes." Brittany looked around and saw that she was standing outside of McKinley and wasn't in the school yet.
"Oh sorry I just get the feeling that something is about to happen." Santana grabbed her hand worried about her.
"Come on Brittany so we can go to our lockers together before our first class." Brittany smiles lacing her fingers hers and as they were about to walk into the school when Brittany hears clicking of heels behind them and turned her head to see a girl she has never seen at McKinley High, wearing dark high heeled boots but you could tell she was short. Brittany glanced at her long sun kissed tan legs in the heels and couldn't believe a girl that short had long legs.
She's wearing black high waisted shorts that show of the outline of her nice looking ass. On the top she's wearing a light grey long sleave v neck top that was tucked inside her shorts, that shows off her slim figure but also shows off her nice breast size. Her hair is long,dark brown with light brown highlights that almost looked blonde at ends. She had bangs and her makeup was dark a little but she looked really hot. She saw that her eyes were brown and she a lightly big nose but it made her look cute in a unique way.
"Fluffy?" She muttered watching the girl walk into the school.
"Who is Fluffy baby?" Brittany looked at Santana and sighs.
"Fluffy is my childhood best friend and my old girlfriend Sanny, I think she moved back and wants to get back together." Brittany tells her pouting.
"B your just going to have to tell your fake friend/old girlfriend that you have a real girlfriend now." She glared at Santana.
"Fluffy the Unicorn is not fake. She's real Sanny and what you said was totally mean." She says shaking her head and walked into school.
Santana stood there after hearing the words her girlfriend just said and shook her head knowing Brittany had her moments.
"I'll talk to B about this Fluffy person later at lunch." Santana thought before walking into the school.
With Brittany and Rachel.
Brittany walked into the girl's bathroom to fix her pony tail when some girl walked out in one of the stalls and Brittany turned around beaming with joy.
"Fluffy?" The girl heard that nickname and gasped seeing who was standing in front of her.
"Bunny?" 17 year old Rachel Berry asked her old girlfriend/childhood best friend.
"Oh my god it's really you." Brittany squeals picking her up and spins her around carefully.
"Oh my goodness, Britt put me down right now before I hit my head on the wall." Rachel says squealing and smiles when she puts her down.
"Sorry Rachie I still can't believe how tiny you are but you grew a little. I'm just so glad your here." Brittany smiles at her and ran her fingers through her hair loving the silky soft feeling of her hair again.
"I missed you Rae, can I kiss you?" Brittany asked hopefully." Rachel looked into her blue eyes and shook her head.
"I missed you too Bunny but we can't have you cheating on your girlfriend." Brittany frowns wondering how she knew about Santana.
"You know about me and Santana? I've been a bad Unicorn." Brittany tells her pouting.
"You could never be a bad Unicorn Britts, you are the Unicorn and it's okay that you've moved on." Rachel tells her sincerely. Brittany sighs.
"Oromise to be my bestie for life even when I'm no longer yours?" Rachel walked closer to her and leans in whispering in her ear.
"You will always be mine even if we're just friends." Brittany blushes and looked at her placing her hand on her cheek.
"Can I please kiss you?" Rachel thought about it and nodded.
"Yes but on the cheek only." Brittany pouts but smiles kissing her cheek then pulls back and they stare at each other.
"Britts I'll see you later, how about you come over for dinner tonight?" She said okay and Rachel writes down her address in Brittany's notebook and her cell number before leaning up and kisses her cheek then both girls walk out and hugged each other before going to their next class.
Brittany watched the girls she was in love with walk away from her again but she was going to see her tonight. She turns around ready to go to her class when she saw her girlfriend Santana standing there looking hurt and confused.
Find out what happens next.