Jim looks over to Pam who glances up at him for a second before Micheal bursts out of his office while shouting.

"Pamela Georgia Beesly! Any messages for me this morning?"

"Not my middle name and here." She hands him a message from Corporate requesting he call them as soon as possible. He returns to his office after making a racist comment and offensive joke directed toward Oscar. Jim offers a disappointed look towards the camera and resumes the notes on his desk. The phone on Dwight's desk rings and Dwight picks it up without taking his attention off of his computer. Jim decides he needs to prank Dwight to get his mind off Pam for a while. After all, he's with Karen and he's perfectly happy.

Jim walks up to Pam's desk and asks for a sheet of paper to be "faxed" back to the office. She doesn't exactly know what the scheme is but, knowing Jim, she does it without question. After she faxes—or rather hand delivers— the fax to Dwight, he immediately shoots a look at Jim who is walking to get a snack from the break room. He darts back to the paper that reads:

Dwight K. Schrute, Scranton Police Department requests to make you, Dwight K. Schrute, head of the department. We need you to quit your current job and head up to the roof to be picked up in the helicopter. Discard this message once you have decided. Good Day, SPD.

Dwight looks around and then writes something on a pad of paper and stashes it in the bottom drawer of his desk. The fax is crumpled and thrown in the recycling.

Back in the break room, Jim and Pam share snickering laughs and knowing stares sitting across from each other. As Pam tries to hide her laugh, Jim looks at her with his big, loving eyes. They both stop laughing and just stare at each other for a while. Jim Halpert, a fun guy who is with a great girl, has no reason to be in a break room with the receptionist, laughing at their co-worker for a prank they pulled, yet here he is. Realizing his current state, he stands up and heads back to his desk while Pam is left still sitting at the table, slightly confused.

...

As Jim makes his way to the door with Karen, he doesn't even look in the direction of Pam's desk while he says goodnight to everyone. He heads out the door, regretting his decision to reject Pam and stay with Karen, but he couldn't just leave her. He wasn't going to be that guy. And he knows Pam wasn't going to be the other woman.