Set after 4X16 Basically I was horrified about Klaus and Hayley and even more upset that Caroline never found out about it. So this is my version of what should have happened. Klaroline
Disclaimer: I do not own TVD or any of it's characters.
Caroline woke up next to Matt on a couch in the former lockwood house. She looked around heartbroken at remembering the letter Tyler had written for her. As long as Klaus was chasing him , there was no way he could come back to mystic falls meaning that they could never be together. Caroline wiped the dried tears from her eyes and slowly manoeuvred her way out of Matt's embrace; trying not to wake him up. Caroline's grief quickly turned into anger as she sped out of the lockwood house. She was about to make a night call to the original douche bag.
Caroline zipped over to the Mikaelson mansion determined to give Klaus a piece of her mind. She sped up to the front door and pounded away before her anger could diminish and she lost her nerve. After a few moments Caroline wondered what was taking him so long. Surely he had sensed her even before she banged down his door. She was about to turn away and go look for him at the grill when the door swung open revealing a shirtless Klaus. '' Hello, love.'' He smirked standing in the doorway no doubt wondering why she had come to see him in the middle of the night. Caroline looked at his very bare chest and toned stomach, nearly forgetting why she had come over in the first place. Looking him up and down she finally saw the look on his smug dimpled face as he looked at her knowingly, with that she quickly snapped out of her trance and pushed passed Klaus determinedly entering the mansion with her arms crossed over her chest.
'' I have a bone to pick with you!'' Caroline said as Klaus closed the door and turned to walk towards her.
'' A bone, sweetheart?'' Klaus said as the grin continued to widen on his face.
''Don't try and be cute with me! You're the reason Tyler's gone, you and your stupid alpha male pissing contest! Now he's gone forever and it's all your fault! He left Matt the deed to his house and said that he couldn't come back because of you! If you really fancy me as much as you say you do , then you'll let him come back.'' Caroline said as her arms unfolded and she looked to Klaus hoping that he would let Tyler come back once and for all.
''I'm sorry Sweetheart , but I can't do that.'' Klaus said walking over to the bar and pouring two glasses of scotch.
''Why not?!'' Caroline protested , very tempted to stamp her feet and pout.
''Because this is not some... pissing contest as you so eloquently put it. Tyler turned all my hybrids against me and plotted my demise numerous times. I have been awfully generous by allowing him to live. I wouldn't push my luck if I were you.'' Klaus said sipping his drink and offering the other to Caroline who stood there glaring at him with all the hate she could muster.
''That's not good enough.'' Caroline said slapping the drink from Klaus' hand.
''Caroline-.'' Klaus growled looking down at the shattered glass on the floor.
''No! It's not good enough Klaus. You can't just chase Tyler off and say that it's all okay because you've done much worse to other people, that's not that how it works.'' Caroline said standing her ground.
''Actually love, you'll find that I can.'' Klaus responded as he finished off his scotch and went to sit down on the couch next to his sketchbook.
'' Now i suggest that you leave before you force me to do something that I'll regret.'' Klaus said nonchalantly as he eyed her still standing in the same spot arms crossed across her chest.
''Please like you regret anything, that would require a heart. Which we both now you don't have.'' Caroline spat angry that he thought he could just brush off her anger like it was nothing but a child's tantrum. Klaus looked hurt by her words and got up from his position on the couch to stalk towards Caroline he eyes starting to glow yellow.
''I would regret ripping out your heart , love. But keep it up and what little feelings I have for you now might evaporate.'' Klaus said as he got closer and closer to Caroline. She backed away almost on instinct trying to distance herself from an angry Klaus.
''You wouldn't hurt me.'' Caroline stated , her voice only slightly wavering indicating her uncertainty. Klaus sped towards Caroline so that she was pressed against a wall caged in between both of his arms which rested beside her head.
'' Are you sure about that, love?'' Klaus asked as he leaned down and gently grazed Caroline's neck with human teeth , making her shiver with delight.
''Let me go Klaus'' was all Caroline could manage with his close proximity. His bare chest was a mere inch away from her own , even with her eyes closed she could feel the heat radiating between the two and she could smell his scent of spicy berries and sandalwood that would constantly haunted her every waking hour.
''Is that what you really want , sweetheart?'' Klaus asked grabbing her waist so that he fingers gently feathered over her exposed skin. Caroline felt like she couldn't breath with his hands on her , with him being this close to her. She knew that technically she didn't need to breath to survive , but her mind was telling her to run , to run far away and not look back.
''Yes.'' Caroline breathed out , almost uncertain of her answer.
''As you wish.'' Klaus said removing his hand from her waist and the other from the side of her head. Caroline all but ran out of there , but at the door she stopped. There was a familiar smell in the air that she must have over looked in her blind rage when she first came in. But finally it clicked as the veins in her face started to show and her teeth popped out . Hayley Caroline hissed she turned back around more outraged then she'd been when she first showed up.