Chapter 1

It's the 3rd night of hanging out in the Gilmore pool house after Rory quit Yale, that Logan did it. It was something he never thought he'd do. Well truth be told, that could be said for many things over the past year and half.

 Dating a goody too shoes girl like Rory, something he thought he'd never do;

 Exclusively dating Ace, something he thought he'd never do;

 Loving a woman, something he thought he'd never do.

This one though, this one was the hardest for Logan.

"Ace, I love you with all my heart."

"I love you too Logan." She smiles that smile that kills him.

"I need to break up with you." There he had said it. The hardest sentence he's ever said.

"What? Why? How? Why?" Logan lets go of her hand and stands up.

"Rory it's just not working."

"Bullshit it's been working fine for a year and half, where is this coming from?"

"Rory, I have to think seriously about who I'm with now that I'm getting closer to graduation." Logan tells her softly, this is so hard to do.

"This is your father talking. Logan, don't let him manipulate you. We're great together. You just told me you love me."

"I do Rory but I can't be with you."

"I hate your father; I hate him I'm going to" Logan cuts her off quickly, "Ace it's my choice. I chose you against his wishes because you were everything I wasn't. Studious, driven, goal oriented. My father could argue with me all night about what the right type of women for me was & I could argue right back about how great you were. I could list all of your qualities I admired. Rory I have nothing left to argue with."

"So you're breaking up with me because it's not fun to argue with your ass of a father anymore?" Rory asks on the verge of tears.

"No I'm breaking up with you because all the qualities that made me fall in love with you, are gone; your drive, goals and ambition. Without them you just aren't as attractive to me. Good-bye Ace." With that Logan walks out before she will see him cry