Potential Good Company

Dean wasn't interested in more than a one night stand with Rory, much to her devastation. Deciding not to let it destroy her, she goes back to Yale and lets loose a little by spending a night with a random guy, Colin. Things get complicated, though, when she meets his friend Logan and they fall into an awkward threesome.

PS: Takes place in season five.

PS2: Plenty of sexual situations.

PS3: Bad language (I think Paris would have a dirty mouth for one).

PS4: I came to the conclusion I don't care for Dean, so some bashing ahead.

PS5: This does eventually feature a threesome. Don't like it, don't agree with it, don't read it.

Notes:

"Words" – regular conversation

'Words' – quotes and such, thoughts too

Chapter 0001: They Never Do

Rory leaned against Dean's chest and closed her eyes. She wasn't a virgin anymore, she'd just lost her virginity to her first boyfriend, her first love, and it had felt wonderful, magical, everything a girl wishes for.

"Hey, I think I need to get back now" – he said all of a sudden. She pulled back from her daydreaming and turned to stare at him.

"What, now?"

"Yeah, I think it's best" – before she could utter a protest, he was up and searching for his clothes. She sat on the bed feeling confused and torn.

"Dean?" – he had managed to find his pants and shoes, and was holding his shirt before he turned to her.

"Yeah?"

"Are we–? What did this–?" – he laughed a little, and she was hurt at how much it sounded like a snort.

"God, you're still the same Rory, aren't you?"

"I'm sorry?" – he smiled and went over to kiss the top of her head.

"I'm not sure what you thought, but this wasn't... I mean, I'm not just going to leave Lindsay"

"No, I know" – she said quietly, looking down – "I mean, you need to... Move out and settle things and–" – he burst out laughing.

"Yeah, not that. Rory" – he sat on the bed, and she was shocked at how much his face looked just awful, not at all like the boy she'd fallen in love years prior – "What we had was great, it really was, but that's all it was, right?"

"What? Dean! I– I lost my– I was–"

"I know, and I'm kinda surprised at that, didn't think Jess– Well, anyway" – he grinned and looked quite unlike himself – "Maybe we can keep this between us, yeah?"

"But I– Wait, but you said you love me" – she whispered, a sinking feeling taking over her.

"Well, I did love you until you went behind my back with Jess"

"I never–" – she shut up, because she had cheated on him, even if she'd never told him about it.

"So, really. I'm sorry, but I love Lindsay, she's my wife, and I'm not going to leave her"

There were few times when Rory felt like her world was falling apart and there was nothing she could do to fix it, but this time took the cake. Her first love, her first, and he was– Why was he–?

"Rory!" – Lorelai screamed as she went into the house. Dean leaped from the bed and hurried to the window and, with only a look over his shoulder, he was gone.

When Lorelai walked into her daughter's bedroom feeling exhilarated and giddy and eager to share her wonderful news, what she encountered was her kid in bed, crying like she'd never seen her cry before. She rushed and sat beside her and just held her as the girl turned to cry on her shoulder, not saying a word.

I don't know where I got this, but the initial idea was that Dean was a bigger asshole than in canon, and screw it, I like Colin, and I like Logan, so yeah, this sort of formed in my head.

Chapters will be pretty short (the longest is just over 1.500 words), so I'll try to post two chapters at a time (this might change if I hit a wall and become unable to write as fast as I have - ten chapters in three days).

For future reference, the warnings and rating are not for nothing. For all that my other GG stories are pretty clean, this one turned out dirt mouthed and sexually charged. I don't know why, I don't, please don't ask me.