A/N: Welcome to my newest story, this one is completely different from all my others, never had I written a fic with Bonnie involved with both of the brothers in this way and it's been awhile since I used the supernatural element in my fics. Most of the time I'm more of the AH (all human) type girl, but I thought I'd switch it up. Let me know what you think, and please. Enjoy.
Bonnie never pictured herself to be in this particular situation before. Ever. Involved with two brothers— vampires for that matter—whom she both loved and could picture herself being with for a long time. She even pictured herself turning for one of them, but being a witch felt all too good for her to consider turning at the moment, but maybe some time down the road she would turn into a vampire and ride off into the moonlight with either Salvatore, but for now, she was having her fun. Living it up in a mansion in the middle of nowhere where they couldn't be bothered from the outside world.
People around town knew about the arrangement that they had going on and at first there was nothing but disgust, but after two years, they were used to seeing Bonnie with either Stefan or Damon on her arm but never both when they would decide to show their faces.
She liked to hang out with them separately though when they first got together they all hung out in a group all the time, but when she got to really know them and realize that their personalities were different, she preferred the one-on-one time so they could be themselves.
Bonnie smiled as she was pulled into the arms of Stefan in the hot tub then soon their lips met. Stefan was more of the romantic, she found, but a rough lover. He would take her out on dates and make sure that she was as relaxed as she could possibly be and was pleased to the absolute fullest. She would never admit this to either of them, but she fell in love with him first.
When she first met him, she was out shopping with her friends and she caught him staring from the corner of her eye. He was cute from what she could tell but when he built up enough courage to walk up to her, she saw nothing but hotness. He was polite and made her blush multiple times before he even introduced himself and when he did, he made her blush even more after that. Bonnie instantly felt connected to him and started picturing her in a white dress walking down the aisle right then and there.
When they first had sex, round one was as she expected it to be; nice, slow, and pleasing. Round two was anything but. They got familiar with each other bodies because of the pace so she figured he felt more confident to kick things up a notch and quite frankly, she was glad that he did. He let his true colors come out and she liked this side of him. When it was over, they found themselves in a makeout session before cuddling and sleeping. It was the first time that she has ever went to bed with a smile on her face. His hand was running along the length of her arm and a kiss would be placed on her shoulder and as his movements got slower and slower, she feel asleep.
Stefan pulled away from her lips then kissed her neck once afterwards removing the shades that she had shielding her face so he could stare into those eyes of hers. She was going to declare her love for him right then, but was pulled into the arms of her other lover, Damon.
When she first met the older brother, she was at her past job bartending for a local club. Men would flirt with her and hit on her all the time and she quickly got used to tuning those guys out, but somehow Damon's voice made it past the barrier.
Even in the dimness, she could tell that he had those ocean blue eyes that she found herself get lost in quickly.
She laughed when he bought her a drink and they toasted to something random before downing their shots. He stayed with her until the club closed and made sure that she made it home safely before giving her his number to which she called him the very next day. Sure she was with Stefan at the time, but she didn't want to put all her eggs in one basket although she had a feeling that Stefan would be in her life for a while.
Damon was the more carpe diem of the two. She always had a rush whenever they would go out and her head would spin with excitement and a smile never left her face whether it was from excitement or just simply from having too good of a time to not smile. She did things with him that she probably would've never done, like bungee jumping for one, but she was glad that he pushed her limits because if he hadn't, she would've never felt more alive and free.
She faintly remembers their first time, not because it was bad but because they were so caught up in the moment that she couldn't comprehend what was happening until she came saying his name. Their second time was the next morning and things were less rushed but it was still so good that she bit her lower lip mostly through it all with her eyes closed. She fell in love with how he made her feel quickly, but it took a little time after that when she fell in love with him.
Imagine her surprise when she was once on a date with Stefan and he took her to his house to show her around when her eyes widened because he just introduced the other guy that she was seeing as his older brother. It put her in a tough spot, but she decided to come clean and since the brothers had loved this woman so deeply they offered her the idea of them sharing her.
Bonnie wasn't for it at first, but somehow she found herself naked on the bed with the two brothers stripped down as well and experienced her first threesome and the pleasure was all too good for her to turn down their offer again. It was only a month after that when they told her their secret thinking that she has to know and that's when they found out that she had a little secret herself which they were glad about because they didn't have to worry about her running away in the middle of the night one day scared for her life that she got herself involved with two vampires.
Bonnie gave Damon the evil eye as he removed the band keeping her hair together in a bun at the top of her head causing the ends of her hair to hit the hot water. She had plans later and now she would have to spend extra time getting ready touching up her hair.
He only grinned and chuckled when she rolled her eyes at him. She moved back to Stefan's side and it was his turn to roll his eyes. Bonnie smiled and shortly after that got out so she could get ready for her dinner date with her best friends.
She hummed a tune looking at her reflection going over her hair with a hair straightener after a quick shower. Bonnie turned then smiled hearing another hum join in and looked back forward in the mirror when he hugged her from behind.
"I'm going on a date with the girls."
"I remember."
She smiled at him through the mirror and when she was finished turned in his arms only to be lifted on the counter top. They kissed only once lingering their lips together before slowly pulling away.
"Be back before twelve."
"Are you putting me on a curfew?" She smiled.
"You're always on a curfew when it's my night to have you, beautiful."
She acted a little shy and blushed turning her head away.
Stefan lifted the corner of his mouth and turned her head to face him then kissed her again. "You're so cute."
Bonnie playfully rolled her eyes gaining a full teeth smile from him. They talked for a few minutes before she hopped off the counter to change only settling on an outfit when Stefan voiced his approval.
She found it a little odd of how territorial he was of her. Whenever they would go out in public, when men would check her out (although knowing that she was fully spoken for), Stefan would make it known that he didn't approve. He would either kiss her, wrap and arm around her or stare the man down so he had no choice but to look away. She would always smile when he did that, it proved that he cared for her a lot and she'd be frightened if the day ever came that he didn't do that anymore.
Before she left the house, Bonnie decided to stop by Damon's room feeling a little bad about how she treated him in the hot tub. She never used one brother to make the other one jealous, not on purpose at least, but she did today and she knew that it hurt his feelings some. She didn't bother knocking on his bedroom door, she just walked in and joined him on his bed. Bonnie frowned noticing that he was still upset so she kissed him mentally letting out a breath of relief when he kissed her back. She wasn't one to apologize but she figured that this situation called for it.
"I'm sorry for kind of rubbing my relationship with Stefan in your face. I've never done that before to either of you so I'm sorry."
Damon grinned. "That's really hot."
Bonnie simply shook her head but smiled. "Me apologizing turns you on?"
She got her answer when his lips met her neck and his tongue came out to play leaving a trail from her collarbone up to her chin. Bonnie enjoyed the feel and had to force herself to move away not wanting to be late. He promised her that he would finish what had started later and Bonnie only smiled walking out his room before practically skipping down the stairs trying to get to her car as quickly as possible. Sure she could just use her magic to teleport herself from point A to point B, but she decided a long time ago that she would only use her powers as a last resort but makes sure that she practices every week with either one of the brothers and sometimes both of them.
Caroline and Elena smiled seeing their friend walk through the door surprisingly on time. They almost started to leave an hour later because with the boys on both sides of her, almost every time one of them would distract her and they find themselves bored trying to save all interesting topics for when Bonnie came. Today, however, they were glad that they left on time otherwise Bonnie would've been the one bored out of her mind.
"Hey girlies." The friends smiled. "What's the 4-1-1?"
"Wow, you've been isolated from the world far too long." Caroline shook her head.
Elena chuckled. "People usually resort to the "what's up" approach."
Bonnie rolled her eyes. "So what's up?"
Caroline let out a breath and she knew that somehow, someway her powers were needed. "We— as in Mystic Falls, have sort of a hybrid problem."
"What do you mean?" Bonnie leaned in closer.
"Klaus skipped town going to who knows where, doing God knows what, so I guess since they don't have their sire around, they felt like they could cause trouble. Throwing parties, setting fires, terrorizing the people," Elena listed off. "They need to be stopped."
"We hate to ask you for this, Bon, but we looked through all options possible, but we need you to get rid of them."
"I need a spell first," Bonnie thought, "I need to look but I highly doubt there is such a spell. Hybrids are fairly new, I don't think they were around all those centuries ago. I need some time."
The friends nodded. Bonnie looked down in thought and Caroline sighed.
"Bonnie, you don't have to do this. We just thought that we should get rid of them, but I'm sure that Klaus would be back and maybe they'll go back to the way they were; out of sight, out of mind."
"Thanks, Care, but I want to do this. I've been itching to use my powers, in a good way of course, and since this is the last resort, I'll do it. I just have to talk to Emily first, maybe she knows something."
"Thanks, Bon." Elena smiled placing her hand on top of hers.
The girls moved on to less serious manners like their relationships. Bonnie had double the story, of course, but her friends seemed to help.
If she was honest, she would admit that she was shocked that her friends accepted her choice of life by being with and living with the Salvatore brothers, but she was grateful that she had someone by her side. Her parents disapproved and majorly. At first she was going to tell them that she was only dating Stefan, knowing that he's more of the man that you would bring home, but knew that it wouldn't be fair to keep Damon in the dark so she came clean and till this day there's a part of her that regrets her choice.
After catching up with the girls since she still had some time left before Stefan wanted her home, she decided to go to the old witches house to see if she could contact Emily. Luckily, it worked and Bonnie found herself in a sit down with her ancestor.
-::-
Stefan was sitting in his chair reading a book when she came in. He smiled up at her then frowned slightly seeing the look on her face. He knows her all too well to know that something's troubling her mind.
"Baby, what's wrong?"
Bonnie sighed removing her dress, "I just have a lot on my mind."
Stefan sat the book down and walked over to her wrapping his arms around her. "What is it?"
She shrugged, "Caroline and Elena told me that they were having a hybrid problem, that Mystic Falls is having a hybrid problem. Klaus' minions are causing trouble around town and they wanted me to help so I agreed and when I left the restaurant, I went to visit Emily to see if there was a spell I can use."
"Was there?"
"Yeah, but it takes up a lot of power and I… I know I have it in me, but I just don't know how much I can take. I've barely used my powers, but I don't want to let everyone down and-"
"Hey," Stefan gathered her head in his hands, "you don't have to do this. Damon and I can take them out."
"I don't want you to." She shook her head. "Once they find out that the both of you are on a killing spree, they'll gang up on you guys, I have to do this."
"I can call Klaus-"
"No, please don't. We already lost you for those months and I don't want to lose you again."
He looked in her eyes and sighed before kissing her forehead. He hated what he put her through, but it was his only option at the time. Go with Klaus and kill or don't go with Klaus and have Bonnie be killed.
Klaus took Bonnie as a threat and honestly if Stefan had refused to go with him, he wouldn't have killed Bonnie but simply forced her to use dark magic to have her join his team. With her, they would've been unstoppable and he knew that Stefan would be more than willing to tag along and he'd find himself with the best crew anyone had ever seen. The Ripper and the witch. He still gets the chills thinking about it.
Stefan managed to get a deal worked out between them in trade for his freedom and at first, Klaus was against it, but Stefan had ended up saving his life from a group of witches who wanted him gone and Klaus thought the least he could do to repay him was set him free.
Stefan wrapped his love in his arms in an embrace and pulled her close. He knew that using magic was their only hope if they wanted to protect the town, but he still didn't want her to do something that could possibly get her killed. He wouldn't know what to do with himself and was scared to think about what would happen to him if something like that ever did happen.
"Lets go to sleep, alright? We can talk more about it in the morning, you need rest."
Bonnie nodded and Stefan let her free of his hold so she could finish getting ready for bed. He watched her every move then opened his arms so she could fit between them and laid back. Bonnie looked up at him and met their lips and after a few minutes, she pulled away and declared to him her love for him. He told her as such back, then ran his hand down her hair encouraging her to close her eyes, and shortly she was asleep.
A/N: So this is chapter one! Let me know what you think in the review box and please follow/favorite if you like!
