I stood looking between myself in the mirror in my hotel room. I bit my lip as the next message came in from my best friend...with benefits, Seth Rollins.
Seth: Please come, my dick is so fucking hard and I'm dying to spank that sweet little ass of yours.
Me: I don't believe you. Prove it.
I had been teasing him all night. He was horny as hell, and I, myself, was in a teasing mood. I giggled to myself. Surely he wouldn't send me a dick pic, would he?
My phone buzzed again. I unlocked the screen and there it was in all of its hard, naked glory. Yeah, he sent me a picture of his dick. You'd think the boy had learned in the past, but he trusted me and I trusted him.
Me: Fuck, Seth. You're killing me.
Seth: No you're killing me.
Me: I'll be up in a few minutes.
I quickly stripped down and put on a red bra and panty set that Seth absolutely loved. I put on my fluffy robe, grabbed my phone and keys and got ready to walk to Seth's room.
Seth and I had been friends for a while. We got in the WWE at, pretty much, the same time. We went from NXT to the main roster all at the same time. We became really close really quick. Then, a little while into our friendship, we hooked up one drunken night and kept doing it when we felt like it ever since. It didn't mess with our friendship. I got a boyfriend, and it stopped. Seth got a girlfriend, it stopped. Then around the same time, we both broke up with our significant other and found comfort in each other again. It was no big deal to us, no strings attached.
I will admit, though, that I did feel something in our kisses and every time he touched me. It wasn't like that at first, but after my last break up, something had changed. I wouldn't tell him that, though. There was no way I'd be the one to fuck up this deal we had going.
I got to the door and knocked. Seth rushed to the door and swept me inside as fast as he could. Then he pinned me to the door and kissed me deeply. His hands found the tie of my robe and untied it. He pushed the robe down my shoulders and to the floor.
"Fuck, you're wearing that. I fucking love that," Seth said, referring to my bra and panty set. "Gah, you've been so fucking naughty all day long, teasing me, making me wait. You are gonna be punished for that."
"Is that so?" I moaned as he kissed down my neck and let his other hand wander down my crotch.
"Yeah, so get your sexy ass over to that bed and bend over," he said as he pushed me towards the bed. As I walked away, he spanked me once.
I did as he said and went over to the bed, bending over and shaking my ass at him. "Like this?" I said innocently.
"Just like that," he said, a smile clearly on his face. I felt him walk up behind me and grind his hard dick into my ass. Then, suddenly he pulled my panties down and I felt a sharp sting as he slapped my ass, making me yelp. "Damn, you're so wet for me already. I'm questioning whether or not I should punish you or fuck you already."
"Fuck me," I moaned. "Please, fuck me Seth."
"As you wish," he said as he pushed slowly inside. "Fuck! You're so tight!"
Seth quickly found a nice pace, pounding deep inside of me as I was bent over the foot of the bed. The room was suddenly filled with us moaning each other's names and the slapping of skin on skin.
"As much as I love this view, I'd love to watch you as I make you come," he said as he pulled out and flipped me over. I whimpered at his absence but was quickly relieved when he pushed himelf back in. "I'm sure you'd be more comfortable if you took that bra off."
I smiled and took off my bra, "You know me so well Rollins."
"I do," he said with a wink and smile as he pulled my legs around his neck.
"Fuck, Seth," I moaned as he reached down and massaged my clit. He shifted a bit and suddenly was hitting my spot with every thrust.
"You look so fucking beautiful like this," he moaned. "Gah, I'm getting close."
"Me too," I said breathlessly.
"Together?" he asked.
"Yes!" I moaned.
A few seconds ticked by. "Now!" Seth moaned out. I let go and felt myself tighten around him as he shot his warm seed inside of me. Seth collapsed down beside me, trying to get his breathing to even out. I laid there trying to get my shit together before I got up and went back to my room.
After a few minutes, I got up to go put my little bit of clothes back on. "Wait," Seth said stopping me in my tracks.
"Yeah?" I turned to him and asked.
"Stay," he said sincerely, something he's only ever said after a break up.
"Um, okay," I said in confusion. After a few minutes of silence, I broke it, "What's up?" Cause, clearly, something was up. Suddenly Seth was acting different.
"I can't fucking take it anymore," he said, his brown furrowed. My heart rose in my throat.
"What? Us?" I asked in confusion.
"This! You leaving after every time. I can't take it. Damn it, Michelle. I'm sorry I can't do this anymore. Not like this. I want you, all of you. I want you to be mine. I don't want to sneak around anymore. I want to be yours and you to be mine. I want you to smile proudly as you call me your boyfriend. I don't want to fuck shit up with us, but I can't hold this in any longer."
I couldn't speak, I just smiled and ran up to him, jumped in his arms, and kissed him.
"I take that as you saying you want me too?" he asked with a big smile on his face.
"Of course, you idiot," I giggled and kissed him again. "I've wanted you for a while now. After I broke up with that last loser I was dating. Something changed after we hooked up that night. The way you were there for me, how sweet you were. I felt something different in every kiss, every touch. I wanted to say something, but I didn't want to fuck us up."
"So, you felt it too?" he asked shyly.
"Yeah," I smiled. "I guess we were both idiots for not saying anything."
"Yeah, I guess so," he smiled back.
"Well, hey," I said as I gathered up my things and put them back on. "I'm pretty tired, so would you like to get in bed with me?"
"Yeah," he smiled again. "I would love to."
"Okay," I smiled sheepishly and went over to the bed to get in it. Seth laid down beside me and pulled me into his arms. I snuggled closer to him in. It felt like home.
"This is nice," Seth said as he rubbed the small of my back.
"It is," I agreed. "Keep doing that and I'll be asleep in no time."
"You like that?" he laughed.
"Mmm hmm," I nodded into his chest. "Very comforting."
"Well, go to sleep baby," he said as he kept rubbing. "I love you."
"I love you too, Seth," I sighed.
I wasn't shocked to hear those words come out of his mouth. We'd been friends for years. And it was true, he loved me. I knew he did, and I loved him. I was so happy to be in his arms, to fall asleep in them and wake up in them in the morning. It's where I had wanted to be for a long time, and now that I'm in them, I'm not letting go.
The next morning I woke up with Seth smiling and staring me in the face. When he saw I was awake his smile got bigger.
"Good morning, beautiful. How'd you sleep?" he asked as he kissed me on the forehead.
"I slept perfectly," I said with a smile. "How'd you sleep?"
"The same," he grinned and kissed me again, this time on the lips.
"Good," I smiled and kissed him. "I hope you don't mind, but I really need to go get some clothes."
"You do, don't you?" he frowned. "Can't we lay here a little longer?" I got my phone and looked at the time. It was close to the time the rest of the superstars on the roster go out for breakfast.
"If you want to miss breakfast," I said with a shrug. "Although, I'm starving."
"Fine," he sighed. "I'll go with you."
"Oh no, mister," I said shaking my head. "You'll want shower sex and you'll hold us up."
"Oh come on!" he whined. "I won't, I promise."
"Okay, maybe I'd want it and hold us up," I sighed and rolled my eyes at myself. "Either way, we'll get held up. You take one here, I'll take one there. You can meet me at my room."
"Fine, get your robe and go," he sighed. "I'll miss you."
I laughed at him suddenly getting sappy. "I'll miss you too," I admitted.
I got up and got my robe. Seth got up and helped me into it. We kissed each other goodbye and I walked to the door to leave the room. When I left and closed the door, I ran into one of my best friends, Sasha Banks.
"Oh my god! Please don't tell me you just came out of Seth Rollins' room wearing nothing but a robe," she said to me dramatically.
"I didn't," I said to her as I flashed my bra strap.
She gasped, "Please don't tell me you spent the night with him last night. I know he's your friend and all, but come on! He has nudes all over the internet."
"We're kinda dating," I said with a slow smile. "He asked me out last night."
"Seriously?" she squeaked as we walked down the hall.
"Please don't tell me you're ashamed of me!" I begged. Sasha and I were the closest out of all the girls, we bonded over our love of K-Pop. "I love him Sasha. We've been hooking up for years now, a friends with benefits type thing, but something changed with us and we kinda fell in love with each other."
"Aww," she cooed, "really?"
I smiled, she accepted us. "Yeah! Oh Sasha, you have no idea how happy I am to be his girlfriend instead of just being his friend."
"How long have you known you loved him like that?" she asked.
"Since I broke up with that jerk I was dating last," I said quietly.
"Oh," Sasha said in recognition. "That was a bad one too."
"Yeah, and just the way Seth treated me after that one. How sweet he was that night, the way he stayed with me that whole night. And how he reminded me of how beautiful I am and that I wasn't worthless. Not to mention he brought me chocolate and flowers and champagne. He spoiled me."
Sasha laughed, "So maybe he's not as bad as I thought. Not with you at least."
"He's really great," I smiled. "Hey, I've gotta go get a shower and get dressed. You wanna come in and wait?"
"Sure, I was coming to see you anyways," she replied.
"Cool," I said as I unlocked the door and went in. "You can chill out on the couch, I'll be out in a few minutes."
I went into the bathroom and turned the shower on, adjusting it to my liking. I got my bath stuff out and took it with me as I slipped out of what I was wearing and got in the shower. It took me no time to wash my hair and bathe off.
After I was done, I got out and wrapped the towel around me and walked back into the room where Sasha was. I picked out a cropped, black tank top and holey, black skinny jeans, black underwear and black shoes.
Sasha looked at her phone as I got changed, texting her fiance, no doubt. "Cute," she said as I finished dressing.
"Thanks," I smiled. Suddenly there was a knock on the door. "I bet that's Seth," I said as I looked at her. "Can you get it? I need to put on a little bit of makeup."
"Sure," Sasha said as she jumped up and went to the door.
I went in the bathroom and to the mirror where I put on some eyeliner, mascara, and nude lipstick. While I was doing this, Seth came into the bathroom and put his arms around my waist.
"Y'don't need that," he said as he kissed me on the cheek.
"Sure I do," I said with a smile, "makes me feel pretty."
"You're pretty without it, though. Beautiful really. Actually, most beautiful girl in the world."
"You're just saying that because you love me," I giggled.
"I'm saying it because you are," he said seriously and kissed me on the back of the head.
"I love you," I sighed contently.
"I love you too," he said as he turned me around and tried to kiss me.
I ducked away, "Let the lipstick dry first."
Seth rolled his eyes and blew on my lips, "It needs to hurry up. I want to kiss my girlfriend."
Sasha laughed from the doorway. "You two are cute," she said with a smile. "You better take care of my girl, now. I don't want to have to kick your ass."
"Oh don't worry. I plan to take very good care of her," Seth said with a smile.
"I'm sure you will," Sasha smiled. "She told me how you treated her after her last break up. That was sweet."
"How much did you tell her?" Seth questioned me with narrow eyes.
"The sheer basics?" I flinched. "She knows about our whole friends with benefits thing. She just doesn't know all the dirty little details."
"Nor do I want to know them," she added.
Seth laughed, "Don't worry, we'll keep them to ourselves."
I got my phone and looked at the time. "Ya'll ready to go? Everyone should be getting ready to leave now."
"Yes! I'm starving!" Sasha said.
"Is the damn lipstick dry yet?" Seth asked, ignoring what I had just said.
"Let's see," I said as I pulled him in and kissed him sweetly. I looked at his lips as I pulled away, they were just as they were before I kissed them. "Yes," I added with a smile.
"C'mon you two," Sasha said as she pulled me and Seth by the arm and to the door.
As we were going to the elevator, we ran into Enzo and Cass. I loved those guys, they were great and the fans loved them too.
"Damn girl," Enzo said as he looked me up and down. He always liked to playfully flirt with me. "Remind me again how you're single."
"She's not," Seth said defensively. He looked like he was going to jump Enzo at any second.
"Down boy," I murmured.
"Sorry, no disrespect," Enzo said as he put his hands up. "I didn't know you two were dating."
"We just started last night," I said with a smile.
"Well, good for you guys," Cass said with a smile as he clapped Seth on his back. "She's a good girl, take care of her or we'll kick your ass."
"Thanks Cass," I said with a bright smile. "Good to know you've got my back."
"We've both got your back," Enzo added, looking like he was trying his damnedest not to piss Seth off.
"Calm down, Zo," Seth laughed. "I'm not going to kick your ass. As long as you don't flirt with my girl anymore, we're good."
"Oh thank god!" Enzo said, breathing a sigh of relief. All of us laughed.
"So how's Carmella?" I asked Cass as we all walked out of the elevator.
"She's good," Cass said. "She's loving being on the Smackdown roster, she just hates that we aren't together."
"Aww, I bet," I frowned. "It sucks ya'll got separated. Pretty much all of the couples got put on the same roster."
"You're lucky you're on the same one as Seth," Enzo said.
"We asked to be put on the same roster ahead of time," I said with a laugh. "I went to Stephanie and was like 'Look, please don't separate me and my best friends. You can separate me from one but not all of them.' Then, next thing I know, both me and Seth and Sasha are on the same show. So, I was really happy. Sucks Becky's on Smackdown though, I miss her."
"You're lucky she actually listened to you," Cass said.
"Oh, come on! They love me! Besides, they know if I would've gotten separated from Seth especially that I would've been depressed. Everyone knows how close we are."
"We all always thought you two were more brother and sister than anything," Sasha said.
"Speak for yourself," Cass said. "I always thought there was something more. Especially that night I caught her coming out of Seth's room."
"What?" I shrieked.
"Sorry, I kept it to myself, don't worry," Cass said.
"They're friends, though," Enzo said. "She can leave his room at night and it not look suspicious."
"Let me guess," I said as I looked at Cass, "I was wearing a robe?"
"Yeah," he laughed.
"I should've known someone would see me eventually," I sighed and rolled my eyes.
"Wait, are you saying you and Seth have hooked up before?" Enzo asked.
"I swear if the two of you tell a soul besides Carmella, I'll kill you," I said seriously.
"Hey, that's you two's business," Enzo said. "I don't start no drama."
"Thanks," I said as we walked into lobby where the other wrestlers were gathering. The rest of the Raw roster was there, gathering up and deciding where to eat. I chose the group going to Cracker Barrel and our whole group from the elevator decided to go.
As we made our way out to the car, Seth rushed to my side and grabbed my hand. I looked down and smiled at our joined hands. Seth squeezed my hand gently and it forced me to look up to see his smiling face. It was something I'd wanted for a long time. We've playfully held hands in the past or linked arms, but nothing like this. I felt the electricity running between us both, it felt unreal. Honestly I wanted to pinch myself to see if I was dreaming. The thing was, I didn't want to wake up.
Our group split up but promised to meet back up at the restaurant. Seth and I got into our my car. Everyone thought it would be best to leave us alone with our relationship change.
"I feel like I'm going to wake up from a dream at any minute," Seth said to me after we got in the car. "This doesn't feel real."
"It's like you were reading my mind," I said to him with a smile. "Why did we have to wait to long to confess our feelings for each other? I mean, yeah at first we were just friends. Then, the whole hookup thing started. Then, something changed, and I don't understand it at all. I'm not questioning it, don't get me wrong. I just don't get it."
"Maybe it's not something we're supposed to understand," Seth reasoned as he kissed my hand.
"Maybe it's just fate," I said with a smile as I pulled him in for a kiss.
"Maybe it is," Seth said as he pulled away and cranked the car up.
I sighed contently, "So are we going public with this? Or do you want to keep it private?"
"Oh we're going public. Broadcast it over the whole internet, I don't care. I want people to know you are mine."
"Mmm, so possessive," I said to him with a wink.
"Don't you fucking dare get me started," he said as his hands clearly tightened on the wheel. "I'll turn this damn car around and keep you locked away in that hotel room until we have to be at the arena."
"And not feed me," I asked in sarcastic shock. "What a bad boyfriend."
"Oh no, I'd feed you," he began, "although I think I'd feed myself off of you first."
"Oh fuck you," I moaned, trying to roll my eyes and not think of the heat beginning to pool between my thighs.
"I will, baby, that's a promise. Want me to show you?"
"Damn it, Rollins you are killing me," I growled. "I'm starving and horny and this is so not fair!"
Seth laughed, "Your choice baby. Although, you really should've thought before you teased me last night."
"Oh come on! I eventually gave in to you!"
"Yeah after two hours! You can't tease me like that baby."
"So this is you paying me back huh?" I said as I rolled my eyes. "That is so unfair."
"Don't get mad," Seth suddenly said in concern. "I'm just messing with you, Shel."
I crossed my arms and looked out the window, "Let's just go get something to eat. I'm not even in the mood anymore."
"Are you mad at me?" he said, a frown clearly on his face.
"No, just annoyed with you slightly," I said as I turned to look at him.
"Don't be," he begged. "I'm sorry baby. I like it when you get all frustrated, it's sexy as hell, but I hate it when you're upset like this."
"It's fine Seth," I said shaking my head.
"Your voice doesn't sound fine," he frowned.
"I'll get over it, baby," I said to him seriously. "Just drive, okay?"
"I love you," he said as he grabbed my hand and kissed it.
"I love you too," I said with a smile.
"There's that smile I love so much," he smiled back.
"Hey Seth," I said after a few moments of comfortable silence.
"Yeah?" he replied.
"After we first met, what made you want to befriend me so badly?" I asked.
"You were beautiful, you are beautiful. You just amazed me, I had to get to know you. The more I knew about you, I became addicted. Honestly, I would've asked you out back then, but you were in that relationship. So I just let it go, let us become great friends, best friends. I tried to ignore my attraction to you, then well you know what happened. Next guy that asked you out, I let it happen, let you go. You always seemed so happy with those guys, until they all heart you. Then that Jon guy came along, gah, you were so happy with him. I thought it was all over. Then, he cheated on you.
"After that, I slowly let up on suppressing my feelings until last night. But, anyways, now you know why I treated you the way I did every time someone broke up with you. I've, secretly, loved you all along."
"I feel like an idiot," I said flatly. "I've probably hurt you so much."
"No! Oh, god, no! I hurt myself. I was the dumbass who never confessed his love for you. I'm the idiot, your idiot."
I smiled, "You are, and you're all mine. The past doesn't matter anymore. All that matters is that we're together. And, we have plenty of time to make up for it all."