Note: I do not own x-men or Marvel comics in anyway

A/N: This is my first Kitty fic so don't be too harsh. Also if you really like it and want more then let me know in a review otherwise i'll stop here instead of writing more to it and possibly screwing it up. hope you guys like it. Also i would like to dedicate this story to my first reviewer ever Pyromanic because i know you like Kyro and you were the first person to review my story so heres a huge thanks to you and ENJOY!

Cheating isn't a crime, right?

Kitty is caught between two different boys. Both on the wrong side of the line, and both attempting to win over her heart. A story for all those Lancitty/Kyro lovers out there. Lancitty/Kyro

Kitty sat on the cold wooden bench waiting. The cold of the winter snow seeped into her skin but still she waited just like she promised. No one else knew she was here and no one ever would not if she had anything to do with it. A warming sensation came to her back and she looked up to see John standing behind her with a small fire held in the palm of his hand. He extinguished the fire and pulled Kitty into his arms wrapping his long trench coat around her to keep her warm. He kissed her passionately sending shivers through her spine like lightening. She turned to leave and he reluctantly released her as that sent a silent message with their eyes telling each other the same time next week.

Kitty knocked on the door to the brotherhood house, a cold shiver of ice running through her veins as she waited. The door was opened and she was greeted by Pietro, who then pushed her inside to the lounge.

"Hello pretty Kitty" she heard a voice say

She looked up from her toes and saw Lance looking up at her. She forced the guilt out of her eyes and walked into the room and over to him. She kissed him lightly on the lips as he held her close to help fill her with warmth. She tried to think about him and only him but he thoughts kept returning to a certain Australian and she just could not help herself. He pulled her in closer and they sat together watching a movie on t.v until she realized the time and whispered that she had to leave before wolverine hunted her down.

She walked into the mansion in silence not even acknowledging the peoples welcoming voices as they talked to her. She pushed open the door to her room and flopped down on her bed beside the window.

"Kitty, what's wrong?" a feminine southern voice asked quietly sounding genuinely caring for once

"Rogue what am I going to do?" she asked the other girl "I love them both but I don't know I just can't hurt them."

Rogue already knew what Kitty was talking about as they had spent endless nights talking about her predicament. She sat down on the bed next to Kitty.

"Close your eyes and tell me what you see" Rogue said

This completely confused Kitty but she still obeyed

"I see myself cheating on two of the worlds best guys. I see myself kissing them. I see myself—" Kitty stopped tears choking her words

"What is it Kitty?" Rogue asked kindly truly caring about the girl beside her

"I see myself falling, no jumping off the mansion roof. I see my own funeral. I see John and Lance dying of the pain I left behind" she sobbed sitting up now

"Kitty you can't go on like this otherwise that's what will happen you have to pick one."

"I know I do but how?" Kitty cried falling into Rogues arms

"Just trust me" Rogue replied

Rogue then summoned up Jeans telepathic powers and looked into Kittys mind and thoughts. Rogue pulled back from her search having found what she needed.

"Chose John" she whispered before releasing her hold on Kitty and leaving the room.

Kitty sat on her bed staring at the door Rogue had gone out almost two hours ago. She had to tell lance she just did not know how. She got up off her bed and pushed the glass doors that lead to the balcony open and walked out into the cold winter's night air. It was dark outside and the snow was falling lightly around her. She looked up into the sky and saw the stars shining unearthly bright down on her. She had to do it tonight or not at all. She jumped lightly down from the balcony that was located up two stories and landed crouched in the soft white snow. She pushed herself up from her crouch and started running. She ran the entire way to the brotherhood house and collapsed on the doorstep to catch her breath. When she could breathe again she knocked on the door. A sleepy looking Lance with slightly messed up hair answered the door.

"Kitty what's wrong?" he asked worriedly "it's like midnight"

Kitty threw herself into a hug with Lance, tears streaming slowly down her face.

"Lance" she whispered "I'm so, so sorry"

"What for Kitty?"

"I…I…I can't do this anymore, we just won't work I'm sorry" she whispered choking the words out

"Are you breaking up with me?" a confused Lance asked

Kitty just nodded, turned, and walked defiantly away.

Kitty continued walking through the snow, ignoring the cold that was seeping through the thin cloth of her top. She continued until she came to an old looking house that no one else knew about. She knocked on the door praying with all hope that someone would be there. The door was opened and a pair of red on black eyes looked out.

"Hello petite" he said "what brings you to the acolyte mansion?"

"I need to talk to John."

The Cajun then turned around and called back into the house. John appeared from somewhere upstairs looking shocked when he saw who it was.

"Kitty!" he cried wrapping his arms around her and rubbing some warmth back into her body "what are you doing here?"

"I choose you" she whispered before she collapsed from cold in his arms.