A/N: this started out as the chorus to a song I was working on for Naruto - basically about him realzing his mortality and the possibility of killing others as a ninja, because I just watched the Neji-Hinata fight and the episode about Haku's death. Anyway, I realized that the emotions actually worked much better for Ed, so here it is - the first installment of FMA: the Musical. It is more or less Ed singing about his feelings about his brother, his guilt over what happened, and his need to fix it. Hope it doesn't suck too much!

Disclaimer: I don't Ed, Al, or FMA. Although if you still want to send me some money, I won't say no.

Sin and Redemption

Oh the burden I bear

It cannot be shared

It's my sorrow and grief

My guilt and my tears

It's my sin

My sin

And for my sin there can be no redemption

The only thing I can do

Is make it up to you

But I don't think that means that I'm forgiven

Maybe it means we can forget

Finally move on, try to live again

Try again

Try again

But I'm still a sinner

And I'm still a fool

But you are forgiven

Because you didn't know

But I'm still a sinner

All these memories I hold

I know I should let go of the past

But sometimes I think

It's the only thing I have

And sometimes I think that all my life

Is trying to make up for what I've done

I'm always saying sorry

And you always just ignore me

I'm sorry

I'm sorry

And I almost wish that you'd be angry

I wish brotherly love didn't go so far

It'd be easier if you just said

I'll hate you forever and ever

But you're always so kind and so sure

That I have all the answers

But what if I'm not as strong

As you want me to be

I can't fail you

I can't fail our memories

I can't fail

This burden I bear

It cannot be shared

I'll go on and I'll win

But I'll remember my guilt and my grief

And my sin

My sin

My sin