Hey guys! So this is the first chapter of my new Mitchie/Alex fanfiction "Change Her Ways". Please leave comments and criticism, it'd mean a lot! I think that within the next few chapters I will be switching it to the alternating point of views like I did in my last story, I seem to write that way better. Tell me what y'all thinkkk! Thank youuu! :]
Disclaimer: I do not own anything in this story, all of the rights go to the owners.
Alex Russo walked through the doors of Tribeca High with her best friend Harper like she does every single morning during the week. They made their way towards their lockers which were next to each other only because Alex had somehow convinced Mr. Laritate to put them next to one another. Alex put her bag into her locker and grabbed some books for her next 3 periods, even though she knew she wouldn't even glance at them during class. Both Harper and Alex finished up at their lockers and shut them. Alex turned around and saw the most beautiful sight her eyes have ever had the pleasure of viewing. Harper turned to Alex to see her mouth slightly ajar and her staring at something down the hall. She followed Alex's gaze and saw the new girl, Mitchie looking confused.
"Who is THAT?" Alex said, still not tearing her gaze away from the brunette. Harper rolled her eyes, knowing Alex's plan already. Let me tell you something, Alex was known for two things. One: for being the biggest badass at Tribeca High, and two: for being the biggest player. She was openly gay, and didn't give two shits about what anyone thought about her. Alex had girls falling for her left and right, and she even made straight girls question themselves. One thing about Alex though, she fucked them and dumped them. No one could tame Alex, she was all in it for the sex, every single time.
"She's new. Her name's Mitchie Torres. Don't even THINK about it Alex," Harper answered, already annoyed. Harper knew that Alex was going to try to get into her pants as soon as possible. I mean, Mitchie was gorgeous, and right up Alex's alley. Alex ignored Harper's comment and already had an idea.
"Watch this," Alex said with a smirk as she walked towards the new girl who was still standing there looking puzzled. Alex made her way towards Mitchie. Cleverly, Alex "accidently" bumped into Mitchie lightly, but hard enough to knock one of the binders Mitchie was holding onto the floor. Alex immediately bent over to pick it up, as did Mitchie.
"Oh my goodness, I am SO sorry," Alex said as she picked up Mitchie's binder and turned to look up at her. Mitchie was now standing up straight again. As they looked right into each other's brown eyes for a moment, Mitchie realized she was looking at the prettiest girl she'd ever seen.
"Oh no, it's my fault, I shouldn't have been standing right in the middle of the hallway," Mitchie answered with a slight frown and embarrassment written on her face. Alex gently handed Mitchie her binder and smiled brightly at the new girl. Mitchie gave a small, yet shy smile back that Alex thought was adorable.
"No, it was my fault. I haven't seen you around before, are you new here?" Alex asked with her signature smile that made many, many girls' hearts melt. Mitchie honestly had never seen anyone like Alex. She thought the raven-haired girl was absolutely stunning in more ways than one. Her face was gorgeous, and her body was banging in her short jean shorts, white shirt and black vest. You see, Mitchie has been questioning her sexuality since the 8th grade, and she was still trying to figure herself out.
"Yeah, today's my first day," Mitchie answered bashfully.
Harper stood watching the two girls interact. She hated that Alex toyed with so many girls' hearts. She actually felt bad for any girl that got physically attracted to Alex, because she already knew what the outcome was going to be. Alex had what people called the Russo Charm, even though it should really be called the Alex Charm because only one of the Russo siblings possessed it. She made girls' think that she truly cared about them, and as soon as they got into her and opened themselves up, Alex made her way in, got what she wanted, and ditched them. It was terrible actually, but Harper was Alex's best friend since they were in kindergarten, and as long as she treated Harper with respect, she didn't really mind it.
"Oh wow, I could show you around if you want? You look pretty confused," Alex responded with another signature smile. Mitchie was already beginning to feel attracted to Alex. She knew she thought the middle Russo was drop dead gorgeous, and now she even started to be interested in getting to know her. But Mitchie figured Alex would never even swing that way. No, Alex was way too good-looking to be into girls, considering she could probably get any guy she wanted. Mitchie just shrugged it off and took it as Alex just being nice.
"Thank you, that'd be great. You know, if you don't mind." Mitchie said shyly. She didn't know anyone yet and she sure didn't want to scare her first candidate as anything close to a friend away by being too eager or overexcited.
"I don't mind at all," Alex responded with a flirty smile. "I'm Alex Russo, and you are?" she said, still shooting Mitchie a wide, beaming smile.
"Mitchie. Mitchie Torres," Mitchie answered with a smile just as wide as Alex's.
"Here let me see your schedule," Alex said.
Mitchie handed Alex her schedule and Alex laughed slightly as she saw that she had every single class with the new girl. What were the odds? Today was really Alex's lucky day, and Mitchie's for that matter.
"Lucky you, we have every class together," Alex said as she handed Mitchie back her schedule with a smirk. Mitchie smiled brightly back. She was really happy because she knew it meant she'd probably be getting to know Alex more.
"Good, so you lead the way to first period?" Mitchie said, still smiling. Already Mitchie was beginning to feel more comfortable around Alex.
"Absolutely," Alex answered as she interlocked her arm with Mitchie's and began walking to their first period English class. Mitchie was shocked when she felt the warmth of the contact with Alex's arm. She continued smiling realizing that she had just met Alex and they were basically already friends. As they walked, Alex turned around towards Harper who was still standing there watching and gave her a wink. Harper rolled her eyes and headed off to her own class, feeling sorry for Mitchie already, knowing she would soon be falling for the Russo Charm.
Alex let go of Mitchie's arm as they walked into their English class and they both missed the contact with each other immediately.
"Hey Mr. Snyder, we've got a new student here," she said with a smile. Mr. S was Alex's favorite teacher. He was the coolest guy ever, and he was the only teacher that respected Alex. Also, this was the only class where Alex would even think about following directions, just because of how nicely Mr. Snyder has always been to her.
"Ah, good morning Russo, and good morning," Mr. S looked back down as his attendance sheet and found the new girls name "Mitchie Torres. Nice to have you in our class," he finished.
"Good morning, and thank you, it's nice to be here," Mitchie answered with a small smile gracing her face.
"You can sit wherever you want. There's not assigned seats in my class but, by the looks of it I'm guessing you want to sit next to Russo here," Mr. Snyder said as he smiled back at the two.
Mr. Snyder knew Alex was a lesbian, and he honestly thought Alex was a boss for how many girls she got. He was like a big kid, honestly. And he and Alex were pretty tight. Alex rolled her eyes and let out a laugh for reasons Mitchie didn't know. Then, Alex grabbed Mitchie's hand to lead her to the back of the room where she sat. Mitchie basically gasped when Alex took her hand. She found it to be oddly soft and warm, and she loved the feeling of it. Alex smirked as she saw Mitchie's distraught face when they came in contact again. They both sat down next to each other and paid attention to Mr. S as he took to the front of the room and began talking.
In the middle of the class period, Alex looked up to see Mitchie staring at her. Alex gave her a smile but Mitchie quickly looked down at her desk. Alex slightly laughed as she saw Mitchie blush. She thought the new girl was really cute, and she wondered how fast it would take her to get into her pants. As the bell rang to signal next period, Mitchie got up first and Alex took this time to check out Mitchie's ass in the tight black pencil skirt she was wearing. Alex knew she wanted Mitchie now, as her butt was incredible. Mitchie stopped and turned around just as Alex looked away in time, thankfully.
"Where to next?" Mitchie asked with a smile.
"Ugh, Algebra," Alex groaned. Alex hated Algebra with a burning passion. Her teacher was the devil in disguise, and she HATED Alex more than any other student she had ever taught.
"What's so bad about Algebra?" Mitchie asked as they walked together towards their next class.
"Everything. The teacher is the biggest bitch in the world, she hates my guts. But it's okay, I catch up on most of my sleep in that class," Alex answered as she smiled at Mitchie.
"Hmm, maybe that's why she doesn't like you," Mitchie said as she smirked back at Alex. Already the two girls were becoming more comfortable and friendlier towards one another. Mitchie, wanted to get to know Alex because she was attracted to her and something about Alex drew her in. Alex, on the other hand, had different plans. To her, Mitchie was just like any other girl, except, she was fresh meat. She was going to make Mitchie fall for her, do her thing, and leave, just like normal Alex Russo.
"No, I'm just too cool for her," Alex responded with a cocky grin as they continued walking.
"Yeah alright, let's go with that." Mitchie said, still smiling back at Alex.
Back at Mitchie's old school, she was kind of a loner. She had one really close friend, and that was Caitlin. She was there for her throughout everything. She knew that Mitchie was struggling with her sexuality, and she knew that Mitchie was also one of the most amazing singers she had ever heard. Those were Mitchie's two biggest secrets, and Caitlin and her mom were the only ones that knew both of them. Mitchie lived with just her and her mom, her dad left them shortly after Mitchie was born. Mitchie was all that her mother had, and vice versa. They decided to move when Connie, Mitchie's mom, was offered a better job here in New York.
Alex and Mitchie walked into Mrs. Smith's Algebra class minutes before the bell was about to ring. It was the first time the whole school year that Alex wasn't late to her class.
"Ah, Ms. Russo, on time for once?" Mrs. Smith said in her high pitched, annoying, cocky voice.
"Yes, I just couldn't wait to find out what you have in store for us to learn today Mrs. S!" Alex answered sarcastically, pitching her voice higher and putting on a fake excited face.
"Have a seat Alexandra," Mrs. S replied, her expression changing to an annoyed one as Alex stood there planted next to Mitchie. Mitchie chuckled when she heard Mrs. Smith call Alex 'Alexandra'. She thought it sounded too proper for someone like Alex.
"What's so funny Torres?" Alex asked as she turned to a giggling Mitchie.
"Nothing, Alexandra," Mitchie answered, now giggling uncontrollably.
"I swear if you ever call me that again," Alex said with a fake sneer.
"Whatcha' gonna' do about it Russo?" Mitchie answered, still smiling and feeling more confident and calm around Alex now.
"Excuse me Miss, but who are you and what are you doing in my Algebra class?" Mrs. Smith interrupted their flirty argument with an arrogant tone.
"Oh, I'm sorry. I'm Mitchie Torres, I'm a new student," Mitchie answered politely. She was known for being an exceptional student at her old school, and she liked being liked by teachers. This year though, she just wanted to be normal instead of being the nerdy girl like last year, so she decided to take all regular classes instead of advanced ones. Alex rolled her eyes at Mitchie's new courteousness; she didn't know Mitchie was a 'good girl'.
"Ah, Ms. Torres, it's a pleasure to have you here. I've seen your records, and you seem to be a great student." Mrs. Smith said, her tone changing from cocky to sweet.
Alex sat down in the back and started mocking Mrs. S, mouthing her words with ridiculous facial expressions. Mitchie caught Alex from the corner of her eye and couldn't help but chuckle. Alex was so cute to Mitchie, and funny, and sweet. Mitchie didn't even realize how much she was starting to become intrigued by Alex.
"Thank you Mrs. Smith," Mitchie said, getting her quiet laughing from Alex's tactics under control. Alex just rolled her eyes again and laughed.
"And maybe you could help out Ms. Russo a bit, considering she doesn't know how to put effort into much of anything except goofing off," Mrs. Smith said rudely as she turned to face Alex. She must have seen Alex mocking her, and it wasn't the first time she had caught her making fun of her.
"Yeah, maybe I could help her out a bit," Mitchie answered with a smirk as she continued staring into Alex's beautiful brown eyes from the front of the room.