It all started with a wish.
And now Timmy was hiding in his closet, Gary's arms around him, his hands in the other boy's hair as their tongues played around in each other's mouths.
He was 16 now. Gary was the same age. Both of them had grown more attractive. Timmy had been shocked when Gary had pulled him into his closet and started kissing him.
He pulled away from Gary, blushing. "…Gary?"
"Yeah, Tim-Tim?" Gary smirked.
"Why did you… do that?"
"What, kiss you?" Gary chuckled.
"Yes. Why did you do it?" Timmy asked.
"Well… I guess it's because you're cute," Gary said.
That was how it had started. And now Timmy found himself naked in his bed, Gary laying naked beside him. Only a few moments ago the two of them had lost their virginity together. Gary pulled Timmy over and embraced the other boy, running a hand through his hair. Timmy sighed contentedly.
"Gary?"
"Yeah, Tim-Tim?"
"…that was great."
"Yeah. Yeah, it was."
Timmy sat across from Gary, eating his vanilla ice cream cone. They had decided to spend a day at the mall together. Gary smiled at him, and he smiled back, reaching across the table to hold his boyfriend's hand.
"I love you."
"I love you, too, Timmy."
It all started with a wish.
The best wish Timmy had ever made.