This is how I would have liked the conversation in Breadstix to go, but even I know it would have made no difference.
"...So you spend months tormenting me, calling me terrible name, then Hate Kiss me and now after one conversation in a bar you want us to be together?"
"I never hated you. I hated me for being such a coward. Here I am big and strong and I live in fear. There you are small and frail and fearless. You proudly strut through the halls like you own the place. I wasn't trying to punch the gay out of you, I was trying to punch it out of me. No I never hated you. I regret everything I did to you, but I don't regret that Kiss. That was the best moment of my life and first time I couldn't deny what I am. You were so strong and proud and...
Beautiful
...I just couldn't stop myself. I'm sorry for any pain it caused you, but I can't bring myself to regret that Kiss, I just can't. It's taken me a long time, but I'm finally trying to be honest about what I feel, you have helped me so much, you just don't know" Dave said tentatively reaching across the table and placing his hand over Kurt's hand.
Kurt was stunned, that was one of the most romantic things anyone had ever said to him, but he's with Blaine, who thinks he is a sexy as a baby penguin, stop thinking that.
"Dave I am so proud of all the progress you have made and I would be lying if I said I wasn't moved just now and I really do want to get to know you better, this new You, but just as friends because I'm with Blaine".
Dave's face deflated, "I should go" he said getting up from the table
"no Dave, you don't have to go"
"I hope you like the candies, the butterscotch are my favorites" as Dave turns to leave another voice enters the conversation
"Mine too" says Nick...